Avoiding Partnership Pitfalls in Nonprofit Management
This case study examines La Piana Consulting's approach to improving nonprofit organizations by applying for-profit business principles to their operations. The paper explores La Piana's core philosophy, its work refining the NAACP's mission and benchmarking strategy, and its facilitation of a merger between the Women's Center of San Joaquin County and Family and Youth Services of San Joaquin County. The analysis highlights how strategic planning, measurable goal-setting, and careful attention to organizational culture can help nonprofits remain mission-driven while achieving financial sustainability and operational effectiveness.
- La Piana Consulting's Core Mission and Philosophy: Introducing La Piana's business-oriented nonprofit consulting approach
- Applying Business Principles to the NAACP: La Piana refines NAACP's mission and strategic vision
- Benchmarking and Measurable Goals in Nonprofit Work: Using quantifiable indicators to track nonprofit progress
- Facilitating a Successful Nonprofit Merger: Merging two San Joaquin County nonprofits through strategic intervention
- Sustaining Nonprofits Through Business Strategy: How business principles support nonprofit mission and sustainability
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses concrete real-world examples — the NAACP and the San Joaquin County merger — to illustrate abstract principles of nonprofit management.
- Balances the tension between nonprofit mission and business discipline, acknowledging both without dismissing either.
- Grounds claims in direct quotations from La Piana's published client stories, lending credibility to the analysis.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied case study analysis: it takes a consulting firm's documented client engagements and uses them to validate a broader theoretical claim — that nonprofits benefit from for-profit management practices. Each example is tied back to that central thesis rather than presented as an isolated anecdote.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by introducing La Piana Consulting and its guiding philosophy. It then moves through two detailed client examples — the NAACP mission refinement and the Women's Center/FAYS merger — using each to illustrate specific business tools (benchmarking, change management, cultural integration). The conclusion synthesizes these examples into a broader argument about nonprofit viability and accountability.
La Piana Consulting's Core Mission and Philosophy
On its official website, La Piana Consulting identifies its core mission as improving leadership and management practices within the nonprofit sector so that nonprofits can change the world. As noted in Andreasen and Kotler (2007), La Piana is motivated by the belief that nonprofits function best when they are run like for-profit organizations. Strategic planning, business planning, corporate restructuring, change management, and governance are all examples of services La Piana's firm provides to nonprofits — services that have, until recently, been traditionally associated with for-profit entities.
Applying Business Principles to the NAACP
Some of La Piana's client organizations include Habitat for Humanity, which it assisted with organization-wide restructuring, and the NAACP, which La Piana helped refine its vision and mission statement. That refined mission centered on the core tenets of "Economic Sustainability, Education, Health, Public Safety and Criminal Justice, and Voting Rights and Political Representation" ("NAACP," 2018, par. 1). What is particularly noteworthy about this outcome is that La Piana ensured the organization stayed true to its original values while creating a new, more concise, and future-focused agenda to lead the historic civil rights organization forward.
Facilitating a Successful Nonprofit Merger
La Piana's work with organizations also includes facilitating the merger between the Women's Center of San Joaquin County (the Women's Center) and Family and Youth Services of San Joaquin County (FAYS). It is conventional wisdom in the business world that mergers often fail because of clashing organizational cultures and values. In this particular case, the merger succeeded — but only because of La Piana's intervention to create structural bridges between complementary organizational actors and to ensure that synergies were generated in a positive manner. Once again, viewing the nonprofit as a business was deemed critical. There was a need to redefine a new yet common purpose that could satisfy members of both formerly separate organizations.
References
Andreasen, A., & Kotler, P. (2007). Strategic marketing for non-profit organizations (7th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson.
A cross-disciplinary partnership enhances services, sustainability, advocacy voice. (2018). http://lapiana.org/stories-our-clients/nonprofit-stories/womens-center-youth-family-services
NAACP. (2018). La Piana. Retrieved from http://lapiana.org/stories-our-clients/nonprofit-stories/naacp
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.