Therapeutic Alliance, Attachment Theory, and Therapy Retention
This paper examines the interrelationship between therapeutic alliance, attachment theory, and client retention in psychotherapy. Drawing on a broad range of clinical studies and theoretical frameworks — from Freud's early transference concept through Bordin's measurable alliance model and Bowlby's attachment theory — the paper explores how the quality of the client-therapist relationship influences both therapeutic outcomes and a client's decision to remain in treatment. Key issues addressed include the optimal timing for measuring alliance strength, the divergent perceptions of alliance held by clients and therapists, the role of attachment styles in shaping alliance formation, and practical recommendations for therapists when alliance is weak or absent in the early sessions.
- Introduction: Therapeutic Alliance and Retention: Scope, aims, and central research questions
- Historical Development of Therapeutic Alliance: From Freud and transference to Bordin's measurable model
- Therapeutic Alliance and Its Relationship to Retention: Empirical studies linking early alliance to outcomes and retention
- Attachment Theory and Its Relevance to Therapy: Bowlby's attachment framework applied to clinical practice
- Interaction of Alliance, Attachment, and Retention: How attachment styles shape alliance quality and retention
- Conclusion: Client and Therapist Perceptions of Therapeutic Alliance: Synthesis and practical recommendations for therapists
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Systematically traces the historical evolution of therapeutic alliance theory from Freud through Bordin, grounding abstract concepts in a clear intellectual lineage.
- Integrates quantitative findings (e.g., Horvath and Symonds' meta-analysis showing alliance accounts for nearly 50% of outcome variance) with qualitative theoretical frameworks, demonstrating both breadth and depth.
- Connects two distinct theoretical domains — therapeutic alliance and attachment theory — showing how they mutually inform clinical practice around retention.
- Consistently returns to the practical question of what therapists should do when alliance is poor, keeping the review clinically grounded rather than purely theoretical.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper employs a literature review structure that builds progressively: it establishes foundational definitions, surveys empirical evidence on outcomes and retention, introduces a complementary theoretical lens (attachment theory), and synthesizes findings into actionable clinical recommendations. This layered approach — moving from theory to evidence to application — is a strong model for integrative academic reviews in the health and counseling sciences.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an introduction defining the scope and central questions, followed by a historical overview of therapeutic alliance from Freud to Bordin. The third section surveys empirical studies on alliance and retention, including subsections on specific populations such as substance users and adolescents. The fourth section introduces attachment theory via Bowlby and Sonkin. The fifth section synthesizes how attachment states of mind interact with alliance formation and retention outcomes. The conclusion consolidates clinical recommendations, particularly regarding the critical early-session window for alliance evaluation.
Introduction: Therapeutic Alliance and Retention
Numerous studies have established that "therapeutic alliance is an essential component of successful therapy. All forms of individual psychotherapy have demonstrated a connection between outcome and therapeutic alliance" (Delaney, 2006). It is important to note that the significance of the therapeutic alliance goes beyond the parameters of any one theory and is considered a "pantheoretical" factor of treatment (Delaney, 2006). While the general concept and practice of therapeutic alliance is associated with outcome, it is also aligned with the issue of retention.
This paper provides an overview of the relationship between therapeutic alliance and retention with reference to the underlying influence of attachment theory. The subject of therapeutic alliance has in recent years been the focus of numerous papers and studies, and it is often seen as an essential element of the therapeutic process.
A central aim of this paper is, through the analysis of the interrelationship between alliance, retention, and attachment theory, to provide the groundwork for determining whether one can detect if a client is experiencing the therapeutic alliance in a positive way. Related to this is the need to ascertain the effectiveness of therapy and alliance from both the client's and the therapist's perspectives.
Another issue addressed here is the most appropriate stage for measuring the status of the alliance. This in turn leads to important practical questions, such as what action should be taken if the therapeutic alliance is not beneficial — whether the patient should be referred to another therapist or work through the alliance difficulties.
Historical Development of Therapeutic Alliance
A brief overview of the history and significance of therapeutic alliance is necessary as a foundation for understanding the variables that intersect between therapeutic alliance and retention.
In a contemporary sense, the understanding of therapeutic alliance as an essential part of psychotherapy can be traced to Bordin's (1979) conceptualization of the alliance. This is a clearly measurable and definable concept. Bordin's definition of therapeutic alliance consists of three interconnected components:
First, the bond of trust between therapist and client. Second, the agreement on the goals of the therapy. Third, the agreement on specific tasks — that is, the particular activities that facilitate the development of therapy toward various intervention goals (Faw et al., 2005).
Furthermore, the therapeutic alliance is considered "the most important determinant in treatment continuance and success, as well as the most frequently identified factor contributing to the outcome of therapy" (Delaney, 2006).
The imperative nature of therapeutic alliance and the collaborative aspect of therapy in psychoanalytic theory can be related back to the work of Freud. This refers to the concept of transference, in which "the client displaces repressed wishes, fantasies, and aspects of past relationships from childhood onto the therapist" (Delaney, 2006). The question of retention — and the reason a patient chooses to endure and remain in the process of therapy — was raised by Freud (1912). His answer reflects directly on the issues at stake in this paper.
Freud concluded that the client was able to view the therapeutic relationship through positive aspects of previous relationships, and that the client could bond with, or form an alliance with, the therapist in order to work together against the client's negative past experiences. Freud then viewed this as an aspect of the client's positive ego that was capable of forming a genuine bond with the therapist's rational ego (Delaney, 2006).
This points to several issues that are explored throughout this paper. First, retention is directly connected to perceptions of the therapeutic alliance. The client's perception of the bond formed — particularly within the first few sessions — is a determining factor in the duration of retention. Second, the process of therapeutic alliance works both ways: it also concerns how the therapist perceives the worth or value of the therapeutic alliance.
