Colonialism in The Tempest and Season of Migration to the North
This essay examines how colonialism is represented in William Shakespeare's The Tempest and Tayeb Salih's Season of Migration to the North, two texts that approach the colonizer–colonized relationship from different historical moments and perspectives. Through close readings of Caliban's dehumanization by Prospero and Mustafa Sa'eed's deliberate embodiment of colonial stereotypes, the essay argues that Salih's novel inverts the colonialist fears expressed in Shakespeare's play in order to challenge rather than reinforce them. Drawing on critical responses by Paul Cefalu and Patricia Geesey, the essay also considers economic and cultural-hybrid interpretations of both texts, ultimately showing how Sa'eed's self-destructive enactment of stereotype functions as an anticolonialist act.
- Introduction: Two Texts, Two Sides of Colonialism: Thesis framing both texts within colonial discourse
- Caliban and the Logic of Colonial Stereotyping in The Tempest: Caliban as dehumanized colonized figure under Prospero
- Mustafa Sa'eed and the Inversion of Colonial Fear in Season of Migration to the North: Sa'eed enacts colonial stereotypes to challenge them
- Critical Perspectives: Cefalu and the Economics of Colonialism: Economic readings of colonial power in The Tempest
- Geesey's Cultural Hybridity and Its Limits: Critique of Geesey's cultural hybrid interpretation of Sa'eed
- Conclusion: Stereotype as Weapon and Its Failure: Comparing how each text deploys and subverts stereotypes
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay sustains a clear comparative argument across two literary works, moving fluidly between close textual evidence and broader thematic claims about colonialism.
- It engages secondary criticism (Cefalu and Geesey) not merely to summarize but to test and refine its own interpretation, including a pointed rebuttal of Geesey's reading.
- The distinction between character and novel — that Sa'eed's stereotyping is not the same as the novel endorsing those stereotypes — demonstrates nuanced literary analysis.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative literary analysis anchored in close reading. By quoting directly from both primary texts and pairing those quotations with critical commentary, the author shows how individual scenes (Prospero's accusation, Sa'eed's seduction of Isabella Seymour) carry the weight of larger colonial ideologies. The rebuttal of Geesey exemplifies how to engage critically with scholarship rather than simply citing it in support.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a thesis framing both texts in relation to colonialism, then moves through textual analysis of The Tempest (focusing on Caliban), followed by analysis of Season of Migration to the North (focusing on Sa'eed). Two critical readings are introduced and evaluated before a synthesis section distinguishes how each text uses colonial stereotypes for opposite purposes. The conclusion consolidates the comparative argument.
Both William Shakespeare's play The Tempest and Tayeb Salih's novel Season of Migration to the North deal with the cultural tensions arising as a result of colonialism, albeit in different historical moments and from different sides of the colonizer–colonized relationship. Whereas The Tempest deals with the European reaction to the colonization of the then-New World and follows a European protagonist confronting a demonized other, Season of Migration to the North follows two protagonists' mirrored experiences returning to Sudan from their time in England, and their difficulties integrating Sudanese and English cultural identities. The two texts offer a way of understanding not only the varied reactions to colonialism and its consequences, but also how those reactions have been received and interpreted by a critical audience.
By examining The Tempest and Season of Migration to the North alongside critical responses to these texts, it becomes possible to see how Salih's novel uses the colonizer's fears of retribution — as expressed in Shakespeare's play — as a way of considering the trauma of colonization and actively combating the cultural stereotypes deployed in the name of colonialism.
Before considering the broader ramifications of either text's treatment of colonialism, it will be useful to examine each text for those moments in which colonialism becomes most relevant and its consequences are felt most explicitly.
In The Tempest, the character of Caliban is most commonly the focus of any investigation into the play's consideration of colonialism, and a look at his backstory as well as his relationship to the protagonist Prospero reveals why.
By the time Prospero and his daughter Miranda are exiled to the island that serves as the play's setting, Caliban has already been living there for some time. His mother, Sycorax, was banished "for mischiefs manifold and sorceries terrible / To enter human hearing, from Argier," and "left by the sailors" on the island while she was pregnant with Caliban (Shakespeare 1.2.264–265, 270). Immediately, Caliban's character is identified with the effects of colonialism: his mother is banished from her home in Africa for practicing ill-defined "mischiefs manifold and sorceries" too terrible to enter "human" hearing — and in this context, as Prospero is the speaker, "human" effectively means "European." This distinction between the "human" Europeans and the inhuman other is repeated when Prospero describes Caliban's birth, calling him "A freckled whelp hag-born — not honour'd with / A human shape" (Shakespeare 1.2.283–284). Prospero's treatment of Caliban conforms to many of the stereotypes relied upon by colonizers to justify their inhumane treatment of colonized peoples, and the relationship between Prospero and Caliban closely mirrors the interactions between early English settlers in America and Native Americans.
When Caliban is first introduced, he recounts that he and Prospero initially had a mutually beneficial relationship: "When thou camest first / Thou strokedst me and madest much of me, wouldst give me / Water with berries in't, and teach me how / To name the bigger light, and how the less / That burn by day and night: and then I loved thee / And show'd thee all the qualities o' the isle / The fresh springs, brine-pits, barren place and fertile" (Shakespeare 1.2.332–338). This account hews closely to the favored colonialist narrative of "civilizing" the inhabitants of conquered lands, with the "animalistic" native gratefully showing his colonial master the workings of the New World of the island. Prospero belabors this point, telling Caliban: "I pitied thee / Took pains to make thee speak, taught thee each hour / One thing or other: when thou didst not, savage / Know thine own meaning, but wouldst gabble like / A thing most brutish, I endow'd thy purposes / With words that made them known." Yet Prospero eventually finds fault with Caliban, claiming that "But thy vile race / Though thou didst learn, had that in't which good natures / Could not abide to be with" (Shakespeare 1.2.353–360). That Prospero locates this fault in Caliban's "vile race" rather than his individual character reveals Prospero's unabashed bigotry, and thus casts doubt on the veracity of his claims regarding Caliban's moral deficiencies.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.