Domestic Violence Exposure Effects on Children: Qual & Quant Studies
This paper reviews two studies examining the effects of domestic violence exposure on children. The first, a qualitative study by DeHart and Alshuler (2009), draws on interviews with incarcerated women to document how their children experienced and responded to domestic violence prior to the mothers' incarceration. The second, a quantitative study by Moylan et al. (2010), uses longitudinal data to test a "dual exposure" hypothesis — that children exposed to both witnessing domestic violence and direct abuse face significantly worse adolescent outcomes than those exposed to only one form of violence. Both studies are evaluated for their methodology, key findings, and limitations, with attention to implications for social work practice and policy.
- Introduction: Domestic Violence as a Public Health Concern: Domestic violence exposure framed as public health concern
- Qualitative Study: Children of Incarcerated Mothers: DeHart & Alshuler study on violence exposure accounts
- Critique and Limitations of the Qualitative Study: Recall bias, sample issues, and missing corroboration
- Quantitative Study: Dual Exposure and Adolescent Outcomes: Moylan et al. longitudinal dual exposure hypothesis tested
- Critique and Limitations of the Quantitative Study: Measurement gaps and sample diversity limitations
- Conclusions and Implications for Practice: Legal and treatment interventions recommended for families
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper pairs a qualitative and a quantitative study on the same topic, allowing meaningful methodological contrast and thematic continuity between the two reviews.
- Each study is systematically broken down using consistent subheadings (purpose, sample, methodology, findings, critique), demonstrating strong organizational discipline.
- The critiques go beyond the authors' own stated limitations — for example, flagging recall bias due to median imprisonment time of four years — showing genuine critical engagement with the research.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates structured comparative critique: it applies the same analytical framework to two very different study designs, evaluating internal validity, sample representativeness, measurement quality, and generalizability for each. This technique is especially valuable in social science coursework where students must evaluate research rather than simply summarize it.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a shared introduction establishing domestic violence exposure as a public health concern. It then addresses the qualitative study in full before pivoting to the quantitative study, each section following a parallel subheading structure. Brief "relation to course readings" passages connect each study to broader themes before a shared conclusion synthesizes both sets of findings. This parallel architecture makes the two studies easy to compare directly.
Introduction: Domestic Violence as a Public Health Concern
Domestic violence is an ongoing experience of physical, psychological, and sexual abuse in the home, and is often a method used by one adult to establish control and power over another person. Exposure by children to marital aggression is now a recognized public health concern. The investigation of the effects of such exposure on the functioning of a child is a significant societal concern. The two studies reviewed below — one qualitative, one quantitative — each address different dimensions of this problem, together offering a broader understanding of how domestic violence affects children's psychological and behavioral development.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.