Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 2,446 words

Racism and Discrimination in Criminal Justice Reform

~13 min read 5 sections Social Issues · Racial Discrimination
Abstract

This paper analyzes how racism and discrimination pervade the American criminal justice system and obstruct meaningful reform. Focusing on three interconnected areas—bail reform, white collar versus blue collar crime prosecution, and policing and defense—the paper argues that systemic bias shapes who is incarcerated, who is prosecuted, and how effectively individuals are represented before the law. Drawing on scholarship by Davis, Pettit and Western, Hehman et al., and others, the paper critiques the $2 billion bail industry, the underenforcement of white collar crime, implicit jury bias, ineffective defense counsel, and discriminatory policing cultures. It concludes that reform efforts will fail unless discrimination and racism are explicitly addressed at every level of the criminal justice system.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Thesis: racism pervades criminal justice reform efforts
  • Bail Reform: Bail industry profits from poverty; reform risks public safety
  • White Collar vs. Blue Collar Crime: Racial bias shapes prosecution and jury decisions
  • Policing and Defense: Community policing and defense misconduct need reform
  • Conclusion: Discrimination must anchor all criminal justice reform
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • Organizes a broad critique of the criminal justice system around three clearly defined focal points—bail reform, white collar crime, and policing—giving the argument a coherent and navigable structure.
  • Balances empirical evidence (e.g., ACLU statistics on pretrial detention, Pettit and Western's incarceration data) with policy recommendations, grounding normative claims in factual support.
  • Introduces nuance by acknowledging that reform itself can produce unintended harms—such as the rise in crime following New York City's bail changes—demonstrating critical thinking beyond simple advocacy.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper effectively uses comparative analysis to link distinct phenomena—bail policy, white collar prosecution rates, and jury behavior—under the unifying lens of systemic discrimination. By drawing on sources across sociology, criminology, and legal studies, it shows how disparate elements of the criminal justice system reinforce one another, strengthening the overall argument.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with an introduction establishing the central thesis and scope. Three body sections then address bail reform, white collar versus blue collar crime, and policing and defense in turn, each ending with a policy recommendation. A brief conclusion synthesizes the argument and reaffirms that discrimination must be the central focus of any reform agenda. References follow in APA format.

Essay 2,446 words

Introduction

Racism, discrimination, prejudice, and bias are inherent factors in the criminal justice system, as has been shown by researchers and activists alike (Davis, 2000; Hehman, Flake & Calanchini, 2018; Pettit & Western, 2004; Tate & Page, 2018). While reform has been attempted in parts of the country—such as New York City's recently enacted bail reform—there are still fundamental issues that must be addressed, particularly with respect to bail reform, white collar crime, and policing. This paper addresses issues in policy and governance related to homeland security measures with regard to criminal justice reform through the three-pronged focal point of bail reform, white collar crime, and policing and defense.

Bail Reform

In the 1990s, the dominant attitude in criminal justice was for America to get tough on crime. This was pursued particularly aggressively in New York City, where the Three Strikes policy was implemented in an effort to clean up the streets, end violent crime in neighborhoods, and restore a sense of safety. Criminals faced strict sentences and no leniency (Vitiello, 2003). Over time, however, advocacy groups began to take more notice of abuses in the criminal justice system—particularly with respect to racial profiling, plea deal abuses (i.e., pressuring individuals charged with an offense to accept a plea deal to avoid a costly trial), the use of lethal force, and bail problems. Of these, one of the most oppressive systems is the bail system, which takes advantage of impoverished individuals. Today, the bail industry is a $2 billion industry that profits off the poor (ACLU, 2019).

With six different types of bail—citation release, surety bond, recognizance, property bond, immigration bond, and cash bond—there are many ways for individuals to obtain release after being charged with an offense. However, even with these options it is not always possible for individuals to make bail. For that reason, the ACLU (2019) reports that 440,000 people, or 70% of people incarcerated, "are there pre-trial, often because they can't afford to pay a bail requirement set for their freedom." Advocacy groups such as The Sentencing Project, The Marshall Project, the St. Louis Action Committee, and the Arch City Defenders have pushed for bail reform. However, there are problems with bail reform as well. For instance, New York City is now experiencing a rise in crime rates as bail reform has drastically changed who can be held and for how long. Even people with extensive criminal records are being released without discrimination.

The trouble here is that discrimination can be negative—but discretion can be positive. It is necessary to find a balance between discrimination and zero discretion whatsoever. For the sake of public safety and stability, the criminal justice system has to be more engaged, more ethical, and more aware of the ramifications of its actions. People have lives that they need to return to while they wait for trial—but individuals who have an extensive criminal record are not the ones who should be immediately released to return to a life of crime. Bail reform was a cause motivated by a sense of social justice, but reform must be conducted in moderation; otherwise, it risks swinging to the opposite extreme and creating a worse and even more untenable situation. The example of Prohibition in the 1920s is instructive, because society moved from tolerating a social problem of drinking to creating an entire underworld for organized crime to thrive in. Bail reformers must think carefully about the repercussions of their actions because the safety of society is at stake.

For that reason, the policy that should be pursued is one grounded in social justice, but individuals must be considered on a case-by-case basis. A universal policy is inefficient and allows too many individuals with extensive criminal records back onto the streets. First-time offenders should be the primary target of bail reform. Multiple offenders should be the ones who receive stricter bail parameters.

3 Sections Hidden · 970 words
White Collar vs. Blue Collar Crime560 words
When it comes to white collar crime, there is also the problem of who escapes accountability and why. Because the criminal justice system focuses primarily on blue collar crime,…
Policing and Defense310 words
Discrimination and racism can also cause serious problems at the policing level, where reform is equally needed. The responsibility of the law in preventing harm and upholding social…
Conclusion100 words
From issues of bail reform to the prosecution of both blue collar and white collar crime to the subject of policing and defense, reform is needed at every level of the criminal justice system. However, unless reformers approach these issues with the realities of discrimination…

References

ACLU. (2019). ACLU lawsuit goes after $2 billion bail industry that profits off poor people. Retrieved from https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/aclu-lawsuit-goes-after-2-billion-bail-industry-profits-poor-people

Chambliss, W. (1989). State-organized crime. Criminology, 27, 183–208.

Davis, A. (2000). Masked racism: Reflections on the prison industrial complex. [Article reprinted from Colorlines]. Indigenous Law Bulletin, 4(27), 4.

Hehman, E., Flake, J. K., & Calanchini, J. (2018). Disproportionate use of lethal force in policing is associated with regional racial biases of residents. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 9(4), 393–401.

Pavlo, W. (2012). Can white collar defendants get a fair trial? Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/walterpavlo/2012/12/19/can-white-collar-defendants-get-a-fair-trial/

Pettit, B., & Western, B. (2004). Mass imprisonment and the life course: Race and class inequality in US incarceration. American Sociological Review, 69(2), 151–169.

Rosoff, S., Pontell, H., & Tillman, R. (2003). Looting America. New York, NY: Prentice Hall.

Tate, S. A., & Page, D. (2018). Whiteliness and institutional racism: Hiding behind (un)conscious bias. Ethics and Education, 13(1), 141–155.

Vitiello, M. (2002). Three strikes laws—A real or imagined deterrent to crime. Hum. Rts., 29, 3.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Bail Reform White Collar Crime Racial Bias Mass Incarceration Community Policing Restorative Justice Implicit Jury Bias Defense Misconduct State-Organized Crime Private Prisons
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Racism and Discrimination in Criminal Justice Reform. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/racism-discrimination-criminal-justice-reform-2175394

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.