Service Quality and the Marketing Mix at Club Pacha NYC

Introduction

Club Pacha has successfully differentiated itself from many nightclubs and entertainment venues in Manhattan by concentrating on a unique four-floor design that assures customers a distinctive experience. Given that the nightclub industry was severely impacted by the recession — yielding a -0.9% growth rate from 2005 to 2010 and only 2.8% growth from 2010 to 2015, with total revenues of $89.1 billion — every nightclub must strive to be sufficiently unique in the experiences it offers to generate return customers. From a marketing standpoint, this is not particularly easy, as there are 199,401 nightclubs in operation across the United States, and the Manhattan and greater New York metro area is widely regarded as the most competitive and affluent nightclub market nationally, if not globally. For Club Pacha to have survived and thrived during a recession, the experiences it delivers to customers must have not only met but exceeded expectations.

The club is also well attuned to what it is actually selling: an eclectic, high-energy experience and, in its VIP Services area, exclusivity and elegance. All of these experiential elements are what successful marketers rely on when integrating the marketing mix and strategies of their firms (McAdam & Pine II, 2006). Each of the extended attributes of the marketing mix is analyzed and assessed in this paper using the Gap Model of Service Quality (Candido & Morris, 2000). Recommendations are also made regarding how Club Pacha can increase the quality of its execution across each extended marketing mix factor, all coordinated to deliver an exceptional customer experience on a consistent basis. Pervading this analysis is the recognition that excellence in marketing — especially services marketing — is oriented toward service delivery, service recovery when a customer is dissatisfied, and gap analysis for evaluating variances between expected and perceived service quality levels (Crosby, 2010).

Environment of the Firm

The economic environment in which the firm operates is highly fragmented, owing to the many psychographic groups that prefer nightclubs as a way to socialize with friends and celebrate special occasions, including New Year's Eve. These psychographic groups are defined more by their shared interests and tastes in music and venue type than strictly by age (Berger, 1993).

A common set of demographic factors does emerge from an analysis of the psychographic attributes of nightclub customers. First, customers with incomes of $50,000 or higher generate 70% or more of the revenues in higher-end nightclubs that include restaurant facilities. Generation Y consumers, born in the mid-1980s, prefer entertainment that is interactive — including venues that offer WiFi access and strong cell phone coverage. The focus on experiences among Gen Y consumers is driven by the need to define personal identity through entertainment and leisure activities (McAdam & Pine II, 2006). High-income Gen Y consumers constitute the primary market for high-end nightclubs and restaurants and are the primary force behind the development of multi-experience venues, which Club Pacha exemplifies through its four-floor design. From a competitive standpoint, Gen Y consumers are the segment that nightclubs attempt to win loyalty from through frequent-visitor programs and special promotions. This segment defines the overall marketing mix of many clubs throughout the New York metro region and across the United States more broadly.

From a government and legal standpoint, city and county food-quality, fire, and safety regulations impose significant ongoing costs on Club Pacha's operations, as taxes funding these services are included in every transaction. Property taxes are also substantial and require the club to generate considerable revenue to meet them. Insurance companies often require city taxes to be paid on a biannual basis, as may the mortgage company or property owner. These considerations make owning a business and its building costly and central to financing strategy. Club Pacha must also carry liability insurance, as the City of New York requires compliance for establishments that operate as public meeting places. Taken together, all of these factors define the club's cost structure and contribute to its breakeven point on a monthly and yearly basis. For an operation of Club Pacha's scale, maintaining compliance also protects the club's image and reputation — being in compliance reinforces brand credibility and supports long-term continued operations.

Because the club's primary customer base is composed of young, educated, higher-income Gen Y consumers accustomed to Internet access, providing WiFi coverage and locating in an area with strong cell phone reception is critical. The majority of the club's primary target market is active on social networks — using Twitter, Facebook, Foursquare, text messaging, and email to stay connected. Providing high-bandwidth WiFi across all four floors, ideally with multiple wireless routers per floor, is therefore an essential success factor. WiFi access also reinforces the overall experience of being at the club and makes the venue synonymous with connectivity and convenience. From a social and cultural standpoint, the club must bring all of these environmental elements together to ensure that a truly differentiated experience is created for its customers. With four floors, Club Pacha can also define unique experiences for each area, including customizing individual floors for specific parties or events — further deepening differentiation.

Extended Marketing Mix

The following extended marketing mix is analyzed using the Gap Model of Service Quality (Candido & Morris, 2000) to determine how Club Pacha can better manage the gaps between customers and providers, the relationship between expected and perceived service, and the analysis of service delivery.

