Traditional Budgeting vs. Beyond Budgeting: Strengths and Alternatives
This paper critically evaluates the traditional budgetary model as a tool of management control, exploring both its enduring strengths and well-documented weaknesses. It introduces the "Beyond Budgeting" (BB) approach championed by Hope and Fraser, and the Balanced Scorecard framework developed by Kaplan and Norton, as alternatives or complements to conventional budgeting. The paper examines BB principles, including dynamic planning, relative goal-setting, and decentralized leadership, while also addressing the model's internal contradictions—particularly around trust and agency theory. The paper concludes that, despite valid criticisms, the traditional budgeting model retains significant value and that organizations should seek to update and adapt it rather than abandon it entirely.
- Introduction: Budgeting as a Management Control Tool: Overview of budgeting's role and its core criticisms
- The Beyond Budgeting Approach and the Balanced Scorecard Framework: Introduction to BB and Balanced Scorecard as alternatives
- Strengths and Limitations of the Traditional Budgetary Model: Advantages and weaknesses of conventional budgeting
- Alternatives to the Traditional Budgeting Model: Survey of modern alternatives to traditional budgeting
- The Beyond Budgeting Concept in Practice: BB principles, trust-based management, and dynamic planning
- Corporate Governance, Agency Theory, and the BB Model: Agency theory tensions within the BB trust framework
- Conclusion: Case for updating rather than abandoning traditional budgeting
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper balances advocacy for reform with a defense of traditional budgeting, presenting multiple perspectives fairly rather than arguing from a single ideological stance.
- It grounds its analysis in a wide range of academic and practitioner sources, lending credibility to claims about both the merits and drawbacks of each budgeting approach.
- The discussion of agency theory and its incompatibility with the BB model's trust-based assumptions is a particularly sharp piece of critical analysis that elevates the paper beyond simple description.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative analysis across competing management frameworks. By systematically evaluating the traditional budget, the BB model, and the Balanced Scorecard against the same criteria—planning, control, motivation, flexibility, and governance—the author creates a structured basis for judgment rather than relying on assertion alone.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an introduction to budgeting as a management tool and its critiques, then introduces the BB and Balanced Scorecard alternatives. It evaluates strengths and weaknesses of traditional budgeting, surveys alternative approaches, explores BB principles and their practical implications, and addresses agency theory concerns before concluding that adaptation rather than abandonment is the most defensible path forward.
Introduction: Budgeting as a Management Control Tool
Organizations have for a long time used budgets as the primary tool in management control. Relying on budget control as the sole method of management control, however, carries several disadvantages. Budgets, for example, are costly to prepare. It has also been noted that budgets often limit an organization's responsiveness and can act as a roadblock to change. Another disadvantage is that most budgets focus on the reduction of costs rather than on the addition of value. In view of these shortcomings, some commentators have proposed that budgeting be done away with entirely. Hope and Fraser, with their clarion call of "Beyond Budgeting," are notable proponents of this push to abandon traditional budgeting.
The Beyond Budgeting Approach and the Balanced Scorecard Framework
The Beyond Budgeting (BB) approach has been proposed by European practitioners as a way of solving the problems inherent in traditional budgeting methods. The literature describes budgeting as one of the key pillars of management control (Anthony, 1998). The approach Anthony took was grounded in accounting, under which strategic planning was treated as a separate discipline (Hansen et al., 2003). Practitioners have argued that the use of budgets is a roadblock to efficient and sound resource allocation and that it encourages short-sighted decision-making. Other harmful organizational behaviors may also result from budgeting (Wallander, 1999; Fraser and Hope, 2003a, 2003b).
