Critical Analysis: Terrorist Use of Weapons of Mass Destruction
This paper applies logic and critical thinking to evaluate the arguments presented in "The Terror Next Time," a 2001 Economist article published shortly after the September 11 attacks. The paper examines the article's central assumption — that terrorists would inevitably use weapons of mass destruction if they obtained them — and systematically assesses the three premises offered: the difficulty of acquiring raw materials, the challenge of manufacturing functional weapons, and the problem of effective delivery. The analysis identifies logical weaknesses in each premise, particularly the author's reliance on the Tokyo subway attack as evidence and the deterrence argument based on state behavior. The paper concludes with a dissent from the article's overall finding.
- Introduction and Context: Overview of article and its post-9/11 audience
- The Central Assumption: Identifying the article's unsupported foundational assumption
- Acquiring Raw Materials and Supplies: Evaluating arguments about WMD material acquisition
- Manufacturing and State Sponsorship: Assessing deterrence argument and state involvement
- Delivering Weapons of Mass Destruction: Critique of delivery premise and Tokyo subway evidence
- Conclusion and Disagreement with the Author: Writer's reasoned dissent from the article's conclusion
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper follows the source article's own internal structure, evaluating each of the three premises in sequence, which makes the critique organized and easy to follow.
- The writer clearly distinguishes between the author's stated assumptions and the evidence offered to support them, a key skill in critical analysis.
- The conclusion offers a genuine, reasoned dissent rather than simply summarizing — the writer explains why they disagree and ties it back to specific logical flaws identified earlier.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates premise-by-premise argumentation analysis, a core technique in formal critical thinking. Rather than evaluating the article's conclusion in isolation, the writer isolates each claim, assesses its evidentiary support, and identifies where unsupported assumptions do the work that evidence should do. This approach shows how a conclusion can be logically invalid even when individual sub-arguments seem plausible on the surface.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by establishing the article's publication context and audience, then identifies the foundational assumption before moving through each of the three premises in order: acquisition, manufacture, and delivery. Each section notes what the author argues, what evidence is provided, and where the reasoning is weak. The paper closes with the writer's personal assessment, grounded in the logical critique developed throughout.
Introduction and Context
In "The Terror Next Time," the author examines the idea of terrorists using weapons of mass destruction. The author concludes that there are three obstacles facing terrorists who want to use such weapons: finding a supply, turning that supply into a weapon, and delivering the weapon to the target. After investigating these obstacles, the author concludes that the threat of terrorists using weapons of mass destruction is not currently very large. Given that the United States was engaged in a war that began over the suspected presence of weapons of mass destruction in a terrorist-friendly country, this conclusion is significant. Even more notable is the author's caution that as availability increases, so does the threat that terrorists will be able to use weapons of mass destruction against the United States.
"The Terror Next Time" was first published on October 4, 2001, less than one month after the September 11 attacks. As a result, the intended audience differed considerably from a contemporary audience and from the audience of September 10, 2001. While most Americans have since moved past the absolute terror that gripped the country in the first weeks following 9/11, it is not difficult to recall the anxiety of those days. People were purchasing duct tape and rolls of plastic sheeting, preparing to barricade themselves in their homes in the event that terrorists deployed weapons of mass destruction against the United States. The audience for the article was therefore composed of people with a very elevated — though understandable — concern about terrorist use of such weapons. The author acknowledges those fears and attempts to allay them by demonstrating that terrorists did not then have the capability to effectively use weapons of mass destruction.
The Central Assumption
One of the most interesting elements of the article is that it is based largely upon an unstated and unsupported assumption. That assumption is that "were terrorists with so little calculation of restraint to get their hands on weapons of mass destruction — whether chemical, biological, or even nuclear — they would surely use them" ("The Terror Next Time"). While the assumption is stated explicitly, there does not appear to be any evidentiary support for it.
If one removes that assumption, then there is far less reason to determine whether or not terrorists possess weapons of mass destruction, and far more reason to determine whether or not terrorists would be willing to use them. This distinction is central to evaluating the article's overall argument, and it will be revisited throughout this analysis.
References
"The Terror Next Time." Economist.com. 2001. The Economist. 23 Apr. 2005. http://www.economist.com/displaystory.cfm?story_id=806202.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.