Detroit Housing Market: A Case for House Flipping

Introduction: Detroit's Housing Challenge

Detroit is a city that is, in many respects, behind the proverbial "eight ball." The more distressed parts of Detroit are full of abandoned and burned houses, crimes go unreported or unanswered, and local agencies are remarkably poor at delivering even basic services at a satisfactory level. However, not unlike struggling industries and neighborhoods of past eras, it is possible for the Detroit housing market to experience a rebirth. Achieving this would require careful navigation of monetary, cultural, and economic pressures, but it is entirely feasible.

There are those who have argued that large portions of Detroit — and nearby areas such as Flint — should simply be razed and left bare. There is some wisdom to this view, given the mass exodus from the area, not unlike what happened in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina devastated many poor and destitute neighborhoods. However, housing is a fundamental need, and anyone rehabbing or building homes in the Detroit area must proceed carefully, because doing so without proper planning can lead to financial losses or invite accusations of gentrification and racial insensitivity.

That said, there are areas in Detroit worth reviving, and this can be done without causing home prices to skyrocket. There would naturally be concern about over-investing in any given property, given the risk of failing to recoup even the purchase price, let alone turning a profit. Even so, positive developments are beginning to emerge in Detroit's housing, government, and private business sectors. Ford and General Motors are starting to thrive again, and Chrysler is also faring reasonably well despite now being owned by Italian automaker Fiat (Healey, 2014). While house flipping alone would not solve Detroit's deep-seated problems, it is absolutely part of the overall solution — and the free market is the best vehicle for it, given that government funding is currently depleted.

The House Flipping Model Explained

Very few homeowners have the means or the technical knowledge to perform significant home upgrades themselves. Adding to this challenge is the fact that renovations through conventional contractors are generally quite expensive, both because of the contractor's profit motive and because of the added difficulty of undertaking major work in an occupied home. However, when a home is vacant and owned by someone with the knowledge and connections to rehabilitate it at a reasonable cost, a quick "flip" becomes possible. The house is purchased, renovated in short order, and ideally sold before more than one or two mortgage payments are required — assuming the purchase was financed. Even with an all-cash purchase, the home must ultimately sell for more than the combined cost of acquisition and renovation.

The general focus of house flipping typically centers first on kitchens and bathrooms, and then on the home's infrastructure — plumbing and electrical systems (Inspect A Property, 2014). Any rooms with obvious defects, such as holes in walls or ceilings, damaged flooring, or worn carpeting, must also be addressed, though these costs are usually manageable as long as the home's structure is sound and there are no major hazards requiring remediation. Mold and asbestos are two such hazards that can dramatically increase renovation costs. Asbestos, in particular, does not always require removal unless it must be disturbed during renovation; however, when it does need to be removed, the process must be handled by licensed professionals, as asbestos exposure is a known cause of cancers such as mesothelioma.

A critical consideration in the Detroit context is the relationship between renovation costs and local home prices. There are likely properties available for very little money — perhaps even for free — but a house flipper would need to target homes where the spread between purchase price and post-renovation sale price is wide enough to justify the business risk. This requires careful selection of both the property and the neighborhood.

Economic Context and Housing Market Trends

Another important dimension of house flipping is the broader economic environment. Housing prices are generally considered relatively predictable: neighborhoods tend to appreciate over time, and homes are widely regarded as one of the primary ways for average individuals to build wealth. Financed over fifteen to thirty years, homes rarely lose value compared to other assets such as cars or consumer electronics. However, the housing market carries real risk. Detroit's decline accelerated sharply when the automakers began struggling, leaving the region economically concentrated in a single vulnerable industry.

The most dramatic recent illustration of housing market risk is the collapse of the housing bubble that began in the mid-2000s and deepened during the Great Recession of 2007 to 2009. The underlying cause was an extended period during which mortgage credit was far too easy to obtain, driving home prices to unsustainable levels (Vogel, 2013). As with gas prices that rise beyond what consumers will tolerate, demand eventually collapsed and prices followed (Foran, 2013). The effects of that crash have lingered unevenly across the country, and Detroit has been among the hardest-hit markets.

