Scientific Investigation Includes Both Independent and Dependent Term Paper

Download this Term Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Term Paper:

scientific investigation includes both independent and dependent variables. The independent variable is the cause (antecedent) of the dependent variable, the presumed effect (consequence). For the present study there are two independent variables: inclusive and self-contained educational programs. The receiving, or dependent, variables are child development and social competence as measured by the SIB and ASC tests. Although not included in the present investigation additional independent variables could have been age, gender, and eligibility category.

Purpose and Design of Study According to the authors the study was designed to study the effects of two different types of educational programs (inclusive vs. self-contained) for students with significant disabilities with respect to gains and rate of improvement in levels of development and social competence as measured by the SIB and ASC on a pre and post-test basis. The author's research question was stated somewhat appropriately: "What are the effects of attending inclusive vs. self-contained programs on children with significant disabilities, and what types of gains and rates of improvement can be anticipated." (See Study Methodology for the relationship research question and selected statistic.) When stating a research question the investigator is not a liberty to assert directional consequences in a presented research question. The author did this by stating "What are the effects... " Using the word "what" implies that differences are to be expected. The researchers should have stated the research question simply by stating "Are there any effects.... " In this manner the researchers can expect results or not results - which is the prudent way in which to formulate a research question.

When a research question has been presented the natural flow leads to the statement of a testable null hypothesis or hypotheses. Null hypotheses state that there will not exist any effect of the independent variable on the dependent variable as measured by a pre-selected assessment instrument. The Fisher and Meyer study failed to state any testable null hypothesis, and, as a result, the test data is susceptible to erroneous and flawed interpretation. More appropriately the authors should have constructed the following testable major null hypothesis and follow up the main effects null hypothesis plus second and third interaction level effect null hypotheses: "There exists no statistically significant difference at ?=.05 in pre and post test SIB and ASC scores for severely learning disabled students and social competence with respect to inclusive and self-contained educational programming. As the study contains various levels of social competence and skill development the appropriate null hypotheses should have been stated with respect to interaction effects. Nested variable consideration should also have been given with respect to nested interaction and nested variables such as age, gender and eligibility levels. Written testable null hypotheses are required also for making the appropriate statistical tool selection. When a researcher chooses to study differences a certain statistic is called for. On the other hand when a researcher is looking to study relationships a different type statistical tool is employed. Not having a null hypothesis from the very beginning stating an examination of differences, relationships and/or effects, the researchers have no basis for choosing the statistical tool for which they opted to use nor interpreting the results.

With respect to the study's research design the author's lightly presented the type of study they conducted. As for the null hypothesis and research question the design section is to be extremely organized and point specific. All researchers are to state specifically what type of research investigation is being presented for evaluation and conclusion. All sub-components of the selected design are to be clearly stated as well. The Fisher and Meyer study again failed in their commitment to regulatory research compliance. Although they did mention very early on in the study that a longitudinal approach was taken there was no mention of how the study was to be kept free of internal, external, or extraneous error. A researcher must always keep in mind that any selected design brings with it certain limitations as well as uniqueness or error. In order to counter these effects certain manipulations or controls to the design and statistical tool must occur. Anything that can affect the controls of any study affects the study's interval validity. Problems with external control will be discussed under the last segment of this paper, "Results and Implications" With respect to internal validity contamination brought about by lack of control Fisher and Meyers failed to report sampling procedures, test administration controls, procedures, and interpretations, scoring mechanisms, SIB and ASC reliability and reliability factors, and a host of possible nested variables such as standardization procedures in test administration, location of testing, conditions of testing environment, and subject level of test taking acceptance. Not having sufficient information with respect to the entire testing situation and structure, chosen sampling method, and standardization qualities of the selected measurement instruments the results and outcomes of the study are highly suspect as to garnering meaningful interpretation and result application.

Research Participants All research endeavors must clearly specify how the participants were chosen. This not only provides the reader with information as how far to extend the implications of the research results but certain statistical tools are subject to certain types of sampling procedures. The present study did not describe the sampling procedure not did it suggest any correction procedure possibly needed for the statistical tool chosen to analyze the data. Therefore, results are suspect again to faulty interpretation and meaning.

