Agency as Art by C. Thi Nguyen: Games and Player Agency
This paper analyzes C. Thi Nguyen's chapter "Agency as Art" from his 2020 book Games: Agency as Art (Oxford University Press). The review examines Nguyen's central argument that games constitute a distinctive art form because they allow players to exercise and explore different forms of agency within a structured environment. The paper evaluates Nguyen's use of practical examples such as the game "Sign," his critical engagement with scholars like Bernard Suits and Jane McGonigal, and the credibility of his work as an academic publication. It also notes areas where clearer connections between evidence and claims would strengthen his analysis.
- Overview of Nguyen's Argument: Games as art enabling exploration of agency
- Agency in Games vs. Other Art Forms: Player agency as social and interactive creation
- Structured Environment and Alternate Agency: Game rules frame but do not restrict player freedom
- Critical Engagement and Supporting Evidence: Nguyen's examples and engagement with other scholars
- Assessing Credibility and Accessibility: Academic credibility and audience limitations evaluated
- Conclusion: Overall value and accessibility of Nguyen's work
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper stays focused on a single central claim — Nguyen's concept of "alternate agency" — and traces it consistently across multiple dimensions of the source text.
- It balances summary with evaluation, identifying both strengths (scholarly engagement, use of examples) and a specific weakness (underdeveloped connections between evidence and claims).
- The use of direct quotations from Nguyen anchors the analysis in textual evidence rather than paraphrase alone, lending credibility to the assessment.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates how to write a source analysis that moves beyond mere summary. By acknowledging where Nguyen succeeds — engaging counterarguments from McGonigal and Suits — and where he falls short — not fully elaborating on how his definitions support his thesis — the writer models the kind of nuanced critical reading expected in academic work.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a publishing and audience context, then explains Nguyen's core thesis in accessible terms. It progresses through the concept of agency, the role of structured game environments, a critique of Nguyen's argumentative style, and closes with a credibility assessment and overall evaluation. The structure follows a natural review arc: introduce, analyze, evaluate, conclude.
Overview of Nguyen's Argument
C. Thi Nguyen's "Agency as Art" is a chapter from his book Games: Agency as Art, published by Oxford University Press — a world-renowned and highly reputable academic publisher. The chapter is certainly worthy of the publishing house and is a finely written scholarly piece that fits comfortably within the conventions of academic writing. The field it engages is game studies and philosophy, and its intended audience appears to be scholars, students, and enthusiasts in game studies, philosophy, and digital humanities.
Nguyen's main argument is that games are a unique form of art that allow players to explore different forms of agency. Essentially, Nguyen is referring to the idea that games provide a space for players to exercise control — a space where they can make decisions about their own play and experience the consequences of those decisions interactively, in a way that is wholly different from other art forms. Nguyen argues that games are not just about achieving arbitrary goals but are also about the process of working towards those goals. This process, according to Nguyen, is what makes games a distinctive art form. As he states, "A game uses all these elements to sculpt a form of activity. And when we play games, we take on an alternate form of agency" (p. 1). Just as a film or a play is a collective work of art, a game is also a collective art form in which the player brings his own agency to the work — much as a dramatist brings the script, an actor brings the performance, and a set designer creates the stage.
References
Nguyen, C. Thi. Games: Agency as Art. Oxford University Press, 2020.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.