Setting and Symbolism in John Updike's "A&P"
This essay examines the role of setting in John Updike's short story "A&P" and its effect on the plot and theme. The essay argues that the supermarket setting functions as a symbol of homogenous, consumerist American society, placed in stark contrast with the natural world represented by the beach. Through Sammy's perspective, the analysis traces how the entrance of three girls in bathing suits disrupts the artificiality of the store, how supporting characters reinforce the theme of conformity, and how the manager's confrontation crystallizes the incompatibility of the two worlds. The essay draws on textual evidence to show how Updike uses setting, character naming, and language to critique mid-twentieth-century American consumer culture.
- Introduction: The Supermarket as Symbol: Setting established as symbol of consumerist society
- The Girls as Natural Intruders: Girls represent natural freedom disrupting artificial order
- Consumers as a Conformist Herd: Shoppers portrayed as automatic, non-individual consumers
- The Manager's Confrontation and Two Incompatible Worlds: Manager's words crystallize the two opposing worlds
- Conclusion: Natural and artificial worlds remain irreconcilable
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It consistently ties textual evidence — direct quotations from the story — back to the central symbolic argument, rather than summarizing plot alone.
- It builds its analysis around a clear binary opposition (the natural world of the beach versus the artificial world of the supermarket), giving the argument a focused, coherent structure.
- It enriches the reading by connecting Updike's story to an outside literary reference (Ginsberg's "A Supermarket in California"), demonstrating broader cultural awareness.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates close reading as an analytical method. Rather than simply describing what happens, the author examines specific word choices — "Queenie," "white shoulders," the manager's repeated phrase "this is not the beach" — and unpacks their symbolic significance within the story's thematic framework. This technique shows how meaning is generated through language and detail, not just narrative event.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by situating the story within its socioeconomic context and stating the central symbolic argument. It then moves through three layers of textual analysis: the girls as symbols of natural freedom, the other shoppers as symbols of conformist consumption, and the manager's confrontation as the climactic expression of the two worlds' incompatibility. A brief conclusion reinforces the thematic stakes with an intertextual reference to Ginsberg.
Introduction: The Supermarket as Symbol
The central theme of John Updike's short story "A&P" is rooted in some of the most important socioeconomic changes brought about by the twentieth century. The story's setting in a modern supermarket — and even its title — signals a focus on the nature of American society: consumerist, homogenous, and hostile to individualism. Updike constructs two antithetical worlds within the narrative: the artificial world of the supermarket and the natural world of the beach. These two worlds are placed in direct opposition throughout the story.
The contrast between them is emphasized by the point of view from which the story is told — that of Sammy, a teenage clerk who cannot quite articulate the differences between the two worlds but who intuitively rebels against the rigid, consumerist society. His rebellion takes the form of a seemingly "heroic" gesture: quitting his job and defending the girls in front of the store manager. The setting is therefore symbolic, underscoring the stark contrast between the artificial and the natural.
The Girls as Natural Intruders
The two worlds are thrown into opposition from the story's abrupt opening, when the entrance of the girls registers as a breach in the monotony and artificiality of the supermarket: "In walks these three girls in nothing but bathing suits" (Kennedy and Gioia, 128). Sammy's naive description of the girls carries its own special symbolism. The name he gives to his preferred girl — Queenie — suggests a different world entirely, perhaps even a fairy-tale one. Queenie's defiance is further amplified by the fact that the straps of her bathing suit are down, intensifying the sense of freedom that the girls collectively project.
This spirit of defiance is also expressed spatially: the girls move against the store's established flow of traffic. As Sammy observes, "The sheep pushing their carts down the aisle — the girls were walking against the usual traffic (not that we have one-way signs or anything) — were pretty hilarious" (Kennedy and Gioia, 128). Their physical movement against the current of the other shoppers becomes a visual metaphor for their resistance to the conformist order of the supermarket world.
Conclusion
Updike's use of setting in "A&P" is ultimately a vehicle for social critique. By placing the story in a supermarket and contrasting it with the offstage world of the beach, he creates a symbolic landscape in which the tension between consumerism and natural freedom plays out in miniature. Sammy's rebellion — impulsive, perhaps naïve, but genuine — enacts the story's central argument: that the artificial order of consumer society and the natural world are irreconcilable, and that choosing one means leaving the other behind entirely.
Works Cited
Kennedy, X. J., and Dana Gioia. An Introduction to Fiction. New York: Longman, 2005.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.