Organizational Development for a Family-Owned Business

Introduction to Hightowers Petroleum Company

Hightowers Petroleum Company is a private company owned by Stephen Hightower. The company is an offspring of a string of family businesses originally started by Yudell Hightower, who relocated to Middletown, Ohio in the 1940s from the cotton fields of Mississippi. Yudell eventually sold his janitorial business and invested the proceeds in his son Stephen Hightower's enterprise. Today, the company employs three generations of Hightowers and continues to distribute gasoline, diesel, biofuels, and related products and services throughout the United States, Canada, Mexico, and Africa.

The company's mission statement reads: "Fueling America's Needs one Customer at a Time." This motto is rooted in the fact that the owner started with one contract and one client — the State of Ohio. He understood that by concentrating all his efforts on delivering excellent service to that single client, he could persuade other clients to engage his company. He went about meeting with various state department buyers to understand their frustrations with managing their fuel supply. He then returned to his office and worked on solutions for each problem, winning the trust of procurement officials by being proactive and attending to their individual needs. Today the company remains focused on being a "big supplier with a small feel to it" — its core differentiator.

Most businesses in the United States are family owned. Their contribution to the economy and to their immediate communities cannot be ignored. However, not all family businesses manage to continue operating across generations — only about a third successfully make the generational transition. This challenge is made more complex by the intricate dynamics involved in running family businesses (Andrews, 2010).

Performance in innovation is often considered crucial for a family business to compete favorably in the market. With growing competition, shorter product cycles, and increased market segmentation, family-owned businesses face the constant need to innovate or risk being out-competed. Strategic posture refers to the way management in an organization responds to demands from the external environment (Ozgener, Oout, Kaplan & Bickes, n.d.). An active posture denotes management deliberately taking steps to meet key stakeholders' expectations, while a passive posture is the opposite — management takes no measures to address those expectations. Both strategies significantly affect innovation performance in any family business. It is equally essential that succession planning receives attention in a family business to ensure smooth transitions to the following generation.

This case study analyzes four organizational diagnostic factors in Hightowers Petroleum Company: (1) ownership, (2) structure, (3) culture, and (4) politics. These are among the most critical factors for the longevity and success of a family business. With the right interventions in each area, the necessary change can take place to develop a strong and prosperous organization.

Ownership: Structures, Assumptions, and Interventions

Bolman and Deal's theoretical framework assumes that the organization resembles a family, with central concepts examining needs, skills, and relationships. It also examines the image of leadership as empowerment and the basic leadership challenge of aligning the organization's needs with the needs of its people. In this case study, it is critical to understand how the metaphor of a family fits into an actual family business and how this affects both family members and non-family members within the organization.

Areas such as ensuring the family maintains control of the business and satisfying the financial needs of both the family and the business must be given careful attention. Family businesses that successfully pass from one generation to the next tend to have open and clearly defined ownership structures — for instance, regulations on the trading of shares. These regulations are often carefully crafted and can remain in effect for as long as 20 years (Caspar, Dias & Elstrodt, 2010).

Some family-owned entities are holding companies that are privately held but have subsidiaries that may trade publicly, while key assets remain under family control. A private family holding company helps avoid conflicts of interest that can arise when institutional investors push competing demands. Most family-owned businesses pay low dividends, channeling earnings back into the company. This is advantageous because issuing new stock is likely to dilute ownership (Caspar, Dias & Elstrodt, 2010).

Some families choose not to accept external investment at all, fueling company growth entirely through reinvested profits. Others bring in private equity to inject needed capital and improve corporate governance, though such arrangements tend to dilute family control. Still others choose to issue an IPO while imposing restrictions on share trading to preserve significant control (Caspar, Dias & Elstrodt, 2010).

When shares must change hands, the recommended first step is to approach siblings and cousins. The holding company may also purchase shares from current family members. Payout policies often reflect a long-term perspective designed to avoid recapitalizing the business. Because of low dividends and exit restrictions, some family businesses have adopted "generational liquidity events" to meet the cash needs of family members. These can include selling publicly traded holdings or selling family shares back to the company or its employees, with proceeds distributed to family members (Caspar, Dias & Elstrodt, 2010).

For navigating developmental stages in the context of ownership, three key guidelines are recommended for Hightowers Petroleum Company. First, regular shareholder meetings should be held to provide a platform for discussing ownership-related issues. Second, establishing directorial and advisory boards serves a long-term purpose, helping the president broaden their perspective. As the organization develops, these boards become increasingly significant, particularly during the Formalization/Expansion and Sibling Partnership developmental stages. A board should be composed of fair, neutral individuals who derive no personal benefit from specific board decisions. Third, business planning should take place across four areas: the strategic business plan, the business contingency plan, the management development unit, and the continuity plan. The board is responsible for assisting the president in developing all four plans (Andrews, 2010).

