Criminal Justice Reform and Bail Reform in America
This paper argues that the United States criminal justice system requires significant reform, with particular attention to the cash bail system. Drawing on statistics from the ACLU and the Drug Policy Alliance, the paper demonstrates the disproportionate impact of unaffordable bail on low-income defendants, noting that 70% of incarcerated individuals are held simply because they cannot pay bail. The paper outlines the pretrial and arraignment process step by step, discusses national and grassroots advocacy organizations working toward reform, and highlights New Jersey as a model of successful bail reform, where the pretrial prison population declined nearly by half within three years of policy changes.
- Introduction: The Scale of U.S. Incarceration: U.S. mass incarceration and unaffordable bail statistics
- Advocacy Organizations Pushing for Reform: National and grassroots groups driving justice reform
- New Jersey Bail Reform: A Model for Progress: New Jersey data showing bail reform outcomes
- The Arrest and Booking Process: Steps from arrest through prosecutorial review
- Arraignment and Plea Options: Guilty, not guilty, and nolo contendere pleas explained
- The Pretrial Process: Step by Step: Six-stage pretrial process including plea bargains
- Conclusion: Call for continued criminal justice reform
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds its reform argument in concrete, sourced statistics — U.S. share of global prison population, average bail cost, and New Jersey outcome data — giving the argument an empirical foundation rather than relying on opinion alone.
- Balances macro-level critique (mass incarceration, systemic racism) with granular procedural explanation (booking, arraignment, discovery, plea bargaining), making the paper accessible to readers unfamiliar with the legal process.
- Uses a real-world policy example (New Jersey) to demonstrate that reform is practically achievable, strengthening the persuasive case for broader change.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates problem-solution structuring: it opens by establishing the severity of the problem with statistics, identifies organized responses (advocacy groups), models a successful solution (New Jersey), and then explains the procedural mechanics the solution addresses. This structure is effective for policy-oriented academic writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a statistical indictment of U.S. incarceration and cash bail, then surveys national and grassroots advocacy organizations. It pivots to New Jersey's measurable outcomes, followed by a detailed walkthrough of the pretrial process — arrest, booking, bail, arraignment, plea bargaining, and preliminary hearing. The conclusion synthesizes the reform argument and calls for continued action.
Introduction: The Scale of U.S. Incarceration
When it comes to incarceration, the United States has the worst record in the world. The U.S. represents only 4.4% of the global population yet accounts for 22% of the entire planet's prison population. For every 100,000 people in the U.S., 716 will be incarcerated. Moreover, 70% of those in prison are held simply because they cannot afford to pay bail (ACLU, 2019). Since most Americans live paycheck to paycheck, it is not surprising that anyone accused of a crime is unlikely to be able to post the average bail amount, which in the U.S. is $11,000 (ACLU, 2019). For these reasons, there is a pressing need to establish both criminal justice reform and bail reform across the United States.
The American carceral system has been compared to the Soviet Gulag: people lose their entire lives once they disappear into the system, where they effectively become slave laborers for corporations, working for pennies on the dollar while incarcerated (Pelaez, 2019).
Advocacy Organizations Pushing for Reform
Several advocacy groups support bail and criminal justice reform. The Sentencing Project is a Washington, D.C.-based national reform organization that focuses on racism in the justice system and reducing the prison population. The Marshall Project is composed of journalists seeking to shed light on a justice system that lacks transparency. Grassroots organizations such as the St. Louis Action Committee and the Arch City Defenders work alongside national organizations to reform the justice system (Ziegelheim, 2018). These groups collectively represent a growing movement demanding accountability and structural change in how the U.S. handles pretrial detention and criminal prosecution.
New Jersey Bail Reform: A Model for Progress
Bail reform statistics from New Jersey show meaningful signs of progress. According to the Drug Policy Alliance (2019), the state's pretrial prison population declined by nearly half over three years, meaning fewer people sit in jail while awaiting trial and are instead able to return to their lives. Less than 1% of those arrested were required to post money bail, and nine out of every ten people arrested in New Jersey are now released from custody within 24 hours of arrest. Only 1% of those arrested remain in custody for more than two days (Drug Policy Alliance, 2019). These figures demonstrate that structural reform is not only possible but measurably effective.
The Arrest and Booking Process
The arrest process begins with a suspect being taken into custody. Police search the individual for contraband, after which the person is booked. If the person is not formally booked but is detained for several hours, their attorney may petition a judge for a writ of habeas corpus — a court order directing law enforcement to bring the detainee before a judge to verify that the arrest is lawful.
Once booked, the individual waits for the case to be reviewed by a prosecutor, who determines what charges should be filed. Typically, the prosecutor must file charges within two to three days of arrest. The arraignment then follows as the next formal step in the process.
During the discovery phase, once a trial is underway, both the prosecution and the defense exchange information relevant to the case. The discovery process allows the defense to understand what evidence the prosecutor holds, while the prosecutor may interview witnesses and build their case. Participation in discovery is mandatory so that a fair trial can proceed.
Conclusion
The justice system needs to be reformed, and the reforms seen in New Jersey have helped to restore arrestees' rights. However, more reform is needed, as the many advocacy groups across the country are demonstrating. These organizations are shining a light on the justice system, helping people obtain bail and return to their daily lives. They are also emphasizing that the pretrial process is being used to manipulate the trial process itself — using fear tactics and pressure to prevent defendants from exercising their right to a fair trial. Continued advocacy and legislative action are essential to build on the progress already achieved.
References
ACLU. (2019). ACLU lawsuit goes after $2 billion bail industry that profits off poor people. Retrieved from https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/aclu-lawsuit-goes-after-2-billion-bail-industry-profits-poor-people
Drug Policy Alliance. (2019). New Jersey Judiciary releases annual bail reform report, with additional key statistics. Retrieved from
Pelaez, V. (2019). The prison industry in the United States: Big business or a new form of slavery? Retrieved from https://www.globalresearch.ca/the-prison-industry-in-the-united-states-big-business-or-a-new-form-of-slavery/8289
Ziegelheim, D. (2018). Grassroots organizations are leading the way on criminal justice reform. Retrieved from https://psmag.com/social-justice/the-grassroots-organizations-leading-criminal-justice-reform
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.