Conflict and Alienation in Hemingway's "Soldier's Home"
This essay analyzes the sources and nature of conflict in Ernest Hemingway's short story "Soldier's Home," focusing on the protagonist Harold Krebs and his inability to readjust to civilian life after returning from war. The paper identifies three primary forces driving the central conflict: the indifference of Krebs's hometown community, his family's failure to understand his suffering, and his own transformed values and identity. Drawing on biographical parallels between Hemingway and Krebs, the essay examines how societal pressure to conform, domestic expectations, and the psychological aftermath of combat combine to alienate Krebs from love, ambition, religion, and meaningful human connection.
- Introduction: Krebs and the Burden of Return: Overview of Krebs's post-war conflict and core thesis
- Society's Indifference and the Failure of Homecoming: Community ignores Krebs; isolation begins
- Family Expectations and the Pressure to Conform: Family fails to understand Krebs's war trauma
- Krebs's Internal Struggle and Loss of Identity: War transforms Krebs; civilian identity collapses
- The Climactic Confrontation and the Lie of Love: Breakfast scene exposes Krebs's emotional detachment
- Conclusion: Unresolved Conflict and the Decision to Leave: Krebs flees home; conflict remains unresolved
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay organizes its analysis around three clearly defined conflict drivers, giving the argument a logical, progressive structure that is easy to follow.
- Direct quotations from the story are used precisely to illustrate Krebs's emotional state, particularly the breakfast scene, which grounds abstract claims about alienation in textual evidence.
- The biographical link between Hemingway and Krebs adds contextual depth and helps explain the story's emotional authenticity without overpowering the literary analysis.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates thematic close reading: each conflict source is introduced, supported with textual evidence, and connected to the story's broader commentary on war's dehumanizing effects. The writer also draws on secondary sources (Johnston, Meyers) to reinforce interpretive claims, showing how literary scholarship can supplement primary-text analysis.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a thesis identifying Krebs's central dilemma, then works through three conflict sources in turn — community, family, and self — before concluding with the unresolved ending and Krebs's flight from home. This cause-to-consequence structure mirrors the story's own narrative progression.
Introduction: Krebs and the Burden of Return
Ernest Hemingway's story "Soldier's Home" features a young veteran, Harold Krebs, who is unable to adapt and lead an ordinary life after returning from war. Like several fellow soldiers-turned-writers, Hemingway uses this tale to explore his own struggles with adjusting to civilian life after the war. Though Krebs values truth, circumstances and society coerce him into lying. The story depicts, in an accurate manner, the contradiction between his personal values — which changed drastically following his experiences on the battlefield — and the expectations others place upon him, namely that he display compliance with societal norms. Ultimately, Krebs retreats into a life of seclusion, alienating himself from love, ambition, societal relationships, and religion.
Several circumstances combine to give rise to the conflicts outlined in the story. Three elements in particular contribute significantly to Krebs's conflict: the failure of his hometown inhabitants to welcome him back as a hero; his family's failure to comprehend his suffering and struggles; and his own transformed nature and values, which make it increasingly difficult for him to adapt to society.
Society's Indifference and the Failure of Homecoming
Society contributes greatly to the conflict witnessed in the tale. The townsfolk regard Krebs's exceedingly late return from battle as peculiar. Krebs anticipates a warm welcome, which he fails to receive owing to his delayed arrival. This gives rise to feelings of betrayal within him; he could have died at war, yet nobody acknowledges him. Because his community has no interest in authentic wartime stories, Krebs begins to avoid mingling with people. His noncompliance with the societal expectation that he seek employment and marry only deepens his estrangement — society does not accept him on his own terms.
Bibliography
Hemingway, Ernest. "Soldier's Home." Contact Collection of Contemporary Writers. New York: Boni & Liveright, 1925.
Johnston, Kenneth G. The Tip of the Iceberg: Hemingway and the Short Story. Greenwood: The Penkevill Publishing Company, 1987. 75–79.
LAGGC. "Ernest Hemingway Research Paper." CUNY.edu, 2011.
Meyers, Jeffrey. Hemingway: A Biography. New York: Harper and Row Publishers, 1985.
Temper, Kelly. "Factors in 'Soldier's Home' Conflict." Warehouse, n.d., p. 3.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.