Competency mapping. In handling family business issues, it is imperative to include some method of obtaining objective assistance. Competency mapping assesses the many facets of professional conduct against dimensions of competency such as quality, strategic capability, and resource management. This process enables systematic scrutiny, collection, and assessment of behavior, providing a structured means of making decisions about employees within the organizational structure of Hightowers Petroleum Company. It helps boost employee morale, improve organizational culture, maximize individuals' fit with their jobs, enhance communication, assist personnel in managing stress, promote teamwork, recognize training needs, facilitate managers' skills development, and more. For family-owned companies specifically, this type of intervention offers the objectivity essential for resolving issues impartially (Sharma, 2012).

Succession planning. Several assessment tools can reveal key individual traits that remain relatively stable across different circumstances and over time. Hightowers Petroleum Company's HR professionals should encourage the company to take advantage of employee promotion and selection tests to achieve better talent management, more accurate assessment of family members interested in joining the company, and more effective development planning throughout the organization. However, the business must also provide opportunities to external candidates (Sharma, 2012).

Nepotism. Nepotism remains a key threat to family business performance. Leaders of all family businesses must decide whether employment in the firm is earned or is treated as a privilege for family members. While fair HR policies require the employment of competent personnel, family members who lack appropriate qualifications are sometimes employed or promoted. Such employees can prove unproductive, contributing little to the company's growth and performance. Beyond individual cases, nepotism-related inequity issues can be addressed to a significant degree by establishing clear organizational HR practices and policies to which all board members are bound (Sharma, 2012).

Dispute resolution. Since family members' workplace disputes often involve personal family matters, it may be best to keep such claims private. Other mandatory options for conflict resolution must therefore be considered. Hightowers Petroleum Company's HR department may need to formulate clear grounds for the termination of family members' employment. Divorce or separation from a key family member, for instance, can lead to immediate discharge. While planning for workplace dispute resolution between family members is a difficult task, it is essential for avoiding future conflict (Sharma, 2012).

Change management. Family-owned companies tend to be slow in accepting change. These businesses are typically unaccustomed to directing funds toward research and development, or to reinvesting profits into technology development. Family members accustomed to higher dividends may be reluctant to forgo them. The company's HR team must understand the significance of change, and should work to convince top managers and non-participative company members that change will ultimately enhance their earning capacity (Sharma, 2012).

Family emotions. All relationships are centered on emotions, and thus the family-owned firm must manage this reality with care. However, emotions in the workplace must remain connected to the business itself rather than to personal family dynamics. Sibling rivalry, ego clashes, alienation, dissatisfaction, and intergenerational conflict are common problems in such companies. The head of the business family plays a key role in ensuring that family emotions do not interfere with business operations. He or she should encourage family members to communicate openly and develop a system for mentoring every family member who enters the business. Management must clearly delineate the boundary between business and family. Hightowers Petroleum's HR unit can assist the family head by recommending appropriate roles for new family entrants and advising on family member mentoring (Sharma, 2012).

Defining authority. Management should clearly define the authority and role associated with every position within the organization in order to avoid conflict and ambiguity. A sense of professionalism must be cultivated in all employees — and particularly among family members. No statement should be interpreted through the lens of personal relationships; every interaction in the workplace is purely business. When younger family members hold higher positions within the company, elder family members must not undermine their authority (Sharma, 2012).

Conclusion and Recommendations

Hightowers Petroleum Company exemplifies both the promise and the complexity of a multigenerational family business. With the right interventions across ownership, structure, culture, and organizational politics, the company can build a strong and prosperous organization capable of enduring further generational transitions. Key priorities include establishing clear, formalized ownership structures; developing strong and independent governance boards; nurturing a values-centered culture that adapts to changing environments; implementing merit-based HR policies that address nepotism and succession; and proactively managing the political dynamics that arise when family and business intersect. These interventions, taken together, provide a coherent organizational development strategy for sustaining Hightowers Petroleum Company's growth and longevity.

Andrews, J. (2010). Managing growth: Best practices of family-owned businesses. Honors Projects in Management. Retrieved from http://digitalcommons.bryant.edu/honors_management/6

Caspar, C., Dias, A., & Elstrodt, H. (2010). The five attributes of enduring family businesses. Retrieved August 1, 2015, from

Ceja, L., & Tapies, J. (2011). Corporate values guiding the world's largest family-owned businesses: A comparison with non-family firms (No. D/916). IESE Business School.

Dyer, W. G. (1988). Culture and continuity in family firms. Family Business Review, 1(1), 37–50.

Ozgener, S., Oout, A., Kaplan, M., & Bickes, M. (n.d.). The effects of organizational politics and strategic posture on innovation performance. Retrieved August 1, 2015, from http://www.isma.info/uploads/files/158-the-effects-of-organizational-politics-and-strategic-posture-on-innovation-performance.pdf

Sharma, E. (2012). HR issues and intervention model for family business. ZENITH International Journal of Business Economics & Management Research, 2(12), 288–297.

Stalk, G., & Foley, H. (2012). Avoid the traps that can destroy family businesses. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved August 17, 2015, from https://hbr.org/2012/01/avoid-the-traps-that-can-destroy-family-businesses

Strategy, structure and organizational culture. (n.d.). Retrieved August 2, 2015, from http://worldanimal.net/documents/2_Strategy.pdf