Ethical Interpersonal Communication in Political Negotiations
This paper analyzes the breakdown in communication between Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and Speaker of the House John Boehner during negotiations over the Bush-era tax cuts. Drawing on Johnson's (2012) framework of ethical interpersonal communication, the paper identifies their exchanges as examples of monologue communication and an I-It relationship characterized by self-centeredness and a lack of genuine engagement. The paper recommends a shift toward an I-Thou relationship by developing specific communication competencies, including mindfulness, the HURIER model of effective listening, and emotional intelligence. Together, these strategies are presented as a pathway to productive, respectful dialogue capable of resolving critical policy disagreements.
- Introduction and Scenario Overview: Reid-Boehner tax cut conflict introduced
- Communication Failures: Monologue and the I-It Relationship: Self-centered monologue and I-It behavior diagnosed
- Recommendations for I-Thou Communication: Shift to dialogue and I-Thou relationship proposed
- Mindfulness and Effective Listening Strategies: HURIER model and mindfulness competencies explained
- Emotional Intelligence in Political Dialogue: Emotion recognition and mood management strategies
- Conclusion: I-Thou dialogue recommended for productive policy resolution
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds its recommendations in a clearly identified theoretical framework — Johnson's (2012) distinction between I-It and I-Thou relationships — and applies it consistently to a real-world political scenario.
- Uses a vivid, documented exchange between Reid and Boehner as concrete evidence of communication breakdown, making the abstract concept of monologue communication immediately tangible.
- Organizes recommendations into discrete, named competencies (mindfulness, the HURIER model, emotional intelligence), giving the paper a practical, actionable structure.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied ethical analysis: it moves from theoretical definition (I-It vs. I-Thou, monologue vs. dialogue) to empirical observation (the documented confrontation) to prescriptive recommendation. This theory-to-practice structure is a hallmark of applied ethics writing and shows how abstract communication frameworks can be used to diagnose and address real interpersonal failures.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a scenario description that establishes the conflict, then transitions into a diagnosis of the communication problem using established theory. The recommendations section forms the bulk of the paper, subdivided by competency (mindfulness, listening, emotional intelligence). A brief conclusion synthesizes the argument and reaffirms the policy stakes. The structure is linear and functional, moving clearly from problem identification to solution.
Introduction and Scenario Overview
This paper focuses on the disagreement over the Bush-era tax cuts between Harry Reid, the Senate Majority Leader, and John Boehner, the Speaker of the House. The two leaders took opposing positions: Senator Reid believed the tax cuts policy should focus on people earning less than $250,000 per year, while Speaker Boehner believed tax cuts should apply to everyone, including the wealthiest Americans. Both leaders had a history of difficulty reaching consensus and engaging in effective communication. Despite their differences, both parties recognized that allowing the tax cuts policy to expire would have a significant detrimental effect on the nation's economic recovery.
The objective of this paper is to guide both Reid and Boehner toward productive communication and behaviors that will foster an I-Thou relationship — one that will allow them to work together to resolve the tax cuts dispute amicably and address other critical issues facing the nation.
References
Johnson, C. E. (2012). Organizational ethics: A practical approach (2nd ed.). SAGE Publications.
Spaeth, R. (2013). Fiscal-cliff drama: John Boehner reportedly told Harry Reid to go f— himself. The Week, January 2, 2013.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.