JC Penney's Pricing Strategy Failure Under Ron Johnson
This paper examines the failed pricing strategy implemented by JC Penney CEO Ron Johnson, a former Apple executive who replaced the retailer's traditional sale-based pricing with everyday low prices. Despite praise from Harvard Business School analysts, the strategy proved disastrous, driving away loyal customers accustomed to deal-hunting and contributing to a 29% year-over-year sales decline within 17 months. The paper analyzes how the pricing change interacted with broader rebranding and merchandising efforts, why it failed to attract younger consumers, and what lessons the case offers about market segmentation, customer understanding, and the risks of radical pricing changes.
- Introduction: JC Penney and the Everyday Low Pricing Experiment: Ron Johnson replaces sales with everyday low pricing
- Why the Pricing Strategy Failed: Loyal customers lost; 29% sales decline follows
- Pricing, Merchandising, and Rebranding in Theory vs. Practice: Integrated strategy failed to attract new customers
- Lessons Learned: Market Segmentation and Customer Understanding: Segmentation and patience key to pricing changes
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper uses a real, well-documented business failure as a focused case study, grounding abstract pricing concepts in concrete outcomes like a 29% sales decline and a CEO termination after 17 months.
- It moves logically from describing the strategy, to explaining its failure, to connecting it with broader merchandising and rebranding decisions, and finally to extracting transferable lessons — a clean analytical arc.
- The writing maintains a critical, confident voice throughout, avoiding hedging and clearly stating positions (e.g., "this strategy is not going to work in the long run").
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied business case analysis: using a specific company event to test and illustrate broader marketing principles. Rather than simply narrating what happened, it evaluates why decisions were made, assesses their strategic logic, and draws generalized lessons about pricing, segmentation, and customer relationship management.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized into four sections. The first introduces JC Penney's pricing overhaul and its initial reception. The second critiques the strategy's real-world impact on existing customers. The third examines how pricing fit within the broader rebranding effort and where the integrated strategy broke down. The fourth extracts key lessons around market segmentation, customer understanding, and executive hubris.
Introduction: JC Penney and the Everyday Low Pricing Experiment
JC Penney is a major department store generating billions of dollars in revenue per year. The industry, however, is mature and — some would argue — stale. Younger consumers in particular are not attracted to the department store shopping experience, instead choosing almost any alternative. JC Penney tapped former Apple executive Ron Johnson as its new CEO and made sweeping changes to its merchandising and, especially, its pricing. One pricing strategy Johnson instituted was to eliminate the traditional JC Penney sales model and opt for lower prices across the board (D'Innocenzo, 2012). Analysts from his alma mater, Harvard Business School, lauded him as a genius for the simplified pricing program (Girard, 2012). Yet Johnson failed to recognize that the key purchase drivers in department store retail are fundamentally different from those in consumer electronics, and the pricing strategy did not go nearly as well as planned. HBS praised the everyday pricing strategy — set at 40% of previous suggested prices — as a classic business school case study. As it turned out, it was exactly that, though not in the way intended.
Why the Pricing Strategy Failed
JC Penney's pricing strategy was a disaster. The store's existing customers wanted to find deals, as bargain-hunting was one of the major appeals of shopping there. Those deals functioned as loss leaders, and customers who came in for sales would also purchase some full-priced items while in the store. The new everyday pricing, however, alienated many of the store's loyal customers, who were accustomed to assembling their own deals (Berfield & Maheshwari, 2012). After 17 months, Johnson was fired as CEO (Passikoff, 2013), leaving behind year-over-year sales declines of 29%.
Whether such a strategy could ever work in the long run is doubtful. Recovering from a 29% single-year decline is extraordinarily difficult. Pricing was not, at its core, the real problem at JC Penney — the stores themselves were the problem. Nothing about the department store shopping experience appeals to younger consumers. Johnson did attempt to address many other issues, but the pricing change was the element that most profoundly disoriented and alienated existing customers, many of whom are likely lost forever. Neither competition nor the broader economy is the central issue here — shifting consumer behavior is what is killing the department store format, and that is the battle JC Penney must fight. All Johnson succeeded in doing was driving away old customers, without recognizing that he could never attract young, new customers through a pricing change alone, since pricing was not the reason they were avoiding the store in the first place.
References
Berfield, S. & Maheshwari, S. (2012). JC Penney CEO Ron Johnson gets lesson in pricing. SF Gate. Retrieved April 19, 2014 from http://www.sfgate.com/business/article/J-C-Penney-CEO-Ron-Johnson-gets-lesson-in-pricing-3589014.php
D'Innocenzo, A. (2012). JC Penney slashing prices on all merchandise. USA Today. Retrieved April 19, 2014 from
Girard, K. (2012). Is JC Penney's makeover the future of retailing? Harvard Business School. Retrieved April 19, 2014 from http://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/6944.html
Passikoff, R. (2013). Ron Johnson ousted as JC Penney CEO. Forbes. Retrieved April 19, 2014 from http://www.forbes.com/sites/marketshare/2013/04/09/ron-johnson-ousted-as-jcpenney-ceo/
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.