Looking ahead, the broader national housing market has been recovering slowly, and that trajectory is expected to continue in the coming years (Esswein, 2014). The recovery has been uneven, however. While middle- and upper-income jobs have largely returned to pre-recession levels, lower-wage and lower-skill positions — including many in the auto sector — have not recovered as fully, and many jobs that have returned now pay less than before (Lowrey, 2014). General Motors, meanwhile, has faced significant challenges related to recalls involving ignition switches in vehicles up to a decade old (ABC, 2014). Interest rates, a key driver of housing demand, have remained historically low since the Federal Reserve cut them during the recession (USNews.com, 2014). As long as economic progress continues — even incrementally — the housing market should improve gradually over the coming generation, though dramatic shifts in rates or prices appear unlikely in the near term (Bradford, 2012).

Conclusion

On the whole, targeting Detroit for house flipping presents genuine opportunity alongside significant risk. Some of those risks are amplified by political and cultural sensitivities around profit-making in distressed communities — sensitivities that are sometimes rooted in misunderstanding but are nonetheless real constraints that any investor must navigate. Others stem from Detroit's structural economic challenges: its over-dependence on the auto industry, its fiscal insolvency, its shrinking population, and its strained municipal services.

What makes the opportunity viable, despite these challenges, is precisely the absence of large-scale corporate competitors, the availability of underpriced properties in select neighborhoods, and the low cost of targeted, modest renovations aimed at producing affordable housing rather than luxury product. The private sector is not only the most capable actor in this space — it is essentially the only one, given the state of Detroit's public finances. A disciplined approach focused on edge neighborhoods, cash acquisitions, affordable price points, and realistic profit expectations can produce meaningful returns while contributing incrementally to Detroit's recovery. The deeper work of transforming the city's most devastated areas lies beyond the scope of any house-flipping operation, but that does not diminish the role that well-executed private investment can play in the neighborhoods where it is feasible.

References

ABC. (2014, July 18). GM delayed recall in another ignition switch case. ABC News. Retrieved July 19, 2014, from

Bradford, H. (2012, April 6). Homeowners stuck with high interest rates even after government refinancing program. The Huffington Post. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/06/mortgage-refinance-program-underwater-homeowners-lack-competition_n_1407949.html

Burdeau, C. (2012, August 28). New Orleans' post-Katrina gentrification is touchy. The Big Story. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from

Campanella, R. (2013, March 1). Gentrification and its discontents: Notes from New Orleans. Newgeography.com. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from http://www.newgeography.com/content/003526-gentrification-and-its-discontents-notes-new-orleans

Data Driven Detroit. (2014, July 21). Data Driven Detroit. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from http://www.datadrivendetroit.org/

Esswein, P. (2014, July 21). 2014 housing outlook: Home prices head higher. MSN Real Estate. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from

Foran, C. (2013, October 3). Why are gas prices plummeting? National Journal. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from http://www.nationaljournal.com/energy/why-are-gas-prices-plummeting-20131003

Healey, J. (2014, January 21). Done deal: Fiat owns Chrysler. USA Today. Retrieved July 20, 2014, from http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/driveon/2014/01/21/done-deal-fiat-now-owns-all-of-chrysler/4718529/

Inspect A Property. (2014, July 21). Top 10 remodels for your house flip. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from

Lowrey, A. (2014, April 27). Recovery has created far more low-wage jobs than better-paid ones. The New York Times. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/28/business/economy/recovery-has-created-far-more-low-wage-jobs-than-better-paid-ones.html

Milford, P. (2014, July 21). Detroit residents sue to stop water shutoffs in poor areas. The Detroit News. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from

Seelye, K. (2011, March 22). Detroit census figures confirm a grim desertion like no other. The New York Times. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/23/us/23detroit.html

USNews.com. (2014, July 21). Should the Federal Reserve keep interest rates low? U.S. News. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from http://www.usnews.com/debate-club/should-the-federal-reserve-keep-interest-rates-low

Vogel, J. (2013, June 14). Thinking outside the housing bubble. U.S. News. Retrieved July 21, 2014, from http://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/economic-intelligence/2013/06/14/housing-bubble-or-credit-bubble-it-matters