This essay argues that the United States needs a large-scale memorial museum dedicated to the history of slavery. Drawing on Susan Sontag's observations about memory institutions, the author contends that the absence of such a museum reflects a cultural tendency toward collective forgetting. The proposed museum would use multimedia and interactive exhibits to confront visitors with the realities of the transatlantic slave trade, the plantation system, and the failures of Reconstruction. The essay further argues that slavery's legacy persists in contemporary racial and economic inequality, and that a memory museum would serve vital social, political, and educational functions by fostering a more accurate and honest national historiography.
The conspicuous absence of any significant memorial to the horrors of slavery in America signifies a collective forgetting. Americans are all too willing to brush aside the failures of Reconstruction, disavowing the connection between the plantation and the penitentiary. Reality for African Americans cannot be so easily divorced from slavery, which continues to hold Black Americans tight in its grip. Instead of participating in this collective forgetting, the nation should sponsor a large-scale memorial museum in honor of the generations of men and women whose lives were predetermined and inextricably altered by a social norm that advocated bigotry.
Susan Sontag draws an important parallel to help us understand how the lack of a slavery memorial characterizes American culture. She states that "the Holocaust Memorial Museum and the future Armenian Genocide Museum and Memorial are about events that didn't happen in America, so the memory-work runs no risk of rousing an embittered domestic population against authority." It is simply easier to forget — to blame Black Americans for their poverty and disenfranchisement, and to pretend that slavery was a thing of the past, in spite of the enduring legacy of Jim Crow. Instead of pretending, the nation should pour its heart and soul into a memory museum that draws attention to the way slavery shaped American history and culture.
A memory museum would be a multimedia and interactive experience recreating the horrors of human bondage and the plantation system. Starting with the brutal facts of the transatlantic slave trade, the museum would bring visitors face-to-face with features of the international slave trade through primary source documents describing conditions aboard human cargo ships. Moreover, legislation approving the international slave trade reveals how cruelly the founding fathers of America failed to acknowledge their own racism. The museum would show plainly that many of the heroes celebrated in history books held deeply racist views.
Because schools often gloss over the history of slavery — extolling the wonders of the Emancipation Proclamation without sufficiently condemning the failures of Reconstruction — whatever emotional content is absent from school textbooks can flourish in a memory museum. Such a museum would be far more explicit in its depictions of slave beatings and sexual violence than textbooks can be. A memorial museum would remind all Americans of the gaps in our history and help rectify the harmful effects of denial. Museums deliver far more poignant content than textbooks, making a memorial museum more memorable and ultimately more educational than what is typically delivered in public schools.
When the European nations banned international slavery, America did not follow suit, thereby distinguishing itself as a nation rich in irony and self-contradiction. America continues to be a land of contradictions — condemning the practices of other cultures while simultaneously ignoring the poverty and inequality within its own national borders. As Sontag notes, a memory museum is a politically safe institution when it addresses conflicts for which the host nation bears no responsibility. Hitler is an easy enemy; Saddam Hussein was a convenient nemesis. Drawing attention away from slavery allows Americans to feel smugly superior, as though nothing so evil could happen in the land of the free and the home of the brave.
Americans are often deluded into believing that no great evil has occurred on their own soil. A slavery museum would force Americans to take responsibility for a slave trade they perpetuated and a plantation economy from which they profited. Remembering slavery is therefore a frightening and controversial prospect for many Americans. It is far easier to point fingers at where others went wrong than to face the darkness within one's own past.
"Links slavery to modern racial and economic inequality"
"Museum would address post-slavery racism and missing history"
"Museum as tool for historical truth and social change"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.