The Dual-Use Dilemma
Atlas & Dando (2006) state that dual-use is a term that has been used to describe technologies that could be utilized in both civilian and military settings. However, the term incorporates different dimensions that pose a challenge to modern biology. The dual-use dilemma emerges in the context of biological research and studies in other sciences. In biological research, the dual-use dilemma is brought about by the fact that one piece of scientific research can be used for good and bad purposes. Katz & Banaski (2018) states that dual-use within the field of life sciences refers to technologies, agents, equipment, or information that can be utilized for legitimate scientific purpose or for malicious purposes. When used for malicious purposes within life science, dual-use threatens public health and safety. This implies that the results of scientific research can be misapplied by others to threaten public health and safety.
Given the potential misapplication of the results of scientific research, the dual-use dilemma remains a major concern to public health professionals and governments across the globe. At the core of this dilemma is an ethical problem relating to how scientific research is utilized within life sciences. Governments face an ethical...
The dual-use dilemma is an ethical dilemma because it relates to promoting good on the backdrop of the potential to cause harm (Miller & Selgelid, 2007).The concept of dual-use primarily relates...
…the impacts of viruses such as the Spanish Flu, Swine Flu, and Bird Flu. As evident in the case of these viruses, viral research has been carried out extensively and provided solutions to these public health issues. However, the benefits of viral research results have been evident when they are used appropriately or for the purposes intended by initial researchers.Viral research has also been characterized by the dual-use dilemma since some study results have been used in a manner that threatens public health and safety. For example, two independent teams of researchers have recently created an H5N1 mutant that is capable of human-to-human transmission (Toh, 2013). The dual use of such studies within life sciences has generated concerns on whether dual-use viral…
References
Atlas, R.M. & Dando, M. (2006). The dual-use dilemma for the life sciences: Perspectives, conundrums, and global solutions. Biosecurity and Bioterrorism, 4(3), 276-286.
Katz, R. & Banaski, J. (2018). Essentials of public health preparedness and emergency management (2nd ed.). Burlington, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning.
Miller, S. & Selgelid, M.J. (2007). Ethical and philosophical consideration of the dual-use dilemma in the biological sciences. Science and Engineering Ethics, 13(4), 523-580.
Toh, T. (2013). [SP1202] The dual-use dilemma: Should dual-use viral research be allowed to continue? [video]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P653gzctKxQ
Scientific Research Design: What are the effects of human resources outsourcing on leadership performance and employee commitment? There is speculation that an outsourced human resources (HR) department will have a negative impact on a company's performance. Furthermore, the researcher believes that this impact will be more significant in larger companies. To test this hypothesis, the researcher will perform case studies of two companies, a large one and a small one, that
Scientific Research Collect Methods Comment by Sabina: Scientific research is obtainable through several methodologies, of which qualitative and quantitative methods are highly utilized. These two research methodology are highly used in the field of social sciences and marketing. Social scientist utilizes these two data collection tools to collect data that would otherwise not be observable without these tools. Marketing researchers utilizes these tools to collect information about the market, gain information about
In these cases, the ethical and moral choice seems to be to find another way to test these products that is not so cruel, and to keep cruel procedures out of the labs altogether. The case of the cat sex experiments at the American Museum of Natural History in New York City in the 1960s are another case in point. Researchers maimed cats in a variety of ways, from removing
The ethicality of research methods and the perspectives and potential prejudices of the researcher must also be taken into account during the research and in the presentation of the research (FHI 2003). Some common qualitative research methods other than focus groups include interviews, content analysis, ethnography, evaluation, and semiotics, all of which provide avenues for answering largely different -- and some similar -- questions about the world and its people
Connection Between Class Learning and an Article The development of a COVID-19 vaccine is considered critical in curbing the spread of this virus and dealing with the global pandemic. Companies like Moderna have embarked on efforts to develop an effective coronavirus vaccine. The development process involves conducting extensive research through clinical trials. These clinical trials involves using different concepