Hannah Arendt's Origins of Totalitarianism Explained
This paper examines Hannah Arendt's foundational work, The Origins of Totalitarianism, focusing on her analysis of the collective social groups — the Mob, the masses, the tribes, and the starving multitude — whose world-lessness made them susceptible to totalitarian movements. The paper traces Arendt's distinction between tyrannical and totalitarian governments, her concept of "total terror," and her account of how concentration camps systematically destroyed the juridical, moral, and individual identities of prisoners. Drawing directly on Arendt's text, the paper shows how totalitarianism annihilated human spontaneity, plurality, and freedom, reducing persons to interchangeable biological units and representing an unprecedented form of political evil.
- Mass Society and the Collective Groups Behind Totalitarianism: The Mob, masses, tribes, and starving multitude as preconditions
- Totalitarianism vs. Tyranny: Terror, Power, and De-politicization: How totalitarian terror differs from tyrannical government
- The Concentration Camp as a Laboratory of Dehumanization: Camps as sites for eliminating human freedom and plurality
- Three Steps in the Destruction of Human Identity: Disenfranchisement, elimination of choice, and erasure of individuality
- World-lessness, Loneliness, and Susceptibility to Totalitarian Control: How social loneliness made the Mob compliant to totalitarian rule
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper follows Arendt's own conceptual architecture closely, moving from the social preconditions of totalitarianism through its mechanisms of terror to its ultimate expression in the concentration camp — mirroring the logic of her argument rather than simply summarizing it.
- It maintains precise distinctions between Arendt's key terms — Mob vs. People, tyranny vs. totalitarianism, fear vs. terror — demonstrating careful reading of a complex philosophical text.
- Concrete historical examples (the Dreyfus Affair, the South African gold rush, the Gulag, Hitler and Stalin) ground abstract theoretical claims in identifiable events.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates close textual explication: it unpacks Arendt's layered vocabulary (world-lessness, spontaneity, juridical identity, logicality) and shows how each concept builds on the last. This technique — defining a theorist's terms through their own usage and then applying those terms analytically — is essential for philosophy and political theory writing at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized in three numbered sections that broadly follow Arendt's own structure. Section I establishes the social groups whose displacement creates the raw material for totalitarian movements. Section II analyzes how totalitarian governments operate through terror and the concentration camp. Section III returns to the social-psychological dimension, explaining why world-lessness and loneliness made the Mob permanently vulnerable to totalitarian conditioning.
Mass Society and the Collective Groups Behind Totalitarianism
Hannah Arendt, in her book The Origins of Totalitarianism, attributes the formation of a mass society in Europe in the first decades of the 20th century to "grassroots eruptions" from a number of collective groups. These were the Mob, the masses, the tribes, and the starving multitude — all "mobilized for action" and powerful (Arendt, 1973).
The first of these groups, the Mob, Arendt perceives as having proceeded from the anti-Semitic riots that flared during the Dreyfus Affair in France. This Mob, according to her, was recruited from all classes of society — the "residue" or the "refuse of all classes" that accumulated from those left behind by the economic cycles of capitalism. They were displaced by the class structure and resented ordered society, and were quickly mobilized for violence by instigators. Arendt distinguishes the Mob from the People in that the Mob was outside the class structure and always attuned to public-spirited action, while the People was firmly placed within it. She is careful to note that the Mob was not identical with, but only a caricature of, the People.
As the first wave of collectivities, the Mob reappeared in Arendt's section on "Imperialism" as joining the gold and diamond rush in South Africa in the late 19th century. Arendt refers to the Mob as the "superfluous men who established a counter-society through which men could find their way back into a human world of fellowship and purpose." Others who dug for gold and diamonds included the second wave of collectivities Arendt calls the masses — workers' movements whom she considers the authentic People, as distinguished from the faceless and displaced non-People, such as the Mob. Those who had a human "world" belonged to the People; those who did not, she classed as the non-People.
She writes that those "superfluous men" (the Mob) who joined the workers' movements became part of the People, and those who did not were incorporated into the imperialist Mob. This imperialist Mob was thrown out of the "human world of fellowship and purpose" by having no place in a structured society, by being physically uprooted and divested of normal expectations and constraints (Arendt). Hence, they were severed from civilization and forced into a ghostlike existence in which they were devoid of any sense of responsibility for their actions and decisions.
From this mold evolved the tribes as the third group or strain of collectivities. These tribes developed out of the imperialist Mob that struggled against or alongside a native population without themselves becoming part of the People, as they were without foundation or structure. People had a world and histories, unlike the Mob and the tribes (Arendt) — examples of which were the Boers and African tribes. They did not share a tangible territory and institutions with the People, but only what they possessed internally.
The starving multitude Arendt writes about accounted for the rest outside these three collectivities — displaced, struggling, incensed, and lost for identity and a place of their own. It was this condition of world-lessness that rendered the Mob inherently susceptible to influence and mobilization by movements. A movement, according to her, was a new way of holding these fragmented individuals together without providing them a stable world or existence. A movement could hold them and get them to act in concert by introducing a racist ideology that made them feel "superior" by merely offering them a "definition" of themselves. This filling-in of their vacuum could incline them to commit violent acts in defeating or displacing another group.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.