Dissociative Effect And The Butterfly Effect Research Paper

Length: 5 pages Sources: 1 Subject: Psychology Type: Research Paper Paper: #19835813 Related Topics: Memory Loss, Effects Of Divorce, Hypnosis, Trauma
Excerpt from Research Paper :

Butterfly Effect

DISSOCIATIVE AMNESIA?

Evan Treborn, the main character of the movie, lived a life of severe traumas (Bress & Gruber, 2004). These experiences resurface in adulthood in the form of blackouts, especially during times of extreme stress. His early life traumas include being compelled to participate in child pornography by their neighbor George Miller; nearly dying from strangulation by his own institutionalized mentally ill father Jason; his father's getting killed right before him by guards; a mother and her infant daughter dying from the dynamite he and his friends were playing with; and witnessing his dog die by burning by Tommy, son of their neighbor George Miller (Bress & Gruber).

It was seven years later when he discovered that he could travel into the past and redo parts of it (Bress & Gruber, 2004). It turned out that his travels to the past coincide with his blackouts as a child. But he also discovered that the changes he made on early actions had consequences in his present life. Altering his personal timeline, for example created alternate futures, such as when he became a college student fraternity member. At that time, he also got imprisoned for killing Tommy and an amputee. These mirages are clear indications of the unconscious desire to stomp out those painful events, which his unconscious mind rejects by blacking out. As he proceeded to struggle, he realized that even his good intentions could lead to unforeseen or unfortunate consequences.

New memories that collect in his alternate times through the years likewise damage his brain and give him a nosebleed (Bress & Gruber, 2004). When these adversities escalate and reach a peak, he determines that his struggles to correct the errors of his past only bring harm to those whom he cares about. He also concludes that the cause of every person's suffering in whatever timeline he may have is really himself.

DISSOCIATIVE AMNESIA?

One more time, he travels back into that time he met Kayleigh when they were children (Bress & Gruber, 2004). He irked her so she would choose to live with her mother and in a different place rather than with her father when her parents divorced. She and her brother Tommy were fortunate that their parents raised in an accepting environment. The result of that acceptance was their success in life. It is now the present time and eight years from the time of Evan's last travel into the past. He crosses path with Kayleigh who only briefly looks at him and walks away without bothering to speak with him (Bress & Gruber).

Dissociative Amnesia

DSM-5 describes this condition as a person's inability to recall important personal information (Granacher, 2014). This information is usually traumatic or stressful and not consistent with normal forgetting. It is selective of specific experiences or events to the person. An attempt to recall is accompanied by clinically significant agony or malfunction in some important body functioning. This dysfunction or disturbance is not connected to or explainable by physical effects of a substance or a neurological or medical condition. Neither can it be explained as dissociative identity disorder, posttraumatic stress disorder, acute stress disorder, somatic symptom disorder o any neuro-cognitive disorder. It is simply not measurable or verifiable in the laboratory as dissociative amnesia, according to DSM-f (Granacher).

A Case of Repression

Evan in this film exhibits a defense mechanism called repression (Robichaud, 2011). He represses certain memories, which he cannot cope with emotionally. These repressed

DISSOCIATIVE AMNESIA?

memories are dissociative. As a boy, he would black out whenever he experienced something traumatic. His psychologist...

...

This happeed when he was re-reading his daily entries into his journal. In the process of altering his past, he also alters his future. Eventually, these alterations bring about an unforeseen misfortune of depriving him existence itself. The film has scientific inaccuracies but is still valuable in providing insights about the workings of the human brain (Robichaud).

The movie also explains how the brain functions in certain ways (Robichaud, 2011). It demonstrates the fragility of human emotions and the damage caused by repressed memory. This kind of memory is developed by stressful situations from which a person wants to escape and which he or she refuses to store in memory. Unbearable experiences, such as extreme violence or rejection, are difficult to accept and usually repressed or shut out of accessible memory. Otherwise, the brain itself makes it difficult for the unacceptable memory from access or retrieval. The brain's defense mechanism is a protective measure meant to shield the person from extreme pain (Robichaud).

The movie uses the concept of repressed memory only half correctly (Robichaud, 2011). An accurate part consists of Evan's confronting extremely painful and depressing experiences, such as participating in child pornography and in the killing of a woman and her daughter, his father's attempt to kill him and the seeing Tom actually kill his dog. A child's brain will naturally repress these unbearable experiences. The brain will protect

DISSOCIATIVE AMNESIA?

him by locking these memories beyond his conscious reach and without his knowledge or volition. It is also accurate information that some of these repressed memories can be retrieved and recalled through therapy, such as hypnosis. As an adult, Evan is able to recall some of these repressed events when he reviews his records in the journal.

The biggest inaccuracy, however, is Evan's ability to alter his past by simply recalling events in it (Robichaud, 2011). It is likely a tool for the fiction. But spectators will perceive Evan as a lunatic or mentally imbalanced. They will judge Evan's capability to alter his past experiences as mere imagination or wish.

Another flaw, although not as serious as the earlier one is the absence of blackouts when Evans is not subjected to extreme stress (Robichaud, 2011). Yet he blacked out in two occasions when he was not experiencing severe stress. One was when he was in school and the other was when he was at home with his mother. The movie tries to explain these flaws away by stating that the blackouts were the results of his future mind's returning to the present or a failed attempt at changing in his past.

