How the Irish Became White: Race, Labor, and Identity
This paper compares two landmark works in the history of race and labor in America: Noel Ignatiev's How the Irish Became White and David Roediger's The Wages of Whiteness. Both texts examine how Irish and other Eastern European immigrants navigated the fluid boundaries of "whiteness" during the 19th and early 20th centuries, often at the expense of Black inclusion. The paper contrasts each author's methodology — Roediger's academically broad, Marxist-inflected analysis versus Ignatiev's more narrative, community-focused approach — while identifying their shared argument: that self-identifying as "white" was a social and economic necessity that deepened racial divisions even as it expanded opportunity for immigrant groups.
- Introduction: Race, Labor, and the Immigrant Experience: Situates both books within immigrant labor history
- Thesis and Analytical Framework of Each Work: Compares each author's central argument about whiteness
- Irish-Americans, the Democratic Party, and the Politics of Whiteness: Examines Irish alignment with Democratic white identity politics
- Expanding White Identity Before and After the Civil War: Traces broadening of whiteness through Reconstruction era
- Comparing Methodology and Sources: Contrasts Roediger's academic scope with Ignatiev's narrative style
- Conclusion: Race Deferred and the Legacy of Whiteness: Reflects on race as unresolved issue in both works
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Sustains a genuine comparative structure throughout, holding both texts in dialogue rather than summarizing each in isolation before moving to comparison.
- Uses direct quotation strategically — the block quote from Roediger anchors the thesis comparison and gives the reader concrete textual evidence for the argument.
- Moves fluidly between analytical observations and historical context, grounding abstract ideas about racial identity in specific political events such as the Lincoln-Douglas contest.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative textual analysis across two book-length scholarly works. Rather than treating comparison as a mechanical checklist, the writer identifies a shared conceptual problem — the expansion of "whiteness" as a social and economic necessity — and uses that shared problem as the lens through which methodological and thematic differences between Ignatiev and Roediger are evaluated. This is an effective approach for undergraduate book-review or historiography assignments.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with historical context situating both books, then introduces each author's thesis. It proceeds to examine the political dimension (the Democratic Party and the Lincoln-Douglas rivalry), moves to the post-Civil War reconstruction period, then compares methodologies and source types. The conclusion reflects personally on the significance of the works while restating the shared argument about race being perpetually deferred in American political life.
The correlation between Eastern European immigrants of the late 19th and early 20th centuries and newly freed Black Americans during Reconstruction is frequently drawn by social scientists and historians. Many conclude that the treatment of newly freed Black Americans — and especially Irish immigrants — was similar, as both groups were seen as inexhaustible sources of low-wage labor to fuel the industrial revolution in the United States. It is for this reason that a comparison between works addressing each of these two cultures is historically appropriate, as both groups were subjugated and disenfranchised from social and official rights and opportunities.
In How the Irish Became White, Noel Ignatiev examines the grey areas in the social and political definition of "white" as it applied to new immigrants, and to the Irish in particular. In The Wages of Whiteness, David Roediger dissects the same issues as they applied to Black Americans and to others who were considered outside the boundaries of "white" culture. Together, these two works offer complementary perspectives on one of the most consequential and contested categories in American history: whiteness as a social and political construction.
Roediger analyzes personal as well as socio-political occurrences that altered the manner in which a person self-identified — through lifestyle or action — as "white" or as "other." Ignatiev, on the other hand, focuses more specifically on the Irish experience, and in particular on how Irish Americans participated in struggles to unify culture, partly by becoming activists for their own causes and partly by supporting abolitionist movements and other civil rights efforts. Each work clearly defines the character of the period, but through differing resources and styles.
Roediger begins his work with a personal, autobiographical introduction that sets the tone and begins to define the cultural context — and explains why one individual, namely the author himself, would choose not to assimilate into "white" identity but would rather embrace his own historical culture. Ignatiev begins his work by describing the introduction of Irish Americans to causes revolving around the abolition of slavery. He does this by tracing the influence of an Irish political and social hero who was an ardent abolitionist, and how he and his followers attempted to persuade Irish Americans to come out against slavery and support emancipation.
One way these two works can be compared is through analyzing the thesis of each. Though both full-length works contain many interwoven messages, each author sets out to discuss ideas revolving around the definition of "whiteness." As the title suggests, The Wages of Whiteness examines race partly within the context of labor. Roediger writes:
"This book will argue that working class formation and the systematic development of a sense of whiteness went hand in hand for the U.S. white working class. Nonetheless, the privileging of class over race is not always productive or meaningful. To set race within social formations is absolutely necessary, but to reduce race to class is damaging." (Roediger 1999, 8)
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.