Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,334 words

Improving Teacher Quality in American Education

~7 min read 5 sections Education · Teacher
Abstract

This paper examines what it truly means to improve teacher quality in American schools by reviewing four research articles on teacher characteristics, student achievement, and performance incentives. The paper explores why traditional proxies for teacher quality — such as IQ, certification, grades, and years of experience — show weak correlations with classroom effectiveness. It also addresses the difficulty of measuring student achievement through standardized tests and grade point averages. Finally, it evaluates Victor Lavy's research on merit-based pay incentives and concludes that continued vocational teacher education combined with performance-related financial incentives represent the most cost-effective strategies for raising teaching quality.

Key Takeaways
  • The Call for Better Teachers: Policy rhetoric and research on teacher quality
  • Assessing Teacher Quality Before the Classroom: Weak links between credentials and effectiveness
  • Measuring Student Achievement and Its Limitations: Grade inflation and standardized test shortcomings
  • Incentive-Based Programs and Teacher Performance: Merit pay study results in Israeli schools
  • Conclusion: Toward More Effective Strategies: Best policy options for improving teacher quality
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper grounds its central claim — that "better teachers" is an underspecified policy goal — in concrete research, using multiple studies to expose the gap between popular rhetoric and measurable outcomes.
  • It moves logically from the difficulty of pre-hiring assessment, to the difficulty of measuring student outcomes, to a constructive solution in the form of incentive-based programs, giving the argument a clear forward momentum.
  • The paper draws on a real empirical study (Lavy, 2004) with specific methodological detail, lending credibility to its policy recommendation without overstating the findings.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates effective use of a literature synthesis structure: rather than summarizing each source in sequence, it organizes the evidence thematically — qualifications, outcomes, incentives — and uses each source to build a cumulative argument. This approach allows the writer to identify gaps in the existing research and position one study's findings as the most actionable conclusion.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with a policy hook and then surveys evidence on pre-hiring quality markers (experience, IQ, certification). It pivots to the challenge of measuring student performance and grade inflation before introducing Lavy's merit-pay study as a solution. The conclusion synthesizes findings and extends the lesson to organizational management more broadly, closing with a generalizable takeaway.

Essay 1,334 words

The Call for Better Teachers

How can we improve education in America today? The common answer is: better teachers. But why don't school administrators simply hire "better teachers"? It is not nearly as easy to determine what makes a better teacher as it is to assert that higher-quality educators ought to be hired. By assessing four recent articles on the quality assessment of teaching qualifications, teaching results, student performance, and programs designed to encourage higher teacher performance, a greater degree of clarity and specificity can be brought to the often vague assertion that teaching "quality" needs to improve.

How often has the call for better teachers been sounded when issues of educational policy are debated? The argument goes that it is not more money, longer hours, better facilities, or newer textbooks that are needed — so long as "better teachers" are hired, things will automatically improve. A 2005 article by the Office of Educational Accountability entitled "Teacher Characteristics" cited more than a decade's worth of studies prioritizing the selection of quality educators as key to improving America's schools: "A 1994 national survey by the Public Agenda (Johnson & Immerwahr, 1994) indicated that Americans ranked 'good teachers' as the most important thing public schools need in order to do a good job. A consensus process conducted in 1996 with over 200 Minnesotans also identified 'quality teaching' as the most salient predictive indicator of the success of our system (Bruininks, Bielinski, Danielson, et al., 1996). In 1996, the National Commission on Teaching and America's Future issued their report, What Matters Most: Teaching for America's Future, in which the Council concluded that effective school reform would depend primarily on investments aimed at providing teachers with increased access to the knowledge they need to meet the demands of the profession (as cited in Darling-Hammond, 1998)."

To summarize the findings of both "Teacher Characteristics" and "Teacher Quality and Student Achievement," another quantitative assessment of teacher quality (Darling-Hammond, 2000): "As new standards for student learning have been introduced across the states, greater attention has been given to the role that teacher quality plays in student achievement." The key word is always quality. There is, of course, some truth to the generalization that America needs better educators. However, once one accepts "quality teaching" as the defining goal, one must survey the available research to determine which particular teacher-related variables are most highly correlated with greater levels of student achievement.

4 Sections Hidden · 730 words
Assessing Teacher Quality Before the Classroom210 words
Assessing who will prove to be a good teacher before they enter the classroom is difficult. For instance, there is little strong relationship between measures of IQ…
Measuring Student Achievement and Its Limitations140 words
Of course, when evaluating teacher quality, how does one manage to measure student achievement as well? There may be a growing tendency for teachers and schools to…
Incentive-Based Programs and Teacher Performance230 words
If measuring student achievement is difficult, and thus arriving at an adequate assessment of teaching quality is equally problematic, then how does one improve teacher quality? Educational researcher Victor Lavy suggests that administrators should ask a different…
Conclusion: Toward More Effective Strategies150 words
Of the four articles reviewed, two strategies have emerged as showing a statistically significant improvement in the quality of education: increasing the affordability and availability of continued vocational education in the professional field of teaching (as opposed to subject-area…

Works Cited

Darling-Hammond, L. (2000). Teacher quality and student achievement: A review of state policy evidence. Retrieved April 28, 2005, from

Grades rise while test scores languish. (2001, August 15). Daily Policy Digest. National Center for Policy Analysis.

Lavy, Victor. (2004). Performance pay and teachers' effort, productivity, and grading ethics. National Bureau of Economic Research. Retrieved April 28, 2005, from http://www.nber.org/papers/W10622

Office of Educational Accountability. (2005). Teacher characteristics. Retrieved April 28, 2005, from http://education.umn.edu/oea/II/BestPractices/Admin_and_Policy/TeacherCharacteristics/TeacherCharacteristics.htm

Key Concepts in This Paper
Teacher Quality Merit Pay Student Achievement Grade Inflation Teacher Certification Performance Incentives Standardized Testing Vocational Education Classroom Effectiveness Educational Policy
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Improving Teacher Quality in American Education. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/improving-teacher-quality-american-education-64564

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.