Criminal Investigation Methods, Mindset, and Information Sources
This paper provides an overview of core principles in criminal investigation, drawing on foundational texts in the field. It examines the two primary inquiry methods — interviews and interrogations — and distinguishes their purposes, atmospheres, and legal contexts. The paper then outlines the optimal mindset an investigator must maintain, emphasizing objectivity, confidence, and self-control. It further explains how the scientific method is partially applied to criminal investigations, from problem identification and hypothesis formation through evidence collection and conclusion. Finally, the paper identifies three major categories of information sources available to investigators: people, physical evidence, and records.
- Introduction: Overview of topics covered in the paper
- Inquiry Methods in Criminal Investigation: Distinguishing interviews from interrogations in investigations
- An Investigator's Optimal Mindset: Objectivity, confidence, and self-control for investigators
- The Scientific Method Applied to Criminal Investigations: How hypothesis and evidence apply to criminal cases
- Primary Sources of Information: People, physical evidence, and records as information sources
- Conclusion: Importance of accurate and relevant information
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Consistently grounds every claim in cited sources, maintaining academic credibility throughout a relatively brief paper.
- Uses concrete, hypothetical examples (e.g., tire impressions, toll call records) to translate abstract principles into practical illustration.
- Maintains clear parallel structure across sections: each topic is defined, contextualized, and illustrated before moving on.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective integration of multiple textbook sources within a single coherent argument. Rather than summarizing one author at a time, the writer synthesizes Palmiotto, Hess and Orthmann, Becker and Dutelle, and Osterburg and Ward across thematic sections, using each source where it carries the most authority. This selective citation approach strengthens credibility without making the paper feel like a simple list of quotations.
Structure breakdown
The paper follows a clear four-part thematic structure after a brief introduction: (1) inquiry methods (interview vs. interrogation), (2) investigator mindset, (3) application of the scientific method, and (4) primary information sources. Each section is headed, self-contained, and roughly equal in depth. A short conclusion synthesizes a key cautionary note about information quality. This structure suits an overview or survey paper at the undergraduate level.
Introduction
This paper addresses a number of issues related to criminal investigations. It examines various criminal investigation inquiry methods and discusses an investigator's optimal mindset. In addition, it highlights the scientific method and how investigators apply it in criminal investigations, and identifies the major sources of information available to criminal investigators.
Inquiry Methods in Criminal Investigation
According to Palmiotto (2004), "investigative authorities estimate that approximately 95% of crimes are cleared through interviews and interrogations." The relevance of these two basic methods of inquiry cannot be overstated in the context of criminal investigation. An interview can be defined as "a purposeful and planned conversation between an interviewer and interviewee to collect data pertaining to an investigation or to substantiate physical evidence" (Palmiotto, 2004). Within the context of criminal investigation, an interview seeks to gather crime details while advancing the investigation. It is, however, non-custodial. Conducted in a more cordial atmosphere than an interrogation, an interview provides an investigator with an opportunity to gather relevant information from victims as well as witnesses. It is important to note that interviews can be conducted at any stage of the investigative process.
When it comes to interrogation, Palmiotto (2004) holds that, unlike an interview, it is adversarial in nature. An interrogation, according to Kenney and More (as cited in Palmiotto, 2004), is "a systematic questioning in a formal situation where the subject is resistant or unwilling to participate." The individual being subjected to an interrogation would most likely want to conceal information from the investigator. It is for this reason that an interrogation is conducted in an adversarial atmosphere — the interrogation room — where the interrogator possesses a certain psychological advantage over the suspect. Unlike an interview, an interrogation is custodial.
References
Becker, R. F., & Dutelle, A. W. (2012). Criminal investigation (4th ed.). Jones and Bartlett Publishers.
Hess, K. M., & Orthmann, C. H. (2009). Criminal investigation (9th ed.). Cengage Learning.
Osterburg, J. W., & Ward, R. H. (2010). Criminal investigation: A method for reconstructing the past (6th ed.). Matthew Bender & Company, Inc.
Palmiotto, M. (2004). Criminal investigation (3rd ed.). University Press of America.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.