Do Religious Freedoms Violate Gay Rights  Essay

Length: 4 pages Sources: 4 Subject: Mythology - Religion Type: Essay Paper: #26114717 Related Topics: Freedom, Gay Marriage, Homosexuality, Transgender
Excerpt from Essay :

Ethics & Gay Rights

The author of this report seeks to explain and fathom the current debate that is going on as it relates to gays and other "non-traditional" couples like lesbians, transgenders and so forth getting married much like heterosexual couples in the United States have done for centuries. The author of this report shall be truly ethical and say up front that she supports gay marriage but she will justify that belief through evidence and good ethical standards throughout this report. The main focal point of this report will be the recent legal fracases in states like Indiana that have tried to (or have) passed laws that allow LGBT people to be discriminated against on the grounds of religion as stated in the United States and/or elsewhere. While many point to the First Amendment's freedom of religion when it comes to saying that gays should not be married, there are plenty of other parts of the Constitution

Ethics Examined

When it comes to the United States Constitution, it has the luxury of being the supreme law of the land. There is the presumption and assumption that if the United States Constitution says "x," then that is what should be done. However, there are two glaring issues with the United States Constitution when it comes to the current scrap relating to gay marriage. First of all, there are legal case precedents not to mention actual clauses in the United States Constitution that seemingly contradict each other. The second major reason is that freedom of religion is one of them and the equal protection clause if the other. The third, and most important reason, is that the United States Constitution has construed wrongly and immorally in the past (Cornell, 2015).

As for the first and second item mentioned above, they can probably be conflated. There are seemingly several parts of the United States Constitution that are being twisted and bent by any number...

...

There are three in particular that need to be looked at from an entirely ethical point-of-view. First of all is freedom of religion. There is a marked difference between having a personal freedom of religion and foisting that on someone else. One common real-world case that is cited is the plight of the gay couple that wanted to get married. They went to a bakery, like most married couples are won't to do, to have a cake made. Upon discovering that the couple was a gay couple, the couple was told that their business was not wanted and that they should go to another bakery. While this would be enough to confirm that another bakery would indeed be better, the couple ended up making an ethical and court case out of it. As would be predictable, the couple cited freedom of religion. However, there are other rulings and parts of the Constitution that complicate this stand. First of all, there is the equal protection clause to the United States Constitution. This states that everyone should be protected equally under the law. In other words, if a straight couple can get a cake at that shop then a gay one should be able to get a cake there as well. As one might guess, the same argument is made in regards to gays getting married. Perhaps the argument about services for marrying couples can be complicated by looping in priests and other people, but the basic argument is there (Cornell, 2015).

Second of all, there is the fact that Supreme Court precedent mandates a separation between church and state. What this means for gay couples and those that would rather not serve them is that religion should not be serving as a basis for what happens during business transactions. While it may not make logical sense for a gay couple to want a cake from an…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

ACLU. (2013). Court Rules Bakery Illegally Discriminated Against Gay Couple - ACLU -- Colorado. ACLU - Colorado. Retrieved 6 May 2015, from http://aclu-co.org/court-rules-bakery-illegally-discriminated-against-gay-couple/

Cornell. (2015). Article VI | Constitution | U.S. Law | LII / Legal Information Institute.

Law.cornell.edu. Retrieved 6 May 2015, from https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/articlevi

Cornell. (2015). Equal Protection | Wex Legal Dictionary / Encyclopedia | LII / Legal
Information Institute. Law.cornell.edu. Retrieved 6 May 2015, from https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/equal_protection
Retrieved 6 May 2015, from http://americanhistory.si.edu/brown/history/1-
from http://www.treasury.gov/about/education/Pages/in-god-we-trust.aspx


Cite this Document:

"Do Religious Freedoms Violate Gay Rights " (2015, May 06) Retrieved January 17, 2022, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/do-religious-freedoms-violate-gay-rights-2151338

"Do Religious Freedoms Violate Gay Rights " 06 May 2015. Web.17 January. 2022. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/do-religious-freedoms-violate-gay-rights-2151338>

"Do Religious Freedoms Violate Gay Rights ", 06 May 2015, Accessed.17 January. 2022,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/do-religious-freedoms-violate-gay-rights-2151338

Related Documents
The Struggle Between Religious Freedom and Other Constitutional Freedoms...
Words: 1213 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Sports Paper #: 56663922

Religious Freedom" is one of the hottest arguments in America. Some believe that religion -- specifically their religion -- is the only way and should be the law of the entire land. Others believe that Religion was invented when the first conman met the first sucker; they have no use for Religion at all, they stress that there should be complete separation of Church and State and that Religion

Freedom of Association Facts the
Words: 1997 Length: 7 Pages Topic: American History Paper #: 9132228

S. citizens. In this program designed to help young ones value the freedoms they currently experience: according to Tyler Barnwell, stands for grievance, as in "to petition the government for a redress of grievances." which denotes religious freedom, Leslie Anne Hill, a Presbyterian, states: "means you don't have to follow a certain religion." stands for freedom of assembly, Sherri Jones states is "the right to get together with other people peaceably, but

Gay Marriage Is a Topical and Controversial
Words: 2476 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Family and Marriage Paper #: 81626139

Gay marriage is a topical and controversial issue, as evidenced by the subject's coverage in the media, presence on ballot initiatives and the high visibility of the controversy in general. There are a few different ethical issues where gay marriage is concerned. To opponents, the primary ethical issue relates to concepts such as the sanctity of marriage and the survival of the species. For proponents, the ethical issues are greater,

Gay Marriage Gaiety Is the Practice of
Words: 1634 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Sexuality Paper #: 37480295

Gay Marriage Gaiety is the practice of bossom love for similar sex and especially between two males or females, bisexual exclusive. "Continued engagement into such practices more often than not lead to desire to attain psychosocial satisfaction through intense urge to achieve a feeling of love and sense of belonging" (Abraham Maslow - Hierarchy of Needs). Hence eventually becoming life long partners as depicted in gay marriages, but marriage is defined

Gay Marriage and Its Constitutionality
Words: 1383 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Sexuality Paper #: 33595985

" (Quoted in Hillary Goodridge & others v. Department of Public Health...") Implementing the Court's decision, Massachusetts made same sex marriage legal in the state on May 17, 2004; it is thus far the only state to do so. Most other states have enacted constitutional provisions that define marriage as a union of one man and one woman. Conservatives Propose Constitutional Amendment: The legalization of gay marriage in Massachusetts and issuance

Gay in Turkey Has a
Words: 4332 Length: 13 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Sexuality Paper #: 68516394

If they repent and mend their ways, then let them be, and there is no mention of the punishment and the negativity is not so strong and in other cases of deviant behavior from the religion which result in death." To understand the propensities of the people therefore it is also necessary to observe the orientation of the population and it is claimed that generally Turkish men, as observed by