Stand Your Ground vs. Duty to Retreat: The Case for Repeal
This essay argues that Stand Your Ground laws, adopted across many Southern and Western states, should be repealed in favor of Duty to Retreat or Castle Doctrine statutes. The paper presents two primary arguments: first, Stand Your Ground laws are less effective deterrents of violence than Duty to Retreat laws and are correlated with rising homicide rates; and second, these laws can be — and have been — invoked to justify shooting law enforcement officers. Drawing on case studies from Florida, Nevada, Georgia, Texas, and Louisiana, as well as scholarly and legal sources, the paper contends that a retreat-first framework promotes safer, more rational conflict resolution and that Stand Your Ground's "shoot first" mentality endangers both civilians and police.
- Introduction: Two Legal Frameworks: Contrasts Stand Your Ground and Duty to Retreat by state
- Stand Your Ground States vs. Duty to Retreat States: State-by-state evidence linking law to higher violence
- Case Studies in Stand Your Ground Violence: Named cases where Stand Your Ground justified homicide
- How Stand Your Ground Negatively Impacts the Law Enforcement Community: Law used to justify shooting police officers
- Conclusion: Call to repeal Stand Your Ground to reduce violence
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its argument in concrete, named case studies — Zimmerman/Martin, Joe Horn, Byron Thomas, Bo Morrison, Paul Burgarello, Keenan Finkelstein, and Elton Bandoo — giving the legal critique real-world specificity rather than relying on abstraction alone.
- It makes an original and underappreciated second argument: that Stand Your Ground can be used against the police, which broadens the paper's appeal beyond the usual civilian-victim framing and strengthens the case for repeal.
- The geographic contrast between Northeastern Duty to Retreat states and Southern/Western Stand Your Ground states provides a structural organizing principle that makes the comparative argument easy to follow.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses a comparative policy analysis structure, systematically contrasting two legal regimes across multiple dimensions — legislative design, empirical outcomes, and specific incidents — before drawing a normative conclusion. Citing a mix of peer-reviewed law review articles, working papers (NBER), and news reporting gives the argument both scholarly grounding and illustrative depth.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a geographic and philosophical contrast between the two legal frameworks, then states its thesis. The body is divided into two main argumentative sections: the first surveys state-by-state evidence that Stand Your Ground increases violence, while the second focuses specifically on the law's threat to police. A brief conclusion restates the call for repeal. The structure is linear and thesis-driven, making it accessible as an undergraduate policy essay.
Introduction: Two Legal Frameworks
Florida, Georgia, Texas, Louisiana, North Carolina, and Nevada have all passed Stand Your Ground laws, whereas Maryland, New York, New Jersey, Rhode Island, Connecticut, and Delaware have all adopted Duty to Retreat or Castle Doctrine laws. Simply acknowledging the geographical location of these states and their respective laws reveals a common theme: Northeastern states take a more cautious approach, requiring that a person retreat to a place of safety if possible rather than impose violence on another; Southern states, by contrast, hold a more assertive position — if one has a right to be somewhere, one has a right to fend off any attack and to use physical force if physical force is used against oneself.
The critical difference between these two perspectives is that the latter is more likely to lead to violence than the former, which essentially holds that violence must be avoided so long as it reasonably can be avoided. (For example, if one is attacked in one's home — considered a "castle" and a secure zone — one has the right to resist the attack with force.) This paper argues for repealing Stand Your Ground laws on two major grounds: first, when compared to Duty to Retreat and Castle Doctrine laws, they are far less effective deterrents of violence (Lave, 2013; McClellan & Tekin, 2012); and second, Stand Your Ground laws can be invoked to defend civilians who shoot police officers.
References
Cameron, D., & Higgins, W. (2014). Florida's Stand Your Ground law. Tampa Bay Times. Retrieved from
Collins, D. (2013). Lawmaker calls for stand your ground law in Maryland. WBALTV. Retrieved from http://www.wbaltv.com/politics/lawmaker-calls-for-stand-your-ground-law-in-maryland/21581192
Del Pozo, E. (2008). Retreat does not equal surrender: Defensive deadly force in dwellings after People v. Aiken. St. John's Law Review, 82(1), 359–382.
Flatow, N. (2014). Florida Stand Your Ground cases. ThinkProgress. Retrieved from http://thinkprogress.org/justice/2014/02/05/3252511/jordan-davis-26-children-teens-died-florida-stand-ground-cases/
Lave, T. (2013). Shoot to kill: A critical look at stand your ground laws. University of Miami Law Review, 67, 827–860.
Lee, S. (2012). Five Stand Your Ground cases you should know about. ProPublica. Retrieved from http://www.propublica.org/article/five-stand-your-ground-cases-you-should-know-about
Martinez, R. (2014). Judge rules against 'Stand Your Ground' defense in cop shooting. RT. Retrieved from https://www.rt.com/usa/judge-against-syg-defense-cop-582/
McClellan, C., & Tekin, E. (2012). Stand your ground laws, homicides, and injuries. National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No. 18187.
McVeigh, K. (2014). Critics say Georgia stand your ground gun law recipe for unnecessary killing. The Guardian. Retrieved from http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/mar/27/georgia-gun-law-stand-your-ground
Rivero, D. (2015). This rapper shot a police officer. Will Stand Your Ground set him free? Fusion. Retrieved from http://fusion.net/story/136443/this-rapper-shot-a-police-officer-will-stand-your-ground-set-him-free/
Sonner, S. (2014). Nevada's stand your ground law in spotlight. Las Vegas Review-Journal. Retrieved from http://www.reviewjournal.com/news/nevada/nevada-s-stand-your-ground-law-spotlight
Vedantam, S. (2013). Stand Your Ground linked to increase in homicides. NPR. Retrieved from http://www.npr.org/2013/01/02/167984117/-stand-your-ground-linked-to-increase-in-homicide
Wallace, P. (2012). Georgia's Stand Your Ground law. GPB. Retrieved from http://www.gpb.org/news/2012/05/07/georgias-stand-your-ground-law
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.