Themes of Compassion and Human Nature in A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings
This paper examines the predominant themes of Gabriel García Márquez's short story "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings," focusing on how human beings tend to reserve sympathy and compassion for those who resemble themselves. Through analysis of key characters—Pelayo, Elisenda, the neighbor woman, and the priest—the paper demonstrates how self-interest and cultural or religious bias shape each character's response to the mysterious winged old man. The paper also considers the story's broader implications about moral concern, the treatment of those who are different, and the ethical responsibility humans bear toward all living creatures, regardless of their nature or origin.
- Introduction: The Story's Central Question: Two central themes of the story introduced
- Selfishness and Indifference Toward the Other: Pelayo, Elisenda, and neighbor's self-interested reactions
- Religion, Sameness, and Moral Concern: Priest withholds concern based on religious difference
- Human Cruelty and the Failure of Compassion: Crowd torments the old man without remorse
- Difference as a Barrier to Kindness: Wings alone prevent compassion toward a human figure
- Conclusion: Moral Lessons About Human Nature: Compassion must extend beyond sameness and familiarity
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper identifies two distinct but related themes—self-centeredness and indifference toward difference—and traces both through specific characters and plot details.
- It moves beyond plot summary to offer moral interpretation, connecting the story's events to broader questions about how people treat strangers, animals, and those outside their religious or cultural group.
- The analysis of the priest's response is especially strong, drawing out the irony that he acknowledged the old man's humanity while still withholding moral concern because of religious difference.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses thematic textual analysis, selecting specific scenes and characters to support an interpretive argument rather than simply summarizing the story. This technique involves reading characters' behavior as evidence of broader human tendencies and using those observations to build a moral argument about the story's meaning.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by stating its two central themes, then works through the story roughly in narrative order—examining Pelayo and Elisenda, the neighbor woman, the priest, the crowd of visitors, and finally Elisenda's parting reaction. A concluding section generalizes the story's implications outward, arguing that moral concern should not depend on similarity. The structure is straightforward and well-suited to a short literary analysis essay at the introductory undergraduate level.
Introduction: The Story's Central Question
The predominant theme of Gabriel García Márquez's "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings" appears to be that humans have a much stronger tendency to express sympathy, concern, and compassion toward those who are similar to themselves than toward those who are different. A related theme is that people also tend to place their own selfish interests ahead of those of others; they are far more likely to think about what someone can do for them than what they can do for another. This tendency seems to be especially pronounced when it comes to strangers.
Selfishness and Indifference Toward the Other
When Pelayo and Elisenda first found the old winged man, they treated him more like an animal than a human being — largely, it seems, because they were unable to understand him. The "wise" neighbor woman had even less compassion, advising Pelayo and Elisenda to beat him to death with a club. Their only concern was for themselves: they wondered whether the old winged man was an angel sent to help their sick child. It never occurred to them that the old man himself appeared to be very sick and in need of their help at least as much as they needed his.
Religion, Sameness, and Moral Concern
When the priest arrived to investigate, he too seemed concerned about the old man only on the condition that he might be a Christian. Had the old man understood the Father and responded in Latin, the priest would likely have demanded that he be treated with greater kindness and respect. Since the old man could not understand Latin, and because he seemed far more likely to be some form of ordinary person than an angel, the priest showed little concern for his welfare.
Ironically, the Father himself argued that the old winged man was actually very human-like; yet he remained indifferent to the old man's condition because he was not a Christian. The implications of that response extend well beyond the story itself, particularly when one considers the ways in which people view and treat one another based strictly on whether they happen to share the same religion. The story uses this encounter to expose how religious identity can function as a boundary for moral concern.
Conclusion: Moral Lessons About Human Nature
García Márquez's story ultimately suggests that human compassion should not be so dependent on sameness. All living things are entitled to our moral concern — even animals, even strangers, and even creatures of unknown nature and origin. By placing an ambiguous, suffering figure at the center of the narrative and showing how nearly every character fails to respond to his need, the story challenges readers to examine the limits of their own empathy and the conditions under which they extend kindness to others.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.