Nursing Ethics, Advance Directives, and Patient Autonomy
This paper examines the ethical and legal dimensions of a clinical case involving a patient whose advance directive was disregarded when healthcare providers proceeded with ventilator intubation. Drawing on the Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA), the ANA Code of Ethics, and HIPAA regulations, the paper analyzes violations of patient autonomy and self-determination, the improper authorization of treatment by an unqualified family member, and breaches of professional nursing conduct. The paper argues that honoring a patient's advance directive is both an ethical imperative and a legal requirement, and concludes by outlining the corrective actions a nurse should have taken to protect the patient's rights throughout the scenario.
- State Regulations and Nursing Standards: PSDA mandates patient rights and advance directive compliance
- The Code of Ethics and Patient Autonomy: Advance directives uphold patient self-determination and autonomy
- Impact of the Ethical Code on Clinical Decisions: Honoring advance directives is a fundamental ethical obligation
- Ethical Implications of Authorizing the Ventilator: Intubation without consent violated autonomy and caused harm
- HIPAA Violations and Professional Conduct: Privacy breaches and nursing failures compounded ethical violations
- Recommended Nursing Response: Correct steps to protect patient rights and advance directive
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds ethical arguments in specific legal frameworks (PSDA, HIPAA, ANA Code of Ethics), giving claims both moral and regulatory authority.
- Moves logically from macro-level legal standards to micro-level professional conduct, building a coherent critique of every party involved in the scenario.
- Concludes with a first-person corrective action plan that demonstrates applied ethical reasoning rather than abstract theorizing.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses a case-analysis structure common in nursing and healthcare ethics courses: it identifies a breach, maps it onto a relevant ethical principle or legal standard, and then derives practical implications. This technique — moving from principle to violation to remedy — is an effective model for applied ethics writing at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by establishing the governing legal standard (PSDA), then introduces the relevant ethical codes (autonomy, self-determination, human dignity). It proceeds through the specific violations in the scenario — the unauthorized ventilator intubation, the HIPAA breaches, and the failures of nursing conduct — before closing with a first-person account of what corrective steps should have been taken. Each section builds directly on the previous one, maintaining a clear argumentative progression throughout.
State Regulations and Nursing Standards
There is a clear nursing standard of practice that must be upheld in this case: adherence to federal law, specifically the Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA). Passed by Congress in 1990, "the law mandates that in healthcare institutions that receive Medicare or Medicaid funding, patients must be informed in writing upon admission of (1) their right to accept or refuse treatment, (2) their rights under existing state laws regarding advance directives, and (3) any policies the institution has regarding the withholding or withdrawing of life-sustaining treatments" (Ulrich, 1999, p. 9).
The implications of the PSDA are clear: patients have the autonomy and independence to direct the course of their care, or to refuse it entirely. Medical professionals carry both an ethical and a legal responsibility to honor the patient's wishes. Mr. E's advance directive should have been addressed immediately and honored from the outset. Much of the confusion and unnecessary speculation in this case could have been avoided had that step been taken from the beginning.
References
ANA. (2001). Code of Ethics for Nurses With Interpretive Statements. Silver Spring: American Nurses Association.
Mitty, E. R. (2008, March). Advanced directive. Retrieved from Consultgerin.org:
Ulrich, L. P. (1999). The Patient Self-Determination Act: Meeting the challenges in patient care. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.