Managing Resistance to Change at Sony Corporation
This paper examines the resistance to change experienced by Sony Corporation's CEO Howard Stringer as he attempted to introduce Western management practices into the traditionally Japanese organization. Drawing on Gareth Morgan's eight organizational metaphors, the paper evaluates how each perspective — including the machine, organismic, brain, culture, political systems, psychic prison, flux and transformation, and domination metaphors — could have been applied to reduce employee resistance. The analysis highlights cultural, structural, and leadership challenges unique to Sony and proposes concrete strategies Stringer could have employed to align employee behavior with the company's evolving strategic goals.
- Introduction: Overview of Sony's resistance and Morgan's framework
- Machine and Organismic Metaphors: Top-down control vs. adaptive, environment-focused design
- Brain Metaphor and Learning: Employees' unwillingness to learn and integrate software
- Culture and Political Systems: Japanese cultural norms and internal political friction
- Psychic Prisons and Barriers to Innovation: Personal achievement bias blocking organizational change
- Flux, Transformation, and Domination: Building a continuous change culture at Sony
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Systematically applies an established academic framework (Morgan's organizational metaphors) to a real-world corporate case, grounding abstract theory in concrete organizational events.
- Moves logically through multiple metaphors, building a layered argument about why resistance persisted and what specific strategies could have countered it.
- Connects cultural, structural, and leadership dimensions of resistance rather than treating them in isolation, showing awareness of organizational complexity.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied theoretical analysis — taking a multi-part conceptual framework (Morgan's metaphors) and using each component as a diagnostic lens on a specific organizational problem. Rather than summarizing the theory, the student evaluates its applicability to Sony's context and proposes targeted managerial responses, which reflects higher-order analytical thinking.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief framing of Sony's resistance problem and Morgan's framework, then works through the metaphors in sequence: machine and organismic, brain, culture and political systems, psychic prisons, and finally flux/domination. Each section identifies the relevant organizational dynamic at Sony and recommends a concrete strategy, concluding with a call for a culture of continuous transformation.
Introduction
Gareth Morgan identified eight organizational perspectives that can be used as frameworks for understanding and managing organizational resistance. In the case of Sony Corporation, CEO Howard Stringer faced significant resistance when he attempted to introduce Western management practices. Employees resisted these changes, and this generated numerous additional problems. By applying Morgan's organizational metaphors, Stringer could have adopted more effective strategies to overcome this resistance. Each metaphor offers a distinct diagnostic lens and a corresponding set of managerial responses suited to Sony's unique organizational challenges.
Machine and Organismic Metaphors
The machine metaphor suggests that employees will operate as expected, follow laid-out procedures, and function like clockwork. Using this metaphor, Stringer could have initiated top-down commands that employees would be required to follow (Muller et al., 2010). This approach works by reducing waste, increasing efficiency, and standardizing products. At Sony Corporation, however, this metaphor may not have been fully effective, since most of the work is neither repetitive nor simple in nature.
Alternatively, Stringer could have transformed Sony into an organismic organization. Organismic organizations focus on inter-organizational relations, innovation, and broader design choices. Emphasizing the relationship between the organization and its external environment could have helped reduce employee resistance. Once employees were able to apply their skills and understand their importance within the larger competitive landscape, they would have been more likely to embrace new changes. Sony Corporation was struggling to survive in the electronics industry — the introduction of Apple's iPod dealt a significant blow to the company's Walkman, making it imperative that Sony develop a competitive product. Using the organismic metaphor, the company could position itself to survive and compete effectively with its rivals.
Brain Metaphor and Learning
The brain metaphor encourages people to learn, process information, and adapt to change. Applying this metaphor to Sony's situation makes clear that employees were unwilling to learn new ways of working or to integrate new types of information. Employees did not recognize the importance of software, insisting instead on a hardware-first orientation — which meant that software remained an afterthought for newly developed hardware products.
Stringer should have demonstrated to both employees and management the critical importance of developing software alongside hardware. Showing them how essential this integration is could have shifted employee mindsets and encouraged them to process and embrace new information. This would have made the workforce more adaptable over time. Combining different functions so they could be performed within the same department would have been an effective structural strategy for overcoming this form of resistance.
References
Muller, S. D., Mathiassen, L., & Balshoj, H. H. (2010). Software process improvement as organizational change: A metaphorical analysis of the literature. Journal of Systems and Software, 83, 2128–2146.
Suddaby, R., Hardy, C., & Huy, Q. N. (2011). Introduction to special topic forum: Where are the new theories of organization? Academy of Management Review, 36, 236–246.
Sumi, A., & Schuetz, M. (2011). Is Sony turning around? Asia Case Research Centre.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.