Club Pacha's service and experience delivery constitute the product being analyzed under the Gap Model of Service Quality. All aspects of the club — from the initial visit, through the exploration of each floor open to the public, to the quality of interactions with hostesses and staff — contribute to perceived service. How the club promotes itself in terms of its unique experiential value, the service commitments it makes, and the implied service value are all part of any gap analysis (Booms & Bitner, 1981). Advertising, promotion, and the intensive use of social media — including Facebook fan pages and YouTube videos — all shape the perceived service level of the club. The experiences patrons have either validate and strengthen that perception or lead to dissatisfaction and reduced likelihood of returning.

For Club Pacha's senior management, the central challenge is to use the continued development of new experiences to sustain a consistent level of expected performance over time that aligns with the perceived experience. New service offerings must concentrate on keeping expected and perceived expectations aligned in order to ensure long-term customer satisfaction (Candido & Morris, 2000). New offerings must also stay focused on minimizing and eliminating the potential for large gaps between expected and perceived quality by setting overall expectations at a realistic level. This is especially important for special events — ensuring, for example, that entertainment booked for New Year's Eve can reliably perform, keeping costs at levels that allow loyal customers to introduce friends to the club, and continuously identifying how unmet consumer expectations can be transformed into new service programs. This cycle must be ongoing in order to keep the club relevant to patrons over time (Crosby, 2010).

The location of the club is the catalyst through which expectations are set and maintained throughout the relationship cycles the club has with its customers. Place must be highly differentiated, genuinely unique, and oriented toward entertainment and exceptional value for the time and money invested. The focus must also encompass how to design the place or location so that it is eclectic enough to meet the diverse expectations of the customer base.

When the Gap Model of Service Quality is applied to Place, many strategic marketing considerations arise. First, it is essential to ensure that the location itself does not independently generate the need for service recovery. This can occur when the quality of different areas within a venue varies so significantly that customers perceive large differences in their experiences across floors. As Club Pacha's website and marketing materials demonstrate, each floor is designed to be unique yet consistent in quality — with regard to sound systems, seating, lighting, and dance floor design. These factors differentiate the club as a whole while also supporting consistency between expected and perceived service. The necessity of service recovery is reduced when each floor maintains the same level of quality. The VIP service area, which overlooks another floor, can further be used in marketing to accentuate exclusivity and underscore the club's unique value proposition.

All of these factors work together to minimize variation in perceived versus expected service delivery and reduce the potential for service recovery situations. Place is one of the most powerful marketing attributes for ensuring that expectations are consistently set and met. Accuracy in promotional claims is essential for minimizing service quality gaps. The club's management could further define areas for specific occasions and feature customer testimonials on their YouTube channel. Leveraging social media to underscore the value of its location would also be a highly effective strategy.

Conclusion and Recommendations

Club Pacha's continued success depends on its ability to align the entire extended marketing mix with the expectations it sets across its promotional channels and pricing strategy. Using the Gap Model of Service Quality as a diagnostic and strategic tool across all seven Ps — product, place, promotion, price, people, physical evidence, and process — reveals both the strengths of the club's differentiated positioning and the areas where gaps between expected and perceived service remain. Management should prioritize closing these gaps through more honest promotional messaging, consistent physical evidence, investment in well-trained staff, and process improvements that keep service delivery reliable even at peak capacity. By continuously monitoring and managing the alignment between customer expectations and actual service delivery, Club Pacha can strengthen brand loyalty, reduce the frequency and cost of service recovery, and sustain its competitive advantage in one of the world's most demanding nightlife markets.

References

Berger, C. et al. (1993). Kano's methods for understanding customer-defined quality. Center for Quality of Management Journal, 2(4), 3–36.

Booms, B. H., & Bitner, M. J. (1981). Marketing strategies and organization structures for service firms. In J. H. Donnelly & W. R. George (Eds.), Marketing of services (pp. 47–52). American Marketing Association.

Candido, C. J. F., & Morris, D. S. (2000). Charting service quality gaps. Total Quality Management, 11(4–6), S463–S472.

Crosby, L. (2010). The experienced relationship. Marketing Management, 19(2), 10.

Dagger, T. S., & O'Brien, T. K. (2010). Does experience matter: Differences in relationship benefits, satisfaction, trust, commitment and loyalty for novice and experienced service users. European Journal of Marketing, 44(9/10), 1528–1552.

Ha, H., & John, J. (2010). Role of customer orientation in an integrative model of brand loyalty in services. The Service Industries Journal, 30(7), 1025.

Lester, D. L., & Parnell, J. A. (2008). Firm size and environmental scanning pursuits across organizational life cycle stages. Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 15(3), 540–554.

Marsella, A., Stone, M., & Banks, M. (2005). Making customer analytics work for you! Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing, 13(4), 299–303.

McAdam, P., & Pine II, B. J. (2006, November). Customer experiences rule. Banking Strategies, 82(6), 50–62.