Human Rights Donnelly, J. 2007 . Book Report

Therefore, those who have the political power to underwrite human rights legislation also have the power to re-write that legislation or simply be excused from the table. In some cases, human rights violations are clear-cut. Genocide is a prime example of a situation in which the global community screams for a more conscientious enforcement of human rights treaties. Yet even in this scenario, there are no clear-cut human rights law enforcement agencies. How can the international community create not just consensus but also transnational legal jurisdiction? What about the institutions needed to act as human rights police? Are we in a post-nation-state world, in which the authority of transnational organizations like the United Nations can trump cultural norms? If so, then which parties are privy to writing the legal code that underwrites transnational human rights?

Sonners, M.R., & Roberts, C.N.J. (2008). Towards a new sociology of rights: A genealogy of "buried bodies" of citizenship and human rights. Annu. Rev. Law Soc. Sci. 2008. 4:385 -- 425.

Sonners & Roberts (2008) propose a sociology of human rights. Sociology typically does not address human rights as being within its domain. Citizenship might fall under the rubric of sociology, but human rights have more of a philosophical underpinning that makes it somewhat out of place in classical sociological disciplines. Ultimately, Sonners & Roberts (2008) argue that it is "morally and...

...

The definition of human rights is currently embroiled in the conflict between civil rights vs. socioeconomic rights. Specifically, traditional and still-existing versions of human rights codes hold out that an individual has the right to self-determination but not necessarily the right to free health care services. In the neo-liberal world, Sonners & Roberts (2008) contend, socioeconomic rights are overtly outshined by the only the most basic idea of human civil rights. The very idea that socioeconomic rights are equivalent with or an inherent part of civil rights is itself an assumption that many sociologists are unwilling to make.
The authors trace the evolution of human rights through law, showing that the same sociological factors that influence norms will eventually influence legal structures. Then, Sonners & Roberts (2008) conclude that the concept of human rights is reflected in shifting legal codes. A sociology of human rights would radically transform the way rights are conceived of by lawmakers and politicians because a sociology of human rights would illuminate why such rights are important in the first place. If we are sympathetic with the authors' central claims, then what is a realistic vision for the future in terms of both sociological…

Sources Used in Documents:

Sonners & Roberts (2008) propose a sociology of human rights. Sociology typically does not address human rights as being within its domain. Citizenship might fall under the rubric of sociology, but human rights have more of a philosophical underpinning that makes it somewhat out of place in classical sociological disciplines. Ultimately, Sonners & Roberts (2008) argue that it is "morally and intellectually indefensible" for sociology to continue distancing itself from the study and implementation of human rights.

First, the authors note that human rights are difficult to define. The definition of human rights is currently embroiled in the conflict between civil rights vs. socioeconomic rights. Specifically, traditional and still-existing versions of human rights codes hold out that an individual has the right to self-determination but not necessarily the right to free health care services. In the neo-liberal world, Sonners & Roberts (2008) contend, socioeconomic rights are overtly outshined by the only the most basic idea of human civil rights. The very idea that socioeconomic rights are equivalent with or an inherent part of civil rights is itself an assumption that many sociologists are unwilling to make.

The authors trace the evolution of human rights through law, showing that the same sociological factors that influence norms will eventually influence legal structures. Then, Sonners & Roberts (2008) conclude that the concept of human rights is reflected in shifting legal codes. A sociology of human rights would radically transform the way rights are conceived of by lawmakers and politicians because a sociology of human rights would illuminate why such rights are important in the first place. If we are sympathetic with the authors' central claims, then what is a realistic vision for the future in terms of both sociological theory and the practice of human rights law?


Cite this Document:

"Human Rights Donnelly J 2007 " (2010, November 04) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/human-rights-donnelly-j-2007-11938

"Human Rights Donnelly J 2007 " 04 November 2010. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/human-rights-donnelly-j-2007-11938>

"Human Rights Donnelly J 2007 ", 04 November 2010, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/human-rights-donnelly-j-2007-11938

Related Documents

In other words, the power and the wealth could easily fall in the hand of the few privileged ones, and their rights would be better served, than those of the marginalized, powerless and poor population (Paribatra, 1999). 6. Conclusions and Recommendations The section on the analysis of the issues at hand commenced stating that the purpose of the briefing paper was a simple one: identifying the positive or negative nature of

Future of Human Rights
PAGES 3 WORDS 961

Future of Human Rights Human Rights Implementation This particular batch of readings was of extreme interest and aided in contextualizing the international struggle for the establishment of human rights in a global context. This aspect of the readings was definitely the strong point of them, for each and every article addressed the implementation of establishing human rights on an international basis. Whereas previous readings were useful in presenting the ideology of human

Human resource management is one of the essential components to the competitiveness of global firms. Corporations that perform exceptionally regarding human resource management tend to integrate strong discipline in their people with attention to strong social capital (developing networks and relationships within the organization). The multiplier impacts of this combination generate inimitable conditions for people management, which in turn drives employee engagement in the global context. The following study focuses

Discipline The particular academic discipline I have chosen to pursue is a major in a General Studies with a double minor in both Biology and Sociology. However, after spending the past several weeks engaged in readings related to human rights, it has become quite clear to me that the consideration of human rights can apply to virtually any field of study. Still, when considering the relationship between human rights and

This comes as a result of the idea that along with the right to limit foreign interference the state also has the duty to ensure the safety and security of its population (Buzan, 1983). In the moment when the security of its people is not ensured, the state can no longer be considered sovereign and in control of the country; thus, international forces must intervene in order to reestablish

Foreign Policy of China (Beijing consensus) Structure of Chinese Foreign Policy The "Chinese Model" of Investment The "Beijing Consensus" as a Competing Framework Operational Views The U.S.-China (Beijing consensus) Trade Agreement and Beijing Consensus Trading with the Enemy Act Export Control Act. Mutual Defense Assistance Control Act Category B Category C The 1974 Trade Act. The Operational Consequences of Chinese Foreign Policy The World Views and China (Beijing consensus) Expatriates The Managerial Practices Self Sufficiency of China (Beijing consensus) China and western world: A comparison The China (Beijing