Skip to main content
Book Review Undergraduate 716 words

Book Review: Gunfighters, Highwaymen & Vigilantes by McGrath

~4 min read 4 sections History · Westward Expansion
Abstract

This book review examines Roger D. McGrath's Gunfighters, Highwaymen, and Vigilantes: Violence on the Frontier (University of California Press, 1984). McGrath argues that frontier violence differed fundamentally from modern urban crime, and that the Hollywood-driven image of a lawless "old West" is largely a myth. The review assesses McGrath's use of historical records, his journalistic narrative style, and his statistical comparisons of frontier and contemporary urban violence. It also engages with responses from critics including New York Times reviewer William Broyles Jr., historian Thomas J. Noel, and Frank Schroth of Library Journal, ultimately concluding that McGrath's work is a valuable and well-documented contribution to the history of the American West.

Key Takeaways
  • Overview of McGrath's Central Argument: McGrath disputes link between frontier and modern urban violence
  • Historical Evidence and Narrative Style: Sources, statistics, and journalistic prose style assessed
  • Response to Critics: Reviewer rebuts Broyles, concedes Noel, notes Schroth's praise
  • Summary Judgment: McGrath's book deemed valuable contribution to Western history
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The review clearly articulates McGrath's central thesis in the opening paragraph and returns to it when evaluating each critic's objection, maintaining coherent analytical focus throughout.
  • The student demonstrates independent judgment by directly refuting one critic (Broyles) with textual evidence while conceding a valid point made by another (Noel), showing balanced evaluative thinking rather than blanket acceptance or rejection.
  • Specific examples — such as the robbery rate statistics and the critique of McGrath's use of the word "found" — ground the analysis in concrete detail rather than vague impressions.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper models multi-source critical synthesis: it places McGrath's own argument alongside three external reviews, then assesses each in turn. Rather than simply summarizing reviewers, the student evaluates their objections against evidence drawn directly from the text, demonstrating the kind of source-weighing expected in undergraduate historical writing.

Structure breakdown

The review opens with a summary of McGrath's thesis and supporting evidence, then transitions to an analysis of narrative style (including a pointed stylistic critique). It next addresses three published critical responses, defending or qualifying each. A brief summary statement closes the review. The structure follows the standard academic book-review format: summary → analysis → critical dialogue → overall judgment.

Essay 716 words

Overview of McGrath's Central Argument

Roger McGrath's Gunfighters, Highwaymen, and Vigilantes: Violence on the Frontier (University of California Press, 1984) asserts that none of the blame for today's violence in America's cities can be pinned on the rowdiness of the frontier. The kinds of violence that occurred in the West as America was being settled were entirely different from modern big-city violence, he insists. The book goes into considerable detail to describe the social values that existed in frontier mining towns, which were more protective of women and innocent bystanders than most people realize.

The book provides an in-depth examination of what life was like in frontier towns and villages in America. The author carefully references existing records — found in newspapers and books — and draws on well-known authorities such as Alexis de Tocqueville to show that gunfights and hangings were largely affairs between consenting male adults and were part of a well-structured system of justice. McGrath covers the Civil War, mining camps, thieves, and vigilantism, and he notes that the robbery rate on the frontier was approximately 84 people per 100,000 — compared with 1,140 per 100,000 in New York City in 1980.

Historical Evidence and Narrative Style

McGrath makes clear from the first page of his Preface that the picture many Americans hold of the frontier is incorrect, which is a powerful way to launch into the book. He argues that the movie industry, television, and popular literature have created a myth that social structure and law enforcement were absent in the "old West." He promises to investigate the subject through well-documented sources, and he delivers on that promise, footnoting his sources methodically throughout.

As to his narrative style, McGrath uses mainly short, succinct sentences — some of which would technically be considered fragments by stricter grammarians. He prefers a matter-of-fact, journalistic approach with restrained literary embellishment. One minor flaw is his repeated use of the word "found" in an awkward construction. For example, the opening line of his Preface reads: "The early morning hours of Thursday, 13 June 1878 found Patrick Gallagher's Shamrock saloon in Bodie crowded with men" (xi). Hours cannot "find" anything. Similarly, on page 86: "The cold and snowy month of April 1863 found James Sears…" — months do not "find" people. These are small stylistic stumbles in an otherwise accessible and entertaining book. The writing is suitable for both juvenile and adult readers, unpretentious throughout, and enlivened by humorous descriptions of life in these turbulent times.

2 Sections Hidden · 230 words
Response to Critics175 words
New York Times critic William Broyles Jr. writes that McGrath's chapters on the mining boomtown of Aurora "provide…
Summary Judgment55 words
McGrath's book is an excellent addition to the existing historiography of the American frontier. It contains information that readers are unlikely to find elsewhere and…

References

Broyles, William Jr. (1984, September 9). Not-so-wild frontier. The New York Times.

McGrath, Roger D. (1984). Gunfighters, highwaymen, & vigilantes: Violence on the frontier. University of California Press.

Noel, Thomas J. (1985). Gunfighters, highwaymen & vigilantes: Violence on the frontier. American Historical Review, 90(1), 299–231.

Schroth, Frank. (1984). Gunfighters, highwaymen & vigilantes: Violence on the frontier. Library Journal, 109(12), 1324.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Frontier Violence Vigilantism Mining Towns Western Myth Urban Crime Historical Records Frontier Justice American West Social Order Critical Review
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Book Review: Gunfighters, Highwaymen & Vigilantes by McGrath. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/mcgrath-gunfighters-highwaymen-vigilantes-book-review-30980

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.