In 1934, Sterba defined alliance as the relationship between the reasonable aspects of both therapist and client (Sterba, 1934). To enable positive outcomes and retention, the client's ego "needed to be strengthened in its interactions with the therapist" (Delaney, 2006). This process was facilitated by an intense form of understanding and cooperation between therapist and client. The concept of alliance was therefore seen as an indispensable process whereby the client would accept the therapist's insight into the particular problem, which in turn would increase the likelihood of positive therapeutic outcomes.
The view of therapeutic alliance was taken further by therapists such as Zetzel, Rogers, and Greenson in the 1950s and 1960s. These theorists advanced beyond the concept of transference toward an understanding of therapeutic alliance as a conscious process that leads to the development of trust and cooperation between client and therapist.
For example, Zetzel (1956) redefined the therapeutic alliance as describing "the authentic object relationship which promoted the client's ability to withstand analysis" (Delaney, 2006). This view stresses the way in which the therapeutic alliance alters or potentially changes the perceptions and emotional and cognitive stance of the client. Zetzel believed that "it was the ability to foster and maintain this alliance with even the most disturbed clients that would allow for a successful analysis of the transference and the success of the treatment" (Delaney, 2006).
This view was developed further by Rogers (1957), who placed the therapeutic relationship between patient and therapist at the centre of therapy. A central aim for the therapist was to establish a firm, stable, and consistent alliance with the client. For this to occur, certain preconditions had to exist: there had to be psychological contact between therapist and client; the therapist should invest in the relationship; there should be unequivocal mutual acceptance; there should be empathy; and, importantly, the client should be aware of and understand the aims and nature of the interaction with the therapist.
These theories led to numerous clinical trials in the 1950s and 1960s, which tended to establish the view that empathic client-therapist alliances produced better outcomes (Horvath, 2001). A study by Horvath (2001) reveals a cardinal finding: the behavior and actions of the therapist were not as important as the way the client perceived those actions (Horvath, 2001). In other words, the way that the client reacted to the therapist's intentions and degree of empathy was deemed the most significant aspect of the therapeutic process in terms of positive outcomes and retention. This is supported by Greenson (1967), who noted that positive collaboration between client and therapist was one of the essential components for therapeutic success.
The concept of therapeutic alliance was further developed by Luborsky (1976), who redefined the contemporary understanding of the term. In his definition, the way that the therapist made the client feel safe and accepted was emphasized. The client was also encouraged to cooperate and collaborate with the therapist in the process of therapy (Luborsky, 1976). This type of alliance would lead to a form of shared commitment from both parties, which would have the best chance of producing positive therapeutic outcomes.
Bordin took this redefinition further by establishing criteria that were measurable and clear. In Bordin's view, the alliance between client and therapist was a conscious and collaborative relationship that was not concerned with transference (Bordin, 1979). In essence, this view stresses that there should first be an agreement between client and therapist as to the aims and intentions of the therapy, as well as an agreement on specific tasks and their purposes within the ambit of the therapy. Finally, the tasks, aims, and actions in the therapeutic alliance should be consistent with the lifestyle and personal context of the client (Bordin, 1979).
Agreement on goals occurs when clients and the therapist agree about the targets of change during therapy. The clients must also perceive that the therapist is genuinely invested in helping them achieve their goals, aided by mutual fondness, attachment, and trust (Delaney, 2006).
All these theoretical aspects tended to elevate the importance of therapeutic alliance in psychotherapy. The alliance was seen in many instances as being therapeutic in itself (Rogers, 1957), and by the late twentieth century it was regarded by many as a prerequisite for effective therapy and a crucial factor in both positive outcomes and retention.
An important point emphasized by many theorists was that the therapeutic alliance must be flexible enough to accommodate the client's perceptions and to deal with various levels of client functioning. At the same time, it should be adaptable to the interventions of the therapist (Gaston, 1990).
These theories were reinforced by further studies and statistical measurement. Researchers found a significant statistical correlation between therapeutic alliance and positive outcomes in therapy. A study by Horvath and Symonds (1991) established that alliance accounted for almost fifty percent of the variance in measurable therapy outcome. Furthermore, this finding was shown to be consistent across different types of therapy and theoretical orientations.
In 1974, Horwitz conducted a study of 42 patients; half were treated with individual psychotherapy and the other half with individual psychoanalysis. The study found that "there were no differences in the outcomes of the two methods but that there was a marked difference due to therapeutic alliance" (Delaney, 2006).
These results are generally consistent across different therapeutic categories. For example, therapeutic alliance has been shown to have a significant impact in drug abuse therapy, as well as in the cognitive-behavioral treatment of children with behavioral problems (Delaney, 2006). It has also been found to be consistent in alcoholism therapy and marital therapy. "The alliance itself appears to have therapeutic properties due to the relationship between client and therapist, involving collaboration and acceptance, providing a mode for treatment that is beneficial in its own right" (Delaney, 2006).
The literature also notes the importance of agreement about tasks between client and therapist in the overall therapeutic alliance. A study by Orne and Wender (1968) states that "the transactions which take place in psychotherapy can run their normal course only if the participants are familiar with certain ground rules, including the purpose of the enterprise and the roles to be played by the participants" (Orne & Wender, 1968, p. 1202).
Another cardinal issue in the literature is that the main body of research on alliance has to date been mostly based on cases with individual clients (Horvath & Bedi, 2002). The understanding of therapeutic alliance from a systemic theoretical point of view was only researched in the 1990s, particularly with regard to how therapeutic alliance affects marriage and family therapy and the importance of mutual interaction and alliance in group therapy sessions.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.