Criminals -- Born Or Made Since The Essay

Length: 7 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Children Type: Essay Paper: #42815491 Related Topics: Biochemistry, Criminal Behavior, Nature Vs Nurture, Criminological Theory
Excerpt from Essay :

Criminals -- Born or Made

Since the construction of the first civil society, behavioral rules distinguishing what is acceptable and what is criminal have existed. Even though individuals typically have a concept of conventional moral behavior, criminal conduct is represented in every society and culture. Criminal deviance is not a novel construct, and has long been the intrigue of researchers, philosophers, and theorists to determine criminal motivation and link the relationship between individuals and the execution of criminal acts. One central argument that has evolved in the realm of criminality is the nature vs. nurture debate, which questions if criminals are born or made. Biological, psychological, and sociological disciplines each offer theories into the origin of criminality to explain if criminal behavior is a consequence of genetics or a matter of the environment in which they are raised (Jones). The biologist introduces genetic evidence and explains the effects of varying biochemistry; the psychologist applies personality and behavioral theories, and the sociologist describes the influence of social interaction, social context, and often explores the social learning theory. Several theorists also contribute such environmental factors as family and media influences as impacts on moral development, ultimately contributing to criminality. Two theories aiming to define psychological causes of criminality are the Personality and Attachment theories. The personality theory as described by Hans Eysenck, attempts to psychologically bridge genetic and environmental forces as factors for criminality. The attachment theory, presented by psychologists John Bowlby, signifies the importance of infants developing a healthy relationship with their primary caregiver to attain healthy social and emotional processes (Helfgott 233). In the nature vs. nurture debate, the biological elements cannot be ignored when considering criminality, however the environmental influences hold adequate responsibility for the production of criminals in society.

The presence of criminal behavior is not new to any existing society, and researchers have long argued the root of criminality within the nature vs. nurture debate. The "nature" side of the argument suggests that criminal behavior is genetically inherited between a parent and their offspring. The question of nature was first introduced in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries when the notion of genetics was better understood (Jones). From this biological perspective, criminality is passed through the generations in the same fashion as some psychological illnesses. The concept that criminal behavior is genetically linked raises several questions and uncertainties. For example, if the nature debate is true, how can a society lower crime rates? The question suggests that the amount of criminals in a society can decrease if reproductive capabilities are limited for individuals who suffer from psychological illness, and exude criminal behavior. Over recent decades, twin, adoption, and family studies have been conducted to examine the role of genetics in antisocial and criminal behavior. Adoption studies appear to be the most critical, as they analyze the presence of criminal behavior in children whose biological parents have criminal history but were raised in an adoptive home. Several studies showed that children who were birthed by incarcerated females, and then adopted by a non-relative family, showed greater incidence of criminal behavior in adulthood (Jones). The research made into the genetic contribution of criminality as viewed in adoptive cases is enough to acknowledge the nature component of the debate as a partial source of criminal behavior.

Additional biological components researchers believe to be contributors to criminality are blood chemistry, hormone levels, and brain function. Blood chemistry, hormones, and the action of neurotransmitters also play a vital role in mood, behavior and performance (Helfgott 53-58). Lower levels of the serotonin neurotransmitter have been linked to violent behavior, as well as personality traits of depression,...


Varying levels of dopamine are linked to the abuse of drugs and alcohol, Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), and aggression (Jones). Activity levels of the monoamine oxidase enzyme have also been related to antisocial behavior, more precisely it can lead to impulsivity and aggression (Jones). The mentioned impacts of neurochemicals, enzymes, and biochemistry have a notable influence on biological shaping of personality and resultant behaviors. The role of biology and its influence on behavior cannot be negated as a factor in the origin of criminality. Genetic information and biochemistry of the body are attributed to a variety of physical and mental traits, and the committing of critical acts has a place in biological understanding.

The "nurture" argument of the debate explains criminal behavior as a result of the environment in which one is raised. Many researchers agree that environmental components such as family, peers, and community impact the development of personality, and ultimately influence criminal behavior. One of the most influential of these components is the family unit, and is one of the most studied factors linking environmental influence and criminality. The family structure is the smallest subunit in any culture, and can be observed from the viewpoints of several research disciplines, including economical, psychological, and social impacts (Akers, and Sellers). Risk factors stemming from familial circumstances involve: low socioeconomic status/poverty, antisocial parents, harsh, lax, or inconsistent discipline, abusive parents, neglect, and poor parent-child relationship (Jones). The family environment provides an opportunity to nurture structure and moral balance, and is a platform for social interaction. The exchange within a family has the power to significantly impact the behaviors of children, who can eventually become juvenile or adult offenders. Poor communication and weak bonds within a family have been shown in association with aggressive and criminal behavior (Jones). Peer groups are also regarded as having significant influence on the development of criminality. Risk factors originating from the peer group include having weak social ties, having antisocial or delinquent peers, and gang membership (Sampson, and Laub 100).

Psychological and sociological theorists account for the majority of the nurture argument to explain the relation between one's environment and development of criminal behavior. Historically, psychoanalytic theorists relate criminal behavior to mental disturbance. For example, a Freudian perspective would have attributed a conflict between the id, ego, and superego as a causal complex for criminality (Akers, and Sellers 16). Personality theorists regard criminal behavior as a consequence of improper or defective personality traits, where the criminal has developed a personality founded on thoughts of conflict, impulsiveness, and aggression (Akers, and Sellers 16). The sociologist viewpoint generally studies the role of individuals within a society, and consequently the effect society has on its individuals. The social component of every day life has a profound influence on how individuals interact and react as members of society.

