Essay Undergraduate 627 words

Discrimination and Perspective in "A Very Old Man With Enormous Wings"

~4 min read

Abstract

This essay analyzes Gabriel García Márquez's 1955 short story "A Very Old Man With Enormous Wings" as a critique of discrimination, exploitation, and social prejudice. The paper examines how the village community's unfamiliarity with the old winged man leads to ridicule and exploitation rather than compassion, drawing connections to broader social patterns in which difference invites mistreatment. The essay also considers the priest's failure of empathy, the parallel treatment of the tarantula girl, and the real-world resonance of García Márquez's themes in the context of racial and cultural prejudice. The author concludes that recognizing and setting aside prejudice is more important than claiming to fully understand the "other."

📝 How to Write This Type of Paper Writing guide — click to expand

▼

What makes this paper effective

The essay uses a specific literary text as a lens for exploring a universal social theme — discrimination — giving the argument both textual grounding and broader relevance.
It connects the fictional community's behavior to real-world racial and cultural dynamics, extending the analysis beyond plot summary into social commentary.
The paper incorporates a Native American proverb as an epigraph-style framing device, immediately anchoring the theme of perspective-taking before the analysis begins.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates thematic literary analysis: rather than summarizing the story's plot, it identifies a central theme (discrimination and failure of empathy) and traces it through multiple characters and episodes — Pelayo and Elisenda's exploitation, the village's indifference, the priest's rejection, and the parallel treatment of the tarantula girl. This multi-point evidence strategy strengthens the interpretive claim.

Structure breakdown

The essay opens with a framing statement about social discrimination, introduces the text and its central concern, and then moves through several analytical paragraphs, each focusing on a different character or group. It closes by connecting García Márquez's fictional world to contemporary racial realities and the author's own biographical context, broadening the argument's scope in the conclusion.

Introduction: Discrimination Through the Lens of Folklore

Particularities have always served as a tool for discrimination, given that contemporary society has grown accustomed to treating people based on their background and appearance. Gabriel García Márquez's 1955 short story "A Very Old Man With Enormous Wings" portrays an episode in the life of a Hispanic community that reveals its discriminatory and exploitative nature after encountering a distressed creature. The Native American saying "Never criticize another until you have walked a mile in his moccasins" partly explains García Márquez's account. Fueled by folklore and by the opportunity to make easy money, Pelayo and Elisenda do not hesitate to take advantage of the angel's state of decay, regardless of knowing nothing about him or about the circumstances that led to his present situation.

Exploiting the Unknown: Pelayo, Elisenda, and the Angel

Individuals are typically comfortable associating things they know nothing about with things that are familiar to them. Pelayo, Elisenda, and everyone in the village believed it would have been impossible for a real angel to share the same characteristics as the old man standing before them. As a result, they resort to treating him poorly and even exploiting him by charging an entrance fee to those interested in seeing him. Judging from the overall state of affairs involving the human community that encountered the old man with enormous wings, it is safe to conclude that they were virtually indifferent to his health or his background.

Indifference and the Spectacle of Difference

Society is apparently inclined to treat different individuals with less respect and far less compassion. The fact that both the old man and the girl who was turned into a tarantula were treated in much the same way demonstrates that no one cared for them — they were regarded as nothing more than freaks of nature by the local community.

2 Locked Sections · 175 words remaining

Failure of Compassion: The Priest's Response · 65 words

"Religious authority fails to recognize angel's nature"

From Fiction to Reality: Race, Culture, and Prejudice · 110 words

"Story's themes connect to real racial prejudice"

Conclusion: Moving Beyond Stereotypes

Gabriel García Márquez is an individual likely to have experienced many disappointments across his life because of the fact that he was a Hispanic writer trying to succeed in a society dominated by white people. His story serves as a reminder that discrimination rooted in unfamiliarity diminishes both the one who discriminates and the community as a whole. The most enduring lesson of "A Very Old Man With Enormous Wings" is not that we must understand everything that is different, but that we must resist the impulse to exploit or demean what we do not understand.

You’re 62% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.

130,000+ paper examples AI writing assistant Citation generator Cancel anytime

Key Concepts in This Paper

Discrimination Otherness Magical Realism Exploitation Empathy Failure Social Prejudice Folklore Racial Bias Compassion Cultural Perspective