J.K. Rowling's Harvard Commencement Speech: A Rhetorical Critique
This paper presents a structured critique of J.K. Rowling's commencement address, "The Fringe Benefits of Failure, and the Importance of Imagination," delivered at a university graduation ceremony. The critique is organized into two main sections: a descriptive analysis identifying the speech's purpose, supporting materials, organizational pattern, language, and delivery style; and an evaluative assessment of how effectively each element contributes to the speech's overall impact. The paper finds that Rowling's use of personal experience, testimony, and cause-effect organization makes for a compelling and well-received address, while also suggesting that an extemporaneous delivery style might have strengthened her connection with the audience.
- Speech Overview: Purpose, materials, organization, language, and delivery type
- Context and Audience: Audience composition and commencement speech tradition
- Supporting Materials and Organization: How examples, testimony, and cause-effect structure serve the speech
- Language, Delivery, and Overall Evaluation: Strengths, delivery critique, and overall assessment
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The critique follows a clear two-part structure — description then evaluation — which mirrors standard speech analysis frameworks and keeps the argument organized.
- The paper consistently connects rhetorical terminology (cause-effect pattern, manuscript speech, extemporaneous delivery) to the specific choices Rowling makes, grounding the analysis in concrete observation.
- The evaluative section demonstrates critical independence by acknowledging the speech's strengths while offering a reasoned suggestion for improvement regarding delivery style.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the technique of rhetorical analysis by systematically categorizing and then evaluating each element of a public address — purpose, supporting materials, organizational pattern, language, and delivery. Rather than simply summarizing the speech, the writer assesses how each rhetorical choice serves (or could better serve) the speaker's persuasive goals.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with source attribution and a descriptive inventory of the speech's key features. It then provides context about the audience and the commencement tradition. The evaluation section synthesizes the descriptive findings into a judgment of overall effectiveness, concluding with a constructive critique of the manuscript delivery format. The structure moves logically from description to interpretation to assessment.
Speech Overview
Source: Speech sourced from YouTube on 23 April 2017.
Title: "The Fringe Benefits of Failure, and the Importance of Imagination"
Speaker: J.K. Rowling
This is a commencement speech that J.K. Rowling, a renowned novelist, delivered at a university graduation ceremony, during which she was awarded an honorary degree by the institution.
In her speech, Rowling makes extensive use of examples and testimony as supporting materials. With regard to examples, she draws on personal experiences; when it comes to testimony, she references individuals who have had a meaningful impact on her life. The organizational pattern used in the speech is the cause-effect pattern. The language Rowling employs is largely formal, and the mode of delivery is physical — the speech is, in itself, a manuscript speech.
Context and Audience
The speech was delivered to a cosmopolitan audience comprising university professors, staff, graduates, and parents. It is important to note, however, that the primary target audience was the graduating students. The university has a long history of inviting individuals who have excelled in various aspects of life to address its graduating classes. Some of the most notable commencement speakers in recent times include Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, Oprah Winfrey, Michael Bloomberg, and Mark Zuckerberg.
The commencement speech is mainly intended to offer meaningful and practical advice to graduates as they leave the academic world to pursue their respective careers. Typically, commencement speakers share their life experiences with graduates and offer guidance on how to succeed in life.
Supporting Materials and Organization
The supporting materials Rowling incorporates into her speech — namely examples and testimony — help sustain the interest of the listener. She draws actively on her own life experiences to illustrate that failure is largely inevitable and to demonstrate why individuals should follow their dreams regardless of the challenges they face. She also incorporates various testimonies from other quarters to further reinforce her central message.
The organizational pattern she adopts — the cause-effect structure — is appropriate for a speech of this nature. This is, at its core, a persuasive speech in which Rowling advocates for embracing life's challenges. Through this organizational approach, she successfully draws connections between failure and the resolve to overcome it, linking both to eventual contentment and success.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.