Mortgage Modification, Risky Lending, and U.S. Bank Policy
This paper examines three news articles to assess the current state of U.S. mortgage modification policy and its broader economic implications. It explores how firms like Lone Star and Caliber Home Loans have extended mortgages to borrowers with troubled credit histories, how the Federal Reserve has moved to ease annual stress test requirements for smaller regional banks, and how the nomination of Steven Mnuchin as Treasury Secretary raised concerns about conflicts of interest and predatory lending practices at Onewest Bank. Together, the articles suggest that loosening regulatory standards and extending credit to high-risk borrowers may recreate the conditions that contributed to the 2008 financial crisis.
- Introduction: Mortgage Modification in the United States: Overview of U.S. mortgage modification history and scope
- Lone Star, Caliber, and Subprime Lending: Goldstein article on risky lending to troubled borrowers
- Federal Reserve Stress Test Changes for Regional Banks: Fed eases stress test burdens on smaller regional banks
- Onewest Bank, Steven Mnuchin, and Political Influence: Mnuchin's Onewest Bank, bailout money, and foreclosure controversy
- Media Bias and Article Analysis: Critical assessment of bias across all three articles
- Conclusion: The Future of U.S. Mortgage Policy: Warning signs of potential repeat economic instability
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper synthesizes three distinct news sources into a coherent argument about the trajectory of U.S. mortgage policy, demonstrating the ability to connect separate journalistic accounts thematically.
- It balances content summary with critical evaluation, explicitly assessing the bias or objectivity of each article rather than simply reporting what each one says.
- The paper maintains a consistent analytical lens — short-term positive vs. long-term negative effects of policy decisions — that ties all three articles together logically.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates source synthesis paired with media critique. Rather than treating each article in isolation, the writer identifies how each source builds on the previous one thematically, culminating in a broader policy argument. The explicit attention to author bias and the distinction between factual reporting and opinion-driven framing shows a sophisticated reading strategy appropriate for undergraduate media or policy analysis courses.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a general overview of mortgage modification history in the United States, then moves through three articles in sequence: the Goldstein piece on Lone Star and Caliber, the Tracy and Ensign piece on Federal Reserve stress test reform, and the Mui and Merle piece on Steven Mnuchin and Onewest Bank. Each section combines summary, direct quotation, and critical commentary. The conclusion synthesizes the three threads into a warning about potential economic instability.
Introduction: Mortgage Modification in the United States
Mortgage modification has been practiced in the United States in some form or another for years. The process entails a change to the terms of a mortgage separate from the original contract agreed to by both borrower and lender. The United States government has provided Americans with various versions of loan modification to help borrowers make payments through reductions in interest rates or principal balances. However, several recent news articles suggest that the government's efforts have been largely in vain. The negative effects of mortgage modification have led to increasingly risky lending practices and the removal of annual stress test requirements for smaller banks, enabling some institutions to lend to borrowers with poor credit scores.
References
Goldstein, M. (2016). Caliber Home Loans embraces borrowers with spotty credit. Nytimes.com. Retrieved December 2, 2016, from http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/08/business/dealbook/caliber-home-loans-embraces-borrowers-with-spotty-credit.html
Mui, Y., & Merle, R. (2016). With Treasury candidate come possible conflicts. Washington Post. Retrieved December 5, 2016, from https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/candidate-for-treasury-secretary-helped-run-bank-that-is-accused-of-bias/2016/11/17/6c7dab5e-acd6-11e6-a31b-4b6397e625d0_story.html
Tracy, R., & Ensign, R. (2016). Fed to ease stress tests for regional banks. WSJ. Retrieved December 5, 2016, from http://www.wsj.com/articles/fed-to-ease-stress-tests-for-regional-banks
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.