A growing body of research has focused on the disadvantages and challenges that arise when organizations rely solely on budgeting as a means of management control (Hansen et al., 2003; Lukka, 1988). Some organizations have therefore begun replacing budgeting with alternative systems, while others complement budgeting with additional tools. Credit for launching this shift in perception goes to Hope and Fraser through their "Beyond Budgeting" work (2003a, 2003b) and to Kaplan and Norton through their Balanced Scorecard Framework (2001). The Balanced Scorecard links performance measurement with the organization's set strategies, thereby reducing the tendency for organizations to divorce operational management from strategic plans. Despite numerous critiques and well-reasoned arguments against budgeting as a management control tool, there is not yet much empirical evidence on the effects of entirely eliminating budgets from organizations (Kaplan and Norton, 2001).
Bibliography
Anthony, R. N., & Govindarajan, V. (1998). Management Control Systems. Richard D. Irwin.
Banham, R. (2012). Freed from the budget. CFO, 28(7), 41–46.
Bescos, P. L., Cauvin, E., Langevin, P., & Mendoza, C. (2003). Criticism of budgeting: A contingent approach. Proceedings of the 26th European Accounting Association Conference, Seville, Spain, April 2–4, 2003.
Burns, W. J., & Waterhouse, J. (1975). Budgetary control and organization structure. Journal of Accounting Research, Autumn 1975, 177–203.
Bunce, P., Fraser, R., & Woodcock, L. (1995). Advanced budgeting: A journey to advanced management systems. Management Accounting Research, 6, 253–265.
Evans, J., Evans, R., & Loh, S. (2002). Corporate governance and declining firm performance. International Journal of Business Studies, 10(1), 1–18.
Frezatti, F. (2004). Beyond budgeting: Any chance for management improvement? Brazilian Business Review, 1(2), 118–135.
Hansen, S., & Van Der Stede, W. (2004). Multiple facets of budgeting: An exploratory analysis. Management Accounting Research, 15, 415–439.
Hansen, S., Otley, D., & Van Der Stede, W. (2003). Practice developments in budgeting: An overview and research perspective. Journal of Management Accounting Research, 15, 95–116.
Heath, J., & Norman, W. (2004). Stakeholder theory, corporate governance and public management: What can the history of state-run enterprises teach us in the post-Enron era? Journal of Business Ethics, 53(3), 247–265.
Hope, J., & Fraser, R. (2000). Beyond budgeting. Strategic Finance, 30–34.
Hope, J., & Fraser, R. (2003a). Beyond Budgeting: How Managers Can Break Free from the Annual Performance Trap. Harvard Business School Press.
Hope, J., & Fraser, R. (2003b). Who needs budgets? Harvard Business Review, February, 108–115.
Kaplan, R. S., & Norton, D. P. (2001). Transforming the balanced scorecard from performance measurement to strategic management: Part I. Accounting Horizons, 15(1), 87–104.
Libby, T., & Lindsay, R. M. (2003a). Budgeting — an unnecessary evil, Part I. CMA Management, March, 30–33.
Libby, T., & Lindsay, R. M. (2003b). Budgeting — an unnecessary evil, Part II: How the BBRT envisions a world. CMA Management, April, 28–31.
Lukka, K. (1988). Budgetary biasing in organizations: Theoretical framework and empirical evidence. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 13(3), 281–301.
Marginson, D., & Ogden, S. (2005). Coping with ambiguity through the budget: The positive effects of budgetary targets on managers' budgeting behaviors. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 30, 435–456.
Otley, D. (2001). Extending the boundaries of management accounting research: Developing systems for performance management. The British Accounting Review, 33(3), 243–261.
Shil, N. C. (2011). Corporate governance and firm value. International Journal of Governance, 1–7.
Uyar, A. (2009). An evaluation of budgeting approaches: Traditional budgeting, better budgeting, and beyond budgeting. Akademik Arastirmalar Dergisi, 11(42), 113–130.
Vaznoniene, M., & Stonciuviene, N. (2012). The formation of company budgeting system: Importance, problems and solutions. Management Theory & Studies of Rural Business & Infrastructure Development, 30(1), 157–170.
Wallander, J. (1999). Budgeting — an unnecessary evil. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 15, 405–421.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.