Race, Regionalism, and Rights in Snow Falling on Cedars
This paper examines David Guterson's novel Snow Falling on Cedars and its 1999 film adaptation through the lenses of race, regionalism, and rights. It explores how the fictional San Piedro Island functions as both a specific Pacific Northwest setting and a universal microcosm of American racial prejudice in the postwar era. The analysis covers the symbolism of the snowstorm, the land dispute at the center of the murder trial, the internment of Japanese-Americans, and the reciprocal nature of racial bias between white and Japanese-American communities. The paper also considers the regionalist literary tradition and how nature serves as a space where social boundaries are both enforced and transcended.
- Introduction: Landscape, Law, and Racial Tension: Novel and film frame race through island setting and trial
- Regionalism as Literary and Artistic Framework: Regionalist tradition contextualizes San Piedro's isolation
- Gender, Desire, and Racial Othering: Ishmael's desire for Hatsue reflects racial othering
- Reciprocal Racial Bias and Internment: Racial bias flows in both directions on the island
- Snow, Stereotype, and the Courtroom: Blizzard symbolizes blind prejudice trapping the community
- Land Rights, the American Dream, and Japanese Internment: Land dispute rooted in internment and racial inequality
- Resolution, Nature, and the Limits of Justice: Ishmael's revelation exposes racism's cost and nature's neutrality
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It layers multiple analytical frameworks — regionalism, race theory, and gender — onto a single text, showing how they reinforce one another rather than competing.
- The use of specific film timestamps and direct quotations from critics, sociologists, and military figures grounds abstract claims in concrete evidence.
- The paper consistently connects the fictional island setting to broader American historical realities, such as Japanese internment and postwar racial stratification, giving the local analysis national significance.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper employs symbolic close reading to connect environmental details — the snowstorm, the courthouse, the landscape — to thematic arguments about racial prejudice and legal injustice. By treating the weather, architecture, and geography as active participants in the narrative rather than mere backdrop, the analysis demonstrates how literary and film criticism can read setting as argument.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a thematic introduction that situates the novel and film within issues of race and regionalism. It then defines regionalism as a literary-artistic movement before moving into character-centered analysis of gender dynamics and interracial desire. Subsequent sections address reciprocal racial bias, the symbolic function of the snowstorm, the history of Japanese internment as it shapes the land dispute plot, and finally the film's resolution and its implications for racial justice. The conclusion returns to the nature-versus-civilization contrast established early in the paper.
Introduction: Landscape, Law, and Racial Tension
Literature is an art form that can convey love, hate, beauty, and ugliness. In the form of novels, literature has the capacity to challenge and reflect upon cultural and societal dilemmas. David Guterson's novel Snow Falling on Cedars and its 1999 film adaptation illuminate the issues that a young Japanese-American man faces when he is accused of murdering a white fisherman in the state of Washington. On the surface, the story is a mystery that focuses on whether the young man is guilty, but on a deeper level, the novel is a narrative that contrasts the stark ugliness of racial intolerance with the beauty of the Washington island setting.
Taking place on the fictional San Piedro Island, part of the Puget Sound area of Washington, racial tensions run extremely high between members of the Caucasian majority and the smaller population of Japanese-Americans who cohabitate on the island. One of the principal characters, Kazuo Miyamoto, is on trial accused of murdering the son of a former colleague of his father's, as part of a broader struggle over land rights for the Miyamoto family. While the film's rejection of white racism is unsurprising, its focus on the landscape of the island suggests a more interesting technique for advocating tolerance and diversity. In the film, the land itself becomes a site where universal acceptance can be imagined. Natural settings are the places where a forbidden love grows, and nature serves as a silent observer of Kazuo's trial.
