This paper examines three landmark films — Brian De Palma's Scarface (1983), Mira Nair's Mississippi Masala (1991), and Spike Lee's Do the Right Thing (1989) — as cinematic explorations of ethnic identity, racial tension, and intercultural assimilation in America. The paper analyzes how each film uses its community setting and characters to critique the social pressures of Americanization, class struggle, and the elusive American Dream. Through close readings of character archetypes and social backdrops, the paper argues that all three films present realist portraits of marginalized communities navigating racial discrimination, cultural preservation, and economic hardship in the United States.
The paper demonstrates comparative film analysis, using sociological concepts such as ethnogenesis, pigmentocracy, Orientalism, and Anglo-conformity to frame its readings. Rather than simply summarizing plot, it applies theoretical vocabulary to interpret how each film constructs and critiques racial and cultural identity.
The paper opens with a broad claim about Hollywood and ethnic representation, then moves sequentially through each film before converging in a thematic synthesis. Each film section introduces its social-historical backdrop, identifies the key character archetype, and connects it to the overarching themes of Americanization and class. The conclusion zooms out to affirm film's role as a medium for social critique.
Over the years, Hollywood and independent filmmakers have taken the concept of "American identity" and given audiences an opportunity to view the multi-faceted ethnicity of community-based ethics and interracial harmonies — or the lack thereof. America has become a melting pot of cultures and beliefs that have had to fight off social stereotypes and resist Anglo-conformity.
Directors like Brian De Palma, Mira Nair, and Spike Lee have taken their audiences into the heart of ethnic racism in communities and the struggles some cultures face in order to survive against Americanization and the paradox of achieving their "American Dream."
In De Palma's remake of Scarface, the 1980 Mariel boatlift from Cuba formed the backdrop and set the stage for Tony Montana's desire to gradually manifest his destiny — a journey that ultimately leads to his self-destruction.
Drawing on historical fact involving the North Miami refugee camps, including Freedom Town, and the social scene of the early 1980s, Scarface is a testimony to interracial struggles that continue today, as well as the underworld element that still exists in the United States. The stereotype of "Chicano" drug cartels, "Pachuco" youths, and gangs continues to plague many communities today, either through their attempts to co-exist with drug gangs or through social ignorance.
Another film that explores intercultural assimilation is Mira Nair's Mississippi Masala, in which an African-American man and an East Indian woman pursue a romantic relationship. Besides drawing on Southern attitudes toward African-Americans, Nair introduces East Indian views on miscegenation — mixed marriages — as her characters strive to retain their cultural identity within an otherwise Western-ideology-dominated environment.
In this film, community is an integral part of daily life, acting as a constant reminder of the "old ways." Masala is an Indian mixture of spices, and the word serves as an archetype for the society surrounding Demetrius and Mina. Mina's family are refugees of a sort — much like Tony Montana in Scarface — having fled Uganda in the wake of Idi Amin Dada's regime.
Both families protest the relationship, not because it is interracial per se, but out of fear that their own identities will be swallowed up by racism and another culture. There is a fear that ethnogenesis will wither away and communities will evolve into a caricature of traditions and beliefs, where materialism and the "American Dream" outrank traditional customs, dress, language, and even food. Nair artistically tells her story through these traditions and customs as they interplay with American culture and style.
All three of these films draw from social and historical backgrounds that allow their stories to be showcased in realism. Cinematography doesn't involve special effects or over-the-top productions, but lets the characters speak to the audiences. We are then able to relate to the different plights and sympathize with characters like Tony Montana, Mookie, and Mina, who are all trying to survive in a world that is otherwise ready to discriminate against them because of their ethnic identities.
You’re 42% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.