This paper examines three key marketing decisions facing Paradise Foods around the launch of its Sweet Dream ice cream sandwich product. It considers what would happen if no new products were launched and current La Treat marketing tactics were maintained, evaluates the cannibalization risk posed by introducing a new product line, and assesses whether Sweet Dream should be positioned in the ice cream novelty market rather than the broader dessert category. The analysis draws on product positioning strategy, consumer behavior in premium food markets, and organizational structure considerations to recommend a path forward for Paradise Foods.
If the current marketing tactics were maintained without any new product launches, the La Treat line would eventually lose market share to competitors. Products such as these are called ice cream "novelties" for a reason — even if consumers love the product, they will likely search for something new and different at some point. The relatively high cost and the sophistication of the product make it an indulgence, hence the tagline "Go Ahead — You Deserve It."
The use of premium ingredients — captured in the phrase "Taste the Goodness" — is a marketing strategy that justifies the price when comparing La Treat to other ice cream novelties and desserts. In this high-end market, consumers follow food trends. They are looking for innovation and originality. Promotions will help sales, at least in the short term. Some new customers will try the product simply because they have a coupon. Loyal customers will be pleased to save money on an ice cream product they enjoy and may have purchased anyway.
Over the long term, however, customers will be looking for new and novel products. Paradise Foods will lose market share if it does not recognize that buyers of luxury food items can be fickle. Innovation, not promotion alone, is the key to sustaining a premium product line.
The positioning statement for La Treat is as follows: La Treat is premium vanilla ice cream dipped in penuche fudge and covered with almonds. Come on — you know you deserve it! The statement explains exactly what La Treat is, so consumers do not have to guess. The word "premium" alerts them to the fact that this is an upscale product.
The use of "come on" makes the pitch more personal, as if La Treat's creators are speaking directly to an individual. The ice cream — with fudge and almonds — is an indulgence, and the "come on" acts as a whisper of temptation, encouraging consumers to enjoy this guilty pleasure. After all, they deserve it.
"Internal cannibalization risk and brand manager incentives"
"Sweet Dream as novelty versus dessert category"
You’re 48% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.