USAA and Shake Shack: Ethical Issues in Business Conduct
This paper examines ethical controversies involving USAA and Shake Shack during the COVID-19 pandemic. USAA used government stimulus deposits to offset members' negative account balances, while Shake Shack—a publicly listed company worth over $2 billion—drew a $10 million Paycheck Protection Program loan intended for small businesses. The paper identifies affected stakeholders for each organization and evaluates both decisions through Kantian and utilitarian ethical frameworks. It concludes with virtue-ethics-based recommendations, arguing that decision makers in both organizations failed to exercise good judgment and compassion toward those most harmed by the pandemic.
- Introduction: Overview of business ethics and paper scope
- Ethical Issues: USAA stimulus offsets and Shake Shack PPP controversy
- Stakeholder Implications: Impact on stakeholders for both organizations
- Kantian Viewpoint: Evaluating decisions through Kantian moral obligation
- Utilitarian Viewpoint: Consequences and greatest-good analysis of decisions
- Recommended Actions: Virtue ethics-based alternatives for both companies
- Conclusion: Businesses must apply ethics to serve all stakeholders
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Applies three distinct ethical frameworks—Kantian ethics, utilitarianism, and virtue ethics—to the same two real-world cases, allowing for structured comparison and contrast.
- Organizes stakeholder analysis systematically using numbered lists for each organization, making the breadth of impact easy to follow.
- Grounds abstract moral theory in concrete pandemic-era business decisions, making philosophical concepts accessible and relevant.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the technique of multi-framework ethical analysis: presenting the same business decisions through different moral lenses (deontological, consequentialist, and virtue-based) to show how each framework reaches different conclusions. This approach is common in applied business ethics and helps students understand that ethical evaluation is not one-dimensional.
Structure breakdown
The paper follows a clear, sequential structure: an introduction establishes the subject and scope; an ethical issues section describes the factual controversies; a stakeholder analysis section maps impacts using labeled sub-sections for each company; separate sections address Kantian and utilitarian viewpoints; a recommendations section proposes virtue-ethics-based alternatives; and a brief conclusion synthesizes the argument. The organization mirrors a standard applied-ethics case analysis format appropriate for undergraduate business ethics coursework.
Introduction
To a large extent, the way businesses conduct their affairs is governed by a certain set of standards or principles. As commercial entities, businesses should not only be driven by the need to generate profits. Instead, they should be aware of their responsibilities to a wide range of stakeholders including, but not limited to, employees, customers, suppliers, regulatory agencies, and competitors. This is especially true given that some actions could be perfectly legal yet unethical or injurious to the wellbeing of certain stakeholders.
This paper examines a number of ethical issues relating to two entities: USAA and Shake Shack. In doing so, it considers the implications of the decisions made by the two organizations on their stakeholders, and how those decisions can be viewed from both a Kantian and a utilitarian perspective.
Ethical Issues
From the outset, it is important to note that the COVID-19 pandemic affected individuals and businesses in diverse ways. Due to the hardships that most people experienced as a consequence of lost livelihoods, the U.S. Congress structured a stimulus package to cushion the most vulnerable. This was the intent behind the funds deposited into the checking accounts of USAA members. However, USAA proceeded to use those deposits to offset the negative balances reflected in some members' accounts. As a result, some funds did not reach those in dire need. USAA can therefore be viewed as insensitive to the plight of its members.
When it comes to Shake Shack, it is worth noting that with a market capitalization of $2.06 billion and a listing on the NYSE, the organization cannot reasonably be considered a small business. Nevertheless, the enterprise used the provisions for accessing Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) funds to its advantage. Furthermore, a significant portion of the loan may have been used for executive compensation, given that the company's Chief Executive Officer had received total compensation of $2.3 million in 2019. By taking up the loan, Shake Shack effectively denied other, more vulnerable and deserving enterprises access to funds intended to protect their employees from the harmful effects of the pandemic. This concern is amplified by the fact that the PPP depleted its funds shortly after the company received its $10 million loan.
References
Brusseau, J. (2014). The Business Ethics Workshop. Flat World Knowledge.
CrashCourse. (2016, December 6). Aristotle & virtue theory: Crash Course philosophy #38 [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PrvtOWEXDIQ
CrashCourse. (2016, November 22). Utilitarianism: Crash Course philosophy #36 [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-a739VjqdSI
Westacott, E. (2019). Moral philosophy according to Immanuel Kant. ThoughtCo.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.