Contraception, Christianity, and Catholic Church Teaching
This paper examines the Roman Catholic Church's theological position on contraception, drawing on Pope Paul VI's 1968 encyclical Humanae Vitae, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, and statements by American bishops. It traces the Church's understanding of marriage as a sacred covenant ordained by God for companionship, procreation, and mutual self-giving. The paper discusses the virtues of chastity and temperance, the Church's approval of natural family planning, and its condemnation of artificial contraception as intrinsically evil. It also addresses the contemporary debate surrounding the Church's ban on condoms in the context of the global AIDS epidemic, presenting arguments from both Church officials and critics.
- Introduction: Humanae Vitae and the Catholic Position on Contraception: Humanae Vitae and bishops' opposition to artificial contraception
- Marriage in Scripture and Christian Tradition: Biblical foundations of marriage, sexuality, and procreation
- Chastity, Temperance, and the Conjugal Vocation: Chastity and temperance as Catholic virtues for all Christians
- The Sacrament of Matrimony and the Purpose of Sexuality: Marriage as sacrament and sexuality ordered toward love and life
- Regulation of Procreation and Natural Family Planning: Natural family planning approved; artificial contraception condemned
- Contraception, AIDS, and the Condom Debate: Church condom ban challenged amid global AIDS epidemic
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper draws on a range of authoritative primary and secondary sources — including the Catechism of the Catholic Church, Humanae Vitae, and statements by bishops — giving its claims institutional grounding.
- It moves logically from broad theological foundations (the nature of marriage in Scripture) to specific doctrinal positions (natural family planning, the ban on contraception) and then to a contemporary policy controversy (condoms and AIDS), creating a coherent narrative arc.
- The paper presents both the Church's official position and the voices of critics and dissenting commentators, giving readers a balanced picture of the ongoing debate.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of institutional and doctrinal sources to construct a theological argument. Rather than relying on personal opinion, it anchors every claim in an identifiable authority — a papal encyclical, the Catechism, a bishop's statement — and consistently attributes positions to named sources. This models responsible use of primary religious documents alongside journalistic and editorial commentary.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with the 1968 Humanae Vitae encyclical and American bishops' responses, establishing the policy context. It then grounds the discussion in Scripture and the Catechism of the Catholic Church, covering marriage, sexuality, chastity, and the sacrament of matrimony. Following sections address the Church's teaching on regulating procreation and its rejection of artificial contraception. The paper closes with the contemporary AIDS and condom controversy, presenting multiple perspectives before ending on an unresolved tension within Church teaching.
Introduction: Humanae Vitae and the Catholic Position on Contraception
Pope Paul VI's 1968 encyclical, Humanae Vitae ("On Human Life"), condemned the use of all artificial means of contraception as a sin and called on all Roman Catholics to reject the contraceptive mentality (Feuerherd 2003). It instead taught Catholic couples to use natural family planning methods to regulate the size of their families. The Catholic Pro-life Bishops' Committee subsequently sought to produce a brochure explaining this "culture of life" in a more positive and appealing way to Catholic couples. Committee Chairman Charles Chaput admitted that an overwhelming majority of Catholic couples use contraceptive means to limit their families despite knowing the Church's position and teaching. Chaput emphasized the need to foster a fuller understanding of the teaching itself. Bishop Joseph Galante believed that the positive values of natural family planning must be reinforced for greater unity between husband and wife and for their growth in grace in keeping with God's plan. The bishops envisioned that the effort would encourage Catholic couples to be true to their "vocation of marriage" (Feuerherd).
In a separate meeting, American Catholic bishops restated and tightened the Church's opposition to contraception (Reference and Education 2003). One bishop called contraception a "silent killer." Most statistics showed that Catholics use artificial birth control at the same rate as non-Catholics. Bishop John Nienstedt of Ulm, Minnesota urged parishioners to heed what the Church teaches. He noted that high school and college students felt it was their basic human right to express themselves as they felt or desired (Reference and Education).
