Self-Compassion and Social Media in Rehabilitation Counseling
This paper critiques and compares two studies focused on improving rehabilitation counseling practice. Stuntzner (2014) reviews the concept of self-compassion as a construct applicable to counseling persons with disabilities, arguing it can reduce negative thoughts and promote positive outcomes. Hartley, Johnston, and Tarvydas (2015) examine social media advocacy as a tool for reducing client marginalization and building connectivity. Both studies rely on literature reviews, presenting Level V evidence, and both conclude with practical recommendations for counselors. The paper highlights their shared emphasis on fostering positivity in clients' lives while noting that neither study provides quantitative assessment to strengthen their evidence base.
- Introduction: Overview of both studies and paper's purpose
- Stuntzner (2014): Self-Compassion in Rehabilitation Counseling: Self-compassion as a counseling construct for disability
- Hartley, Johnston, and Tarvydas (2015): Social Media Advocacy: Social media as a tool to reduce client marginalization
- Comparative Analysis of Both Studies: Shared methodology, themes, and Level V evidence
- Conclusions and Limitations: Recommendations, implementation guidance, and study limitations
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Clearly identifies the purpose of each study before drawing comparisons, giving readers a solid foundation for understanding the critique.
- Uses a parallel structure to discuss both studies — examining methodology, findings, and recommendations in the same order for each — making the comparison easy to follow.
- Connects both studies to a shared theme (building positivity in patients' lives), which grounds the comparison in a meaningful clinical insight rather than surface-level similarities.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative critique, a technique in which two sources are evaluated side by side against shared criteria — in this case, methodology (literature review), level of evidence (Level V), and practical applicability. By applying the same evaluative lens to both studies, the writer shows not only what each study found but also where both fall short, specifically their lack of quantitative data.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief framing introduction, then summarizes each study individually before moving into a direct comparison of their methodologies and themes. It concludes by discussing shared recommendations and shared limitations. This classic compare-and-contrast structure — describe, then analyze together — is well-suited to short academic critique papers at the undergraduate level.
Introduction
Stuntzner's (2014) study on the concept of self-compassion as a component in rehabilitation counseling and the study by Hartley, Johnston, and Tarvydas (2015), which focuses on the use of social media advocacy in rehabilitation counseling, both examine ways that rehabilitation counseling can be improved through the implementation of different variables. This paper critiques and compares the two studies and shows how their findings can be used to help rehabilitation counselors advance their profession in the field.
Stuntzner (2014): Self-Compassion in Rehabilitation Counseling
Stuntzner's (2014) article is based on a literature review of the concept of self-compassion as a construct, with the aim of determining how this idea might be applied to rehabilitation counseling to help reduce "negative thoughts, feelings, and outcomes while also promoting positive ones" (p. 37). Stuntzner's findings indicate that self-compassion is a concept that can be more clearly defined and utilized by counselors to assist in the healing of persons with disabilities.
References
Hartley, M., Johnston, S., & Tarvydas, V. (2015). The ethics and practice of social media advocacy in rehabilitation counseling. Journal of Rehabilitation, 81(1), 42–51.
Stuntzner, S. (2014). Compassion and self-compassion: Exploration of utility as potential components of the rehabilitation counseling profession. Journal of Applied Rehabilitation Counseling, 45(1), 37–44.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.