Teacher Ethics: Disagreeing With Principals and Reporting Child Abuse
This paper examines two ethical case studies in teaching practice. The first involves a teacher who disagrees with a principal's decision to ban sports before class and must decide how to respond, including whether to engage on social media. The second case centers on a teacher who discovers signs of physical abuse on a student and must navigate the legal and ethical obligations of reporting suspected child abuse. Drawing on professional codes of conduct and research by Walsh et al. (2005), the paper outlines best-practice guidance for handling both situations, emphasizing private professional communication with school leadership and the importance of teachers understanding mandatory reporting requirements and child protection frameworks.
- Introduction: Two Ethical Dilemmas in Teaching: Overview of two teacher ethics scenarios
- Case Study 1: Disagreeing With the Principal: Teacher disagrees with principal's sports ban
- Professional Advice for Teacher B: Best-practice guidance for handling the disagreement
- Case Study 2: Suspected Child Abuse: Student arrives at school with signs of physical abuse
- Teacher Reporting of Child Abuse: Range of Actions: How teachers should investigate and report suspected abuse
- Implications for Teacher Training and School Administration: Training gaps and systemic recommendations for schools
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The dual case-study format provides concrete, realistic scenarios that ground abstract ethical principles in classroom-level decision-making.
- Each case is structured consistently — background, competing values, range of actions, and implications — giving the analysis a disciplined, professional shape.
- The paper draws on a professional code of conduct and published research (Walsh et al., 2005) to support its recommendations, lending authority beyond personal opinion.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied ethical analysis: for each scenario, it identifies the competing values at stake, surveys possible responses, and recommends a course of action with reference to professional obligations and research evidence. This structured weighing of values against practical consequences is characteristic of professional ethics writing in education.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by framing both cases, then handles each sequentially. Case Study 1 addresses professional disagreement and social media use; Case Study 2 addresses child abuse identification and mandatory reporting. Each section moves from problem identification to ethical framing to actionable advice, closing with systemic implications for teacher training and school administration.
Introduction: Two Ethical Dilemmas in Teaching
The two case studies examined here each present a teacher with a genuine ethical dilemma. In the first, a new staff member — referred to as Teacher B — must decide how to respond after a school principal bans sports and games before class, a decision that has drawn significant criticism on the school's Facebook page. In the second, Teacher C discovers physical marks on a student that suggest abuse at home and must decide what to do in the face of family resistance and institutional complexity. Both cases require teachers to weigh their personal convictions against professional obligations, legal requirements, and the wellbeing of students.
A school has set up a Facebook page maintained by parents and friends of the school. It has attracted many commentators and followers, including several members of the teaching staff. Teacher B, who is new to the staff at the beginning of the year, has joined the online discussions. In the second term of the year, the school head bans games and sports activities before class hours, explaining that students need to be energized and ready for study rather than fatigued from active sport. Teacher B is unhappy with the decision. The decision also draws considerable negative attention and response on the school's Facebook page, beginning with criticism of the head's decision but evolving to include numerous other complaints about the principal and the school. The central question is: what is the most appropriate advice for Teacher B?
Case Study 1: Disagreeing With the Principal
The most significant problem in this case is that Teacher B disagrees with the decision made by the school principal. There is also the separate question of whether it is appropriate for Teacher B to post comments about the issue on the school's Facebook page. It is not unusual for teachers and principals to disagree — they subscribe to varying convictions and perspectives. Principals are generally expected to view matters holistically, while teachers often focus more narrowly on their subject area and immediate classroom responsibilities.
Every principal will, at some point, make decisions that sit poorly with some members of staff. These decisions may touch on daily duties, curriculum, procedures, discipline, policy, or the evaluation of teacher performance. The dilemma is how a member of the teaching team ought to handle disagreement with a decision made by the head of the school. Available literature on best practice suggests a general consensus on how such situations should be managed.
References
Eduflow. (n.d.). Disagreeing with the principal. Retrieved September 22, 2016, from http://eduflow.wordpress.com/2014/09/21/disagreeing-with-the-principal/
American School Counselor Association (ASCA). (n.d.). Personal judgment in reporting abuse. Retrieved September 22, 2016, from
Education Directorate. (n.d.). Teachers' code of professional practice. Retrieved September 22, 2016, from http://www.education.act.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/17692/TeachersCode_ofProfessionalPractice.pdf
Walsh, K., Farrell, A., & Schweitzer, R. (2005). Critical factors in teachers' detecting and reporting child abuse and neglect: Implications for practice. Retrieved September 22, 2016, from http://www.academia.edu/2821874/Critical_factors_in_teachers_detecting_and_reporting_child_abuse_and_neglect_Implications_for_practice
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.