This paper examines criminal profiling as an investigative tool, tracing its origins from Dr. James Brussel's landmark 1950s work identifying New York's "Mad Bomber" to the modern methods developed by FBI agent John Douglas and independent profiler Pat Brown. The paper explains how profilers analyze crime scene evidence, behavioral patterns, and psychological characteristics to build offender sketches. It also addresses the limitations of trait-based profiling models, citing skeptical research that cautions against sole reliance on profiling. The paper concludes that criminal profiling, when used alongside traditional investigative methods, remains a valuable but imperfect tool in law enforcement.
The role of a criminal profiler is to create a personality or character sketch of the individual responsible for committing an offense or crime. As Tammy Clevenger explains in the article "What is a Criminal Profiler?", criminal profiling — also known as offender profiling, criminal personality profiling, criminal investigative analysis, criminological profiling, and behavioral profiling — should not be confused with psychological profiling. The FBI's specific term for the practice is "criminal investigative analysis" (Clevenger, ¶2).
The first officially recognized use of criminal profiling was performed in the 1950s by Dr. James Brussel, who used profiling to determine the identity of the "Mad Bomber of New York City" as George Metesky (Clevenger, Recent History Section, ¶1). Dr. Brussel was trained in psychiatry and criminology and served as the acting Assistant Commissioner of New York State's Commission for Mental Hygiene.
Robert Finn wrote about Dr. Brussel's original "portrait," or criminal profile, in the article "Criminal Profiler Shares Some Secrets of the Trade." Dr. Brussel predicted that the bomber would be suffering from paranoia, would be a loner with no friends, precise, neat, and tidy, heavyset, Catholic, and foreign-born. Dr. Brussel added, "When apprehended, the bomber would be wearing a double-breasted suit, fully buttoned," and that he was unmarried, possibly living with an older female relative in Connecticut (Finn, ¶2). Every element of the profile proved correct when authorities apprehended Metesky.
John Douglas, former head of the FBI's Investigative Support Unit, is responsible for much of the foundational research on known serial killers, gathered through interviews and studies of criminals such as Charles Manson, Sirhan Sirhan, Richard Speck, John Wayne Gacy, David Berkowitz (Son of Sam), and James Earl Ray (Inside the Mind, ¶2). The goal of this research was to understand the motives and the mindset of serial killers.
According to the article "Inside the Mind of the Mind Hunter: An Interview with Legendary FBI Agent John Douglas," the following was said of Douglas: "He identifies with both predator and prey. He examines a crime scene and creates profiles of the perpetrators, describing their habits and predicting their next moves. He is a renowned figure in law enforcement and the model for the Scott Glenn character in the movie The Silence of the Lambs" (Inside the Mind, ¶3). Douglas introduced the world to a powerful new tool for analyzing and identifying the personality of the criminal.
Another internationally known profiler, Pat Brown, began her career by studying sex offenders, serial criminals, abnormal psychology, investigative methodology, and law enforcement — skills she went on to apply in real-life cases with great success. Brown states, "Real profiling is a thorough analysis of physical and behavioral evidence at the crime scene, which enables the profiler to develop specifics related to one particular case or set of cases" (World-Renowned Criminal Profiler, ¶2). A profiler must begin by analyzing the pieces of evidence from the crime scene and, especially in cases involving serial criminals, determine the patterns, methods, and techniques used by the individual (Profiling Criminals, ¶11). Interviews with witnesses are also used in establishing the profile.
"Brown's definition and dynamic profiling methodology"
"Evidence and characteristics profilers use to build sketches"
"Skeptical research on trait-based profiling flaws"
When used as an additional tool alongside traditional police methods, criminal profiling can be a proven technique in the resolution of many crimes. Criminal profiling will never be an exact science, but it remains a very useful investigative technique.
You’re 60% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.