The movie offers some cognitive and emotional insights into the mechanism of memory loss (Robichaud, 2011). It is assuring that the brain protects us when it enables the repression of memories the person cannot tackle without his conscious knowledge or permission. This tells us that the unconscious mind is actually more powerful than the conscious mind. It is to the benefit of the person that he does not temper with his past. It is what shapes him into what he becomes. Evan's past is largely unfortunate and so he endeavors to modify his past and that of his friends. But when he did this, someone else

DISSOCIATIVE AMNESIA?

would suffer. What Evan overlooks is that, although his past was unfortunate, that of his friends is just fine.

The movie is an experiment at illustrating dissociative amnesia, but it presents serious inaccuracies (Robichaud, 2011). It is accurate in presenting Evan's unconscious mind's blacking out repressed memories. As a child, he was unable to consciously recall them. But in reviewing his own records of daily experiences, he eventually begins to believe that he has the gift of going back to his past to correct wrong decisions he made. While the movie is entertaining and somewhat intriguing, these details are serious obstacles. It teaches its audience that the mind protects the person from what the brain perceives as harmful to the entire person. This movie serves to inform…

Sources Used in Documents:

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Bress, E. And Gruber, J.M. (2004). The butterfly effect. New Line Cinema

Granacher, R.P., Jr. (2014). Commentary: dissociative amnesia and the future of forensic psychiatric assessment. Vol. 42, The Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry

and the Law: American Academy of Psychiatry. Retrieved on September 30, 2014 from http://www.jaapl.org/content/42/2/214/full.pdf+html

Robichaud, G. (2011). Dissociative amnesia in "The Butterfly Effect." AP Psychology.


Cite this Document:

"Dissociative Effect And The Butterfly Effect" (2014, September 30) Retrieved May 17, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/dissociative-effect-and-the-butterfly-effect-192252

"Dissociative Effect And The Butterfly Effect" 30 September 2014. Web.17 May. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/dissociative-effect-and-the-butterfly-effect-192252>

"Dissociative Effect And The Butterfly Effect", 30 September 2014, Accessed.17 May. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/dissociative-effect-and-the-butterfly-effect-192252

Related Documents
Dissociative Identity Disorder
Words: 2610 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 92027892

Dissociative Identity Disorder is also referred to as multiple personality disorder, in which an individual's identity dissociates, or fragments, creating additional identities that exist independently of each other within the individual (Gale 2001). Each personality is specifically distinct from the other, such as tone of voice and mannerisms, vocabulary and posture (Gale 2001). Most people exhibit only one or two personalities, however, there are cases in which an individual will

Dissociative Identity Disorder
Words: 373 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 14729843

Dissociative Identity Disorder The most severe and chronic manifestation of dissociative disorders is dissociative identity disorder (DID) and is believed to be extremely rare (Weber 1003-1004). Clinical dissociation occurs when disconnections between consciousness, memory, perceptions, and identity form, and with DID, distinct and largely mutually-exclusive personalities develop that alternately cope with different aspects of the host's life. The most prominent diagnostic feature is an inability to recall events an alternate personality

Dissociative Identity Disorder Dissociation Is
Words: 2734 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 77139839

Certain Christian communities offering support of this kind are guided by the Scriptures, specifically Isaiah 61, concerning their possessing of the Spirit of the Lord and being anointed (Grace 2002). One group that provides assistance to persons suffering from DID is called the Christian Survivors Ministries (Grace 2002). It makes available an environment of love and acceptance where the afflicted survivors can and will not be rejected or feel ashamed and

Dissociative Identity Disorder Dissociative Disorders
Words: 1202 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 77311217

Clevelandclinic.org/health/health-info/docs/2800/2819.asp?index=9786&src=news.,2002). Dissociative fugue -- In this kind of dissociative disorder, the person is found to have lose his or her sense of personal identity and impulsively wanders or travels away from home for a temporary period of time. People with dissociative fugue often become confused about who they really are and may even create new identities. Outwardly, people with this disorder show no signs of illness, such as a strange appearance

Dissociative Identity Disorder Did Is the Name
Words: 993 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 94199299

Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) is the name that the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders-IV-Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR) uses for the disorder previously known as Multiple Personality Disorder (American Psychiatric Association [APA], 2000). Dissociative disorders are a heterogeneous set of disorders described in the DSM-IV-TR that all involve some form of identity loss (APA, 2000). The concept of a personality describes, in fairly generalized terms, a sense of integration

Differentiating Between Schizophrenia Dissociative Identity and Bipolar...
Words: 917 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Counseling Paper #: 72656746

Differences between The Mental Illnesses The challenge of near-similar presentation of symptoms between schizophrenia, dissociative identity, and bipolar disorder has led to many cases of misdiagnosis. This warrants the need to differentiate the three illnesses as a way of limiting the recurrence of misdiagnosis challenge. Bipolar disorder is a common mental infirmity characterized by alternating mood depressions and mania for several months or even weeks. Maniacs exhibit high levels of energy