The social learning theory is a sociological construct that explains how children learn behaviors: Children learn behaviors by observing behaviors of others (Jones). The socially learned behavior model demonstrates how children will mimic behaviors, positive or negative, as portrayed by the adult in which they are closest to, their friends, and behavior observed from film and television (Jones; Akers, and Sellers 19). For example, if a child observes violent behavior in the home and this behavior is deemed acceptable, then the child learns violence is proper behavior. The social learning theory is a critical point made in favor of the nurture debate as it describes how substantially social environments shape behavior. In recent decades, the influence of the media on criminal behavior and juvenile delinquency has become increasingly scrutinized. The overwhelming presence of violent television shows, films, video games, and music are providing behavior models in which children can try to imitate. The effects of children witnessing violence in the media has the potential for mild to severe displays of aggression, and increases risk of criminal behavior in adulthood, especially if a child receives long-term exposure to violence beginning at an early age (Anderson et al. 81).

To embellish on the personality theory, Eysenck describes personality as a vital piece to negotiating between genetic and environmental forces as causes of criminal behavior. Eysenck acknowledges that sociologists blame criminality on social factors, such as unemployment or poverty, while psychologists are separately blaming personality and intelligence factors (Eysenck 40). Although a psychologist, Eysenck admits that each perspective offers valid insights into the causes of criminality, and one set of theories cannot continue to ignore the other set of theories. Neither social conditions nor psychological differences can be dismissed from the root of criminal behavior as some people commit crime and others do not, despite sharing overlapping characteristics with criminal profiles. As Eysenck supports the nurture argument, he also supports the contribution of nature, and biology, to one's resultant personality. Eysenck believes that most of the variance for individual differences in personality is due to genetic causes, however DNA cannot directly influence behavior, just as social conditions such as poverty cannot control one's behavior (Eysenck 41).

Eysenck defines three major dimensions of personality: psychoticism, extraversion, and neuroticism. Psychoticism refers to a personality pattern characterized by aggressiveness and personal hostility. Extraversion is a component of personality that includes impulsiveness, sociability, and excitability. Neuroticism encompasses an individual's tendency to experience negative emotional states, such as anxiety, depression, anger, and guilt (Eysenck 42-44). The relationship between the three…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Akers, R, and C. Sellers. Criminological Theories: Introduction, Evaluation, and Applications.

4th ed. Los Angeles, CA: Roxbury Publishing Co., 2004. xx-xx. Print.

Anderson, C, L Berkowitz, E Donnerstein, and R. Huesmann. "The Influence of Media violence on Youth." American Psychological Society. 4.3 (2003): 81-110. Print.

Eysenck, H.J.. "Personality and Crime." Psychopathy: Antisocial, Criminal, and Violent

Cite this Document:

"Criminals -- Born Or Made Since The" (2011, July 20) Retrieved September 21, 2021, from

"Criminals -- Born Or Made Since The" 20 July 2011. Web.21 September. 2021. <>

"Criminals -- Born Or Made Since The", 20 July 2011, Accessed.21 September. 2021,

Purpose of

The documents we provide are to be used as a sample, template, outline, guideline in helping you write your own paper, not to be used for academic credit. All users must abide by our "Student Honor Code" or you will be restricted access to our website.

Related Documents
Criminal Profiling
Words: 3039 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 15366797

Criminal Profiling as an Aid for Apprehending Serial Killers Popular media loves to emphasize the role of the criminal profiler in apprehending serial killers. It has been a central them in books, television shows, and movies for the past two decades, and the concept of the feisty criminal profiler interviewing wily and brilliant convicted serial killers in an effort to gain insight into active serial killers has become so iconic that

Criminal Justice Criminal Profiling, or
Words: 570 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 72693237

If human behavior can be loosely predicted, then so too can criminal behavior. 4. Criminal profiling is not one hundred percent accurate or valid. It is an inexact science. Results of profiling are close to chance, which is one reason why the process is criticized and used cautiously. Officers of the law may be misled by an inaccurate or hasty profile, and in some cases might even apprehend innocent persons

Criminal Profiling in Solving Violent
Words: 939 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 48964972

(Holmes and Holmes 4)" Like any other processes, systems, and/or methodologies, there are several ones involved also in criminal profiling. The two basic ones are criminal investigative analysis and behavioral evidence analysis. The former "employs the psychological typologies to organize information and construct a profile. The premise holds that elements of the crime scene represent the offender's personality and approach aims to provide the most likely characteristics, both personality and

Criminal Profile Detroit the Population of Young
Words: 652 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 44214404

Criminal Profile Detroit The population of young professionals in Downtown Detroit is increasing by the day and so is the retail of the region. There are many luxury buildings that have been built now. The development schemes towards the side of east river are now covering many luxury condominium progresses. This has resulted in attracting many young citizens to the Downtown of the city along with the renewed New Center and

Criminal Profiling Is a Technique
Words: 647 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 63601785

One significant drawback of criminal profiling is the wide variation of results among profilers. Factors that affect this variation includes the difference in investigative background among profilers, which necessarily influences the profiling being done. The prove inconsistency among profiler results demonstrates a basic lack of validity (Young, 2006, p. 22). Godwin (2002, p. 8) also notes that profiling serial murders generally lack a rigorous examination of existing data and contributing

Criminal Profiling Is Criminal Profiling
Words: 443 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Sports - Drugs Paper #: 39833050

But 50% the sample were recreational weightlifters who only used the drugs casually. Purpose of use thus affected the frequency of use, and different kinds of illicit drugs were also associated with the different abuser profiles. From a criminal profiler's perspective, this suggests that, when examining who uses a particular performance-enhancing drug, a specific 'type' of athlete or non-athlete might be more likely to be associated with the drug, depending