Marriage in Scripture and Christian Tradition
The Holy Bible points to marriage as the first human relationship (Mueller, ed., 2001, p. 436). God Himself established it as the cornerstone of society and meant it to be a blessing to humankind. It was His response to the first man's need for a suitable companion in his aloneness. God intended it to be the closest and most intimate human relationship. In this union, the bodies of the partners would belong to each other. They were joined together for a lifelong commitment — to be a source of joy and fidelity to each other (Mueller).
From the beginning of creation, marriage was to be a union of sexual beings who would multiply and reproduce (Mueller, ed., 2001, p. 442). Before the fall of man, God delighted in His creation, which included this sexual union, and saw that it was "very good." After the fall, there have been both proper and improper uses of this gift of human sexuality, but God's purpose and attitude toward it have not changed and cannot change. The New Testament instructs Christians to give their spouses their conjugal rights and not to deprive them of these, except for brief periods. A married Christian's body rightfully belongs to his or her spouse. The Holy Bible also clearly confines the use of that gift within the vocation of marriage (p. 443). Those who are not married to each other are not free to exercise it; doing so constitutes fornication or adultery. This also expressly means that an unmarried Christian must avoid sexual relations with anyone.
God also called a husband and his wife to an intimate relationship and shared life that can bring them joy and be a blessing to them both. This was to be their commitment, even at the point of sacrifice. They were to submit to each other in reverence for all their lives, performing different roles — roles that would be difficult to fulfill apart from God's grace. Only in God's grace can marriage be strong and full of His love and forgiveness (Mueller).
Chastity, Temperance, and the Conjugal Vocation
The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that God created the human race in His own image and likeness (the Vatican 2007). In the humanity of man and woman, God inscribed the vocation of marriage and the accompanying capacity and responsibility of love and communion. He commanded His first creatures to be fruitful and to multiply. Sexuality affects all aspects of a human person — affectivity, the capacity to love, and the capacity to procreate. God gave both man and woman equal personal dignity in creating them in His image and likeness, and they are to view each other accordingly. The Roman Catholic Church views and teaches that a couple's union in marriage is a way of imitating the Creator's generosity and fruitfulness. It was to be a permanent union until death (the Vatican).
Every Christian or Catholic must be chaste. Chastity integrates sexuality within the entire person so that there is inner unity of body and spirit, along with self-mastery. Self-mastery trains a person in human freedom. Through it, one is able to govern passions and find peace, rather than allowing passions to dominate and lead to unhappiness. Human dignity calls each person to act out of conscious and free choice from within, not through blind impulses or external constraint. Guided by this, a person is able to secure the means best suited to his or her goal. Chastity develops from the cardinal virtue of temperance, which controls the passions and appetites with reason. Self-mastery cannot be developed overnight; it comes as a result of perseverance beginning from childhood and adolescence.
Chastity and temperance are virtues for every Christian or Catholic, married or not. The unmarried Christian needs them to remain apart from sexual activity. The married Christian needs them in deciding when and how to exercise the gift of sex. Married couples are called to live conjugal chastity or continence. The Catholic Church teaches that those who are engaged to be married must also live in continence, viewing this period as a time of testing for mutual respect and fidelity, and reserving intimate expressions of affection for the state of marriage (the Vatican).
Bibliography
Bruce, Iain S. "AIDS and Condoms: The Issue Splitting the Roman Catholic Church." The Sunday Herald: Newsquest Media Group, May 7, 2006.
Feuerherd, Joe. "Roman Catholic Church's Position on Contraception." National Catholic Reporter, November 21, 2003.
Mueller, Steven P., ed. Called to Believe, Teach and Confess. English Standard Version. Crossway Bible, 2001.
Reference and Education. "Bishops Move to Tighten Adherence to Church Teaching Against Contraception and Legal Recognition of Same-Sex Unions." Christian Century: The Christian Century Foundation, November 23, 2003.
The Vatican. Catechism of the Catholic Church. Part Three: Life in Christ. The Vatican Library: the Holy See, 2007.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.