The legal procedures metaphorically represent the racially biased feelings of the people of Washington, who judge Miyamoto not so much for what he has done, but for who he is — a line later spoken by Kazuo's elderly lawyer in the film. Regionalism in the film is played out in an intriguing and somewhat paradoxical manner. On the one hand, it is clear from the dialogue and flashbacks that the people of San Piedro are very proud of their island and consider it an isolated community with a distinct culture. On the other hand, one learns very little about the actual physical location of the island over the course of the book and film, and the information provided is scarce. In this way, the regionalism is at once quite present and specific, yet simultaneously non-descript — this island could be any coastal island in the United States that lies at a high enough latitude to receive snow. The novel and film want to alert audiences that while these events take place on a specific island at a specific point in American history, the trial and its prejudicial sentiments could have occurred anywhere in the country. The regionalism in the narrative is prominent and strong, specific and non-specific at once.
Regionalism as Literary and Artistic Framework
Regionalism was an art movement that grew out of the Modernist movement. Beginning in the 1930s, regionalism focused on realistic representations of the world outside the artist's windows. Regionalist artworks depicted the American heartland and offered hope and inspiration that a better future was possible for those who persevered. In literature, the regionalist movement is seen in works that focus on rural locations, local characters, and small communities serving as microcosms of the larger world. Such a technique is employed within Snow Falling on Cedars. Author Josephine Donovan writes that regionalism "depict[s] authentic regional detail, including authentic dialect, authentic local characters, in real or realistic geographical settings" (50). The heart of the movement was a turning away from large metropolitan cities and a re-embrace of the rural community, which had fallen out of favor during the Industrial Revolution. This included depictions of landscapes and the placement of people within natural settings.
Central to the relationship between Ishmael and Hatsue is their exploration of and time spent in natural settings. Nature is an essential element of their passion and romance, both in its innocence and in its intensity. The regionalist movement was grounded in the understanding of outsider versus insider — a concept central to traditional Japanese culture — as well as rural versus urban, themes which are both present in Snow Falling on Cedars. The island off the coast of Washington is extremely rural and isolated. The audience feels the remoteness and wilderness of the island through many scenes in the film; in the middle of the movie, for example, one can see a stand of redwood trees with barely a bird's call to break the silence (1:49:53). The island is thus separated from the rest of the United States and the rest of the world, yet connected through the opinions and prejudices of those who live there.
Gender, Desire, and Racial Othering
Another theme that reflects the regionalist artistic perspective is the conflict between feminine and masculine identities. In regionalism, the tension between accepted social groups is an extremely important factor. Snow Falling on Cedars shows this conflict in a multitude of ways, one of the most important being the dichotomy between reporter Ishmael Chambers and the main female character, Kazuo's wife Hatsue. Ishmael finds himself inextricably drawn to the young woman. He desires her both sexually and emotionally. They share a past that is intensely intoxicating and verges on obsessive, at least on Ishmael's part. There are many reasons for this attraction, not the least of which is that as a woman of Japanese heritage, Hatsue represents the idealized exotic and unobtainable object of affection. As children, part of what made Hatsue so appealing was her "otherness" — because she was othered by the community, the two were forced to keep their relationship a secret (Hrezo). He is drawn to her because she is exotic and different, yet simultaneously he looks down upon her and others her. The structure of the courthouse, in which white citizens occupy positions of institutional power, provides a visual reinforcement of this dynamic.
References
Bayly, Michael J. "Theological Reflections on Scott Hicks' Snow Falling on Cedars." 2000. Print.
Campbell, Donna M. "Regionalism and Local Color Fiction, 1865–1895." Web. Nov. 2012. http://public.wsu.edu/~campbelld/amlit/lcolor.html
Donovan, Josephine. New England Local Color Literature: A Woman's Tradition. New York, NY: Ungar, 1983. Print.
Dypedahl, Magne. "Reading Snow Falling on Cedars as Historical (Crime) Novel."
Hrezo, Margaret S. "Snow Falling on Cedars." Law and Politics Book Review. 18:4. 2008. 325–27. Print.
Snow Falling on Cedars. Dir. Scott Hicks. Prod. Ron Bass. Screenplay by Ron Bass and Scott Hicks. Perf. Ethan Hawke and Youki Kudoh. Universal Pictures, 1999. DVD.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.