Teaching Ethics in Public Schools: Methods and Controversies
This paper examines the declining ethical standards among American youth and argues that public schools bear a responsibility to address this gap through formal ethics education. It surveys practical classroom techniques for teaching ethics at the elementary level, including ethical dilemma games, flash cards, films, and poster projects. The paper also addresses the central controversy of whether public schools should teach ethics at all, weighing concerns about the separation of church and state against the pressing need for character education. It concludes by outlining a six-step framework for implementing a non-controversial ethics curriculum that incorporates parental input and community consensus.
- Introduction: Ethics and the Role of Schools: Parental mixed signals and the case for school ethics
- Lagging Ethics in the United States Today: Statistics on declining youth moral standards
- Techniques for Teaching Ethics: Classroom methods for elementary ethics education
- Should Ethics Be Taught in Public Schools?: Debate over school responsibility and church-state concerns
- Controversies and Problems in Teaching Ethics: Pitfalls when ethics instruction enters religious territory
- Implementing a Non-Controversial Ethics Program: Glazner's six-step plan for schools
- Conclusion: Public figures' support and call to action
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper moves logically from problem identification (declining youth ethics) to practical solutions (classroom techniques) to policy considerations (church-state concerns and a six-step plan), giving it a coherent argumentative arc.
- Concrete classroom examples — flash cards, films, poster projects, and ethical dilemma games — ground abstract arguments in teachable, grade-appropriate practice.
- The paper acknowledges counterarguments from both religious parents and church-state separatists, demonstrating awareness of multiple stakeholder perspectives.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper effectively uses a problem-solution structure: it first establishes the seriousness of the ethics deficit through statistics and social observation, then pivots to propose concrete pedagogical remedies. This technique is reinforced by citing a named expert's (Glazner's) step-by-step framework, which lends practical authority to the policy recommendations.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an illustrative anecdote about parental mixed signals before transitioning to a formal introduction that states the thesis. Body sections move from diagnosis (declining ethics statistics) to methodology (teaching techniques) to controversy (church-state issues) to resolution (a six-step implementation plan). The conclusion synthesizes supporting voices from public figures and reaffirms the paper's central claim that ethics education benefits all of society.
Introduction: Ethics and the Role of Schools
We want our children to exhibit ethical behavior, yet it is all too common to see adults engaging in decidedly unethical activities in front of their children. What about the mother who tells her child repeatedly about the importance of honesty, and then switches price stickers on items in a department store in front of her child? What kind of example about honesty is she setting? What about the father who tells his child to treat others with kindness, then lets his child hear him shouting obscenities at a driver he thinks cut him off in traffic? Is this really showing his child the traits he wants his child to exhibit? Then there are more subtle ways of showing our children that ethics do not really matter. Parents normally tell their children to treat others as they would want to be treated, but when a story comes on the evening news about someone who cheated an elderly person out of a large sum of money, parents will often laugh and nod admiringly at the ingenuity of the perpetrator, while at the same time remarking about how horrible it is. Mixed signals, anyone?
We want our children to be upright, ethical citizens, but our actions and reactions show them that we do not necessarily practice what we preach. We also, through our actions, show them that we silently condone unethical behavior and even admire it. Children will do what they are shown more often than what they are told. When they see their parents acting in unethical ways, they are going to think that this behavior is acceptable and that their parents really approve of it, in spite of what their parents say.
Since parents are not reliably teaching their children ethical values, who will? Who is best qualified to impart this knowledge? The first institution that comes to mind is the school system. After all, schools teach our children many things — so why not ethics? There is a growing movement in this direction, and it is becoming more common for schools, even at the elementary level, to include ethics in their curricula. Many people see schools as the best hope of producing upright, ethical citizens. Of course, this movement is not without controversy. There are those who think it is not the place of schools to teach ethics, since ethics is akin to morality, and morality goes hand in hand with religion; those who espouse this viewpoint believe that either the churches or the parents should bear that responsibility. This paper discusses the various methods of teaching ethics to public school students, particularly at the elementary level, and addresses whether ethics can be taught in public schools without crossing into religious territory.
References
Glazner, Perry. "Can Public Schools Teach Character?" Citizen Link. 1999.
Madden, Kara. "Getting a Grasp on Ethics." The European Advisers Newsletter. 2002.
Steinman, Sarah O., et al. The Ethical Decision-Making Manual for Helping Professionals. Kentucky: Wadsworth Publishing Company, 1997.
Tiatorio, Anthony. "What Is Ethics?" Ethics in Education. n.d.
Waldfogel, Dean. "Teaching Ethics in the Public Schools." About.Com. 1994.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.