Patient Autonomy Term Paper

  • Length: 4 pages
  • Subject: Healthcare
  • Type: Term Paper
  • Paper: #85670763

Excerpt from Term Paper :

Patient Autonomy

The concept of patient autonomy, as opposed to medial paternity, is one that has gained much ground in recent years; "... about 30 years ago, issues began to appear that were difficult to solve using traditional ethics. New medical and reproductive technologies, research controversies, and a societal ethos that questioned all authority posed difficult questions." (Czaplyski, Larry, 2002)

At issue in this paper is the meaning and significance of patient autonomy and the way in which is relates to medical paternity. As the discussion will outline, the case for patient autonomy is not only ethically valid but also essential for the moral and practical balance in the medical profession. Underlying this view is the fact that the issue of patient autonomy does not exist in isolation or in the medical field alone - but relates to other issues and ethical problems in the society at large. These larger issues refer to various forms of control and authoritarianism which act against personal liberty and freedom.

The argument will centre on two imperatives. Firstly, that patient autonomy is an inalienable right and is ethically related to freedom of choice and freedom of speech. The second reason for upholding patient autonomy focuses on the fact that the practice of modern medicine has tended to become increasingly more clinical and mechanical and imposes itself on the patient through the force and status of science. This has resulted in an unhealthy patient-doctor relationship and the distancing of the patient and medical practitioner. In this respect patient autonomy is seen as not only ethically valid but as a necessary counterweight to achieve an open and balanced relationship between the patient and the health practitioner.

The concept of and motivation for patient autonomy is best understood by understanding the meaning of the term medical paternity. Paternity is a concept that is allied to a wider and predominantly contemporary problem, namely the world wide reaction against forms of control and dominance from persons, associations or groups that are not transparent and open in their dealings. The term paternalism carries with it many loaded meanings based on restriction and control, particularly pertaining to information. The term has been deconstructed in many spheres, including the field of medicine. This deconstruction aims at exposing the hidden layers of hegemony and biased authoritarianism that the term implies.

Although there may be disagreement on how to define the term "paternalism," there seems to be an origin of paternalism other than that from the physician which can affect the degree of autonomy which a patient can express. In my view, paternalism is a parental form of direction or order to the patient to the effect that "we know what is best, you may not understand it but follow what we say." This kind I think originates from institutions within our social or political environment. (Bernstein Maurice, 2004)

The definition of patient autonomy on the other hand counters the tendency of paternalism to dominate and control by insisting on "the right of patients to make decisions about their medical care without their health care provider trying to influence the decision. Patient autonomy does allow for health care providers to educate the patient but does not allow the health care provider to make the decision for the patient. (MedicineNet: Patient autonomy) more precise definition which hints at the complexities and possible ambiguities involved in the term 'patient autonomy' is the following:

Thus, patient autonomy refers to the capability and right of patients to control the course of their own medical treatment and participate in the treatment decision-making process. Today, case law and the courts define the legal limits of patient autonomy, usually framed under the rubric of informed consent. (Healthcare Ethics, 2004)

The idea of informed consent is an area that often arises in debates on patient autonomy. This term refers to the concern that the issue of autonomy must take account of those patients who are not adequately informed or knowledgeable, or who are not in a position to make decisions. This obvious and important point which, however, should not be allowed to obscure the central issue which is not the degree of patient autonomy but rather an essential element in the medical arena. A definition that points to…

Cite This Term Paper:

"Patient Autonomy" (2004, October 05) Retrieved January 16, 2017, from

"Patient Autonomy" 05 October 2004. Web.16 January. 2017. <>

"Patient Autonomy", 05 October 2004, Accessed.16 January. 2017,