Complex Characters in Their Eyes Were Watching God
This paper analyzes the complex characters in Zora Neale Hurston's 1937 novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, a landmark of the Harlem Renaissance. The essay argues that Hurston creates complexity through characters with conflicting motivations, evolving traits, and shifting emotional states. Focusing on protagonist Janie Crawford's journey from submission to self-determination, as well as the multifaceted portrayals of her husbands Joe Starks and Tea Cake, the paper demonstrates how each character defies simple categorization. The analysis also briefly addresses counterarguments regarding flat characters such as Nanny, ultimately affirming that the novel's major figures exhibit genuine psychological depth.
- Introduction: Character Complexity in Hurston's Novel: Thesis on complex characters in Hurston's novel
- Janie Crawford: Growth and Self-Discovery: Janie's journey from submission to self-identity
- Joe Starks: Ambition and Self-Contradiction: Joe's charisma versus controlling ambition
- Tea Cake: Love, Jealousy, and Complexity: Tea Cake's shifting traits across the marriage
- Counterargument and Rebuttal: Addressing claims of flat characterization
- Conclusion: Restatement of Hurston's complex character craft
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay maintains a clear, consistent thesis — that Hurston creates complexity through conflicting motivations, character change, and emotional range — and returns to it when analyzing each character.
- It moves logically through three major characters (Janie, Joe Starks, Tea Cake), giving each dedicated analysis rather than mixing them together, which keeps the argument organized and readable.
- The paper acknowledges and rebuts a counterargument (that some characters are flat), which strengthens the overall claim by showing awareness of alternative interpretations.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates textual evidence integration: it grounds character claims in direct quotations from the novel and supports broader assertions with scholarly secondary sources. This combination of primary and secondary evidence is a foundational technique in literary analysis essays at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a brief introduction to character analysis and the novel, followed by a focused analysis of Janie Crawford's arc across her three marriages. It then examines Joe Starks and Tea Cake as individually complex figures. A short counterargument paragraph addresses the claim that some characters are flat, before a concise conclusion restates the thesis and its broader relevance to literature.
Introduction: Character Complexity in Hurston's Novel
In literature, authors use different characters to tell a story, and these characters have diverse traits depending on the context the author aims to elicit. Character analysis is an essential part of understanding literature, as it allows readers to interweave themes. Their Eyes Were Watching God is a novel by Zora Neale Hurston, first published in 1937. The book is a classic frequently referred to as a landmark of the Harlem Renaissance. It revolves around the main character Janie Crawford as she grows from a naïve teenage girl into a woman in control of her own destiny. The novel explores several themes, including gender roles, race, masculinity, feminism, and women's liberation. Hurston successfully creates complex characters in Their Eyes Were Watching God by giving them conflicting motivations, subjecting them to extensive changes as the plot progresses, and portraying them experiencing a wide range of emotions.
Janie Crawford: Growth and Self-Discovery
Janie Crawford is the main protagonist of the novel, and she is presented as a complex character. The most defining dimension of her complexity is her progressive growth from being subjugated to male dominance to becoming the subject of her own narrative, as she finds enlightenment, fulfilling love, and self-identity. Her dynamic self-growth is a clear example of what makes a character genuinely complex.
As a woman of mixed ethnicity, Crawford is the novel's central figure — full of beauty and vibrancy. Since childhood, she experienced the harmony of life and its creations in the blossoms of a pear tree. Just as a pear tree grows, it symbolizes her passions and dreams as she searches for the meaning of life (Washington & Mary Helen, pp. 9–23). The theme of gender roles powerfully resonates with her marriage experiences. Janie Crawford was married to her first husband when she was just sixteen years old. During this first marriage, she is naïve and feels like little more than property to her husband. She senses she has no real value to him — he isolates and belittles her existence — and she struggles to find contentment in the relationship.
Janie finally finds the true love she has always yearned for when she marries Tea Cake. Tea Cake and Janie have a mutually respectful relationship in which she feels genuinely desired. Through this relationship, Janie is able to develop her own voice and discover her self-awareness. Unlike in her previous marriages, she chooses to be silent when she wants to — out of her own will and not out of submission. When Janie's neighbors begin questioning her sudden reappearance in town — "What she doin' coming back here in dem overhalls? Can't she find no dress to put on?" — she does not bother to explain herself, demonstrating her independence and self-worth.
Joe Starks: Ambition and Self-Contradiction
Joe Starks is Janie's second husband, and he too is presented as a complex character due to his multifaceted nature and self-conflicting motivations. At first, he appears as a charismatic figure with ambitious plans for his future. Joe convinces Janie to leave Logan and come with him to Eatonville, and Janie, young and inexperienced, is easily swayed by his confidence.
Joe is characterized as a strong, organized man determined to make a name for himself in an African American town. However, his desire to be with Janie is not rooted in love; rather, he wants a woman he can display as a trophy. His charisma conflicts with other traits — overambition, poor communication, and intense jealousy toward Janie. This internal conflict is what makes his character complex. From the outset of the story, he craves significance in society, yet he takes this drive too far, silencing his wife and others: "She's uh woman and her place are in de home." His authoritative nature eventually takes its toll as he ages, and his body ultimately shuts down.
Conclusion
Hurston effectively creates complex characters in Their Eyes Were Watching God through conflicting motivations, dissenting character traits, and changing perceptions. Janie Crawford's journey from submission to self-determination, Joe Starks's self-defeating ambition, and Tea Cake's oscillation between tenderness and jealousy all illustrate this depth. Creating complex literary characters is valuable in modern literature because it illustrates conflicts more vividly and generates richer, more nuanced narratives.
Works Cited
Washington, Mary Helen. "I Love the Way Janie Crawford Left Her Husbands: Zora Neale Hurston's Emergent Female Hero." Bloom's Modern Critical Interpretations: Their Eyes Were Watching God (2008): 9–23.
Daniel, Janice. "'De understandin' to Go'long Wid It': Realism and Romance in 'Their Eyes Were Watching God.'" The Southern Literary Journal 24.1 (1991): 66–76.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.