Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,088 words

Clash of Civilizations vs. Economic Interests in the War on Terror

~6 min read 5 sections Politics · International Politics
Abstract

This paper examines two competing explanations for post-Cold War international conflict by comparing Samuel Huntington's "Clash of Civilizations" thesis with Mian Muhammad Ashraf's economic interests critique. Huntington argues that cultural and religious differences between civilizations — particularly between the West and Islam — are the primary driver of interstate conflict. Ashraf counters that economic interests are the dominant force shaping global politics. The paper applies both frameworks to America's ongoing War on Terrorism, concluding that the conflict reflects elements of both civilizational clash and economic rivalry, and argues that lasting peace requires moving beyond a purely civilizational framing of the struggle.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Post-Cold War debate and scholars introduced
  • Huntington's Civilization Thesis: Civilizational identity as primary conflict driver
  • Ashraf's Critique: Economic Interests as the Dominant Force: Economic interests supersede civilizational clash
  • The War on Terrorism: Civilization, Economics, or Both?: Both frameworks applied to the War on Terror
  • Conclusion: Policy recommendations for a balanced approach
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper clearly sets up a direct comparison between two named scholars, giving the argument a structured, debate-style clarity that is easy to follow.
  • It applies abstract theoretical frameworks (civilizational clash, economic determinism) to a concrete, high-stakes real-world case — the War on Terrorism — demonstrating analytical relevance.
  • The conclusion avoids a binary either/or resolution, instead arguing that both frameworks partially explain the conflict, which reflects nuanced critical thinking.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper exemplifies comparative theoretical analysis: it summarizes each scholar's thesis faithfully before evaluating them against empirical evidence. By using a specific policy case (the War on Terror) as the testing ground, the writer moves from theory to application — a core skill in political science and international relations essays.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with historical context (the post-Cold War debate), then dedicates one section each to Huntington and Ashraf's positions before synthesizing them in an applied analysis section. This classic "thesis A / thesis B / application" structure is well-suited to comparative essays and keeps the argument transparent and logically progressive throughout.

Essay 1,088 words

Introduction

The fall of the former Soviet Union in the early 1990s spurred debate among policymakers and intellectuals about the shape of future world politics and the role that the United States would play in it. One of the greatest early voices in this debate was Samuel Huntington, who, through his article "The Clash of Civilizations," identified differences in civilization as the greatest source of conflict in the international political system in the post-Cold War period. According to Huntington, conflicts between civilizations seeking to gain and maintain influence in a new world order are the leading source of interstate instability in the post-Cold War era. Events such as the 9/11 terrorist attacks in New York, as well as the bombings in London, Madrid, and Bali, have been interpreted by many scholars as evidence for this paradigm.

However, other scholars have come out strongly in critique of Huntington's viewpoint. One such scholar is Mian Muhammad Ashraf, a lecturer in the Political Science Department at a university in Pakistan. This paper compares the views of these two scholars within the context of America's ongoing War on Terrorism, beginning with a brief description of the positions put forward by each.

4 Sections Hidden · 800 words
Huntington's Civilization Thesis270 words
As already noted, Huntington based his view of world conflict on the clash of civilizations. In his view, the dominant source of interstate conflict in the…
Ashraf's Critique: Economic Interests as the Dominant Force210 words
Ashraf supports Huntington's view that there is a clash of civilizations, particularly between groups in the West and non-western domains. In his view, however, this is not the dominant cause of…
The War on Terrorism: Civilization, Economics, or Both?240 words
Much has been said about America's War on Terrorism and whether or not it constitutes a clash of civilizations as suggested by Huntington. Based on the theses put forth by both Huntington and Ashraf,…
Conclusion80 words
In order for the war against terrorism to be successful, western policymakers need to recognize these facts and begin viewing the war differently — not as a means of undermining Islam as a civilization or defending "our civilization" against "theirs," nor of advancing narrow economic interests. There is a need to avoid undermining either side, and to…

References

Ashraf, M. M. (2012). The clash of civilizations: A critique. Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences, 32(2), 521–527.

Dunn, M. (2006). The clash of civilizations and the war on terror. 49th Parallel, 20(1), 1–12.

Huntington, S. P. (1993). The clash of civilizations. Foreign Affairs, 72(3), 22–49.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Clash of Civilizations Economic Interests War on Terror Post-Cold War Order Western Hegemony Civilizational Identity Interstate Conflict Islam and West Regional Groupings Cultural Conflict
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Clash of Civilizations vs. Economic Interests in the War on Terror. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/clash-of-civilizations-war-on-terror-2159090

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.