Study Methodology As stated above no information was presented as to the reliability and validity of the two chosen instruments. Whether or not the selected measurement instruments meet the requirements of standardization is unknown. In turn, the review of literature section did not discuss the worth of the two instruments whatsoever; and it is within this section that a reader looks for information as to the importance of using the selected measurement instruments. Additionally, Fisher and Meyers failed to present any previous research information as to the selected measurments' comparability to, or compatibility with, other similar assessment devices. Should, however, there not exist any similar measurement instruments the authors were obligated to state the lack thereof. All this is required for the reader to be able to objectively evaluation to "goodness" of the research and the data being produced.

Not only are results interpreted on the basis of the an alignment between the research question and the null hypothesis, the very manner in which a research question is phrased dictates the type of statistic that will be used to analyze the collected data. For example should a researcher wish to test for the relationship between intelligence and school achievement a correlation coefficient is used to analyze the data. Fisher and Meyers stated their research interest lie in testing the "effects" of the independent variable on the dependent variable with respect to two sets or measurement scores in a pre and post test situation. Choosing a "t" Test of independent sample statistical analysis does not, in any way, show effects. A "t" Test is employed to test for differences between two independent groups that have been measured in one or more ways. By using a "t" Test the Fisher and Meyers research question should have read: Are their statistically significant differences in the SID and ASC scores of learning disabled students on a pre and post test basis who have been in either an inclusion program or a self-contained program? Under no circumstance is the "t" Test amenable to test effects - only differences. As a result the analyzed information is inappropriately applied back to the investigators original research question. Either the question has to be revised or another statistical tool, one for testing for effect, must be selected. The recommended chosen tool in this example is an analysis of variance with orthogonal modifications. Even though the authors…[continue]

Cite This Term Paper:

"Scientific Investigation Includes Both Independent And Dependent" (2004, May 05) Retrieved November 28, 2016, from

"Scientific Investigation Includes Both Independent And Dependent" 05 May 2004. Web.28 November. 2016. <>

"Scientific Investigation Includes Both Independent And Dependent", 05 May 2004, Accessed.28 November. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Vallerand A Riley Doucet C Hasenau

    Whomever recommended that the authors employ such a tactic simply needs to return to a 'two-tier" education program wherein the primary objective is to increase one's content knowledge of statistics. Although the authors also make mention of using an ANOVA to garner statistical value nowhere in the report as these values reported other than on a cursory basis. Again, when statistical values are produced they must, at all time

  • Healthcare Environment Palese Et Al 2011 Argue

    healthcare environment, Palese et al. (2011) argue there is no effective data to support that patients' satisfaction is correlated with a nursing care. Moreover, there is evidence revealing uncertainty in the nursing care environment since there is lack of identification of caring consequences. While the patient's satisfaction has been linked with nurses' caring behaviors, however, there is no empirical evidence to support "the effect of caring on patient's satisfaction."

  • Developing Countries Are Extremely Dependent

    Wichit Na Ranong, President of the Tourism Council of Thailand, said: "In a few months there will be a lot of social problems. We need more work for our people. We need the tourists to come back and spend their money, to restore people's livelihoods, otherwise we could be in trouble." As far as the accommodations and infrastructure are concerned the beaches on the West Coast of Phuket were the

  • Preferences in Learning Between American

    The trainer will then focus on the steps to be taken to develop new skills. For example, if the trainer wants to talk about motivating, leading, negotiating, selling or speaking, it is best to start with what the learners do well before showing some chart on Maslow's theory, Posner's leadership practices, or selling skills from some standard package that has been develop elsewhere. Many foreign trainers make grave errors

  • Social Variables in the Development

    To critically investigate the current state of international business relationship development literature. 2. To explore the characteristics that determines sustainable international business relationships within the Libyan business context-from the Libyan point-of-view. 3. To present a model based on the findings from the two objectives above. This model will serve two main functions: (I). It will help fill in gaps in the current literature relating to the development and maintenance of business

  • Statistics the Plant Opening Is Only a

    Statistics The plant opening is only a few months away and the Board of Directors for ABC Complete Kitchens, Inc. is interested in learning more about what you recommend for plant productivity analysis. Specifically, the board members want you to identify and describe the tools and techniques that are available that will help the plant's executive team better conduct statistical analyses for plant productivity evaluation. Be sure to define the

  • Role of Life Long Learning in Creating an Ecologically Minded Society...

    popularized social and cultural trends are merging, intentionally or not, toward laying the foundation for generating a new narrative about what it means to learn across a lifespan in an environment conducive to healthy living. It seeks to examine the coalescing of what is called lifelong learning side-by-side with the theories and practices related to the evolution of ecological thinking and environmental awareness. The idea that life can be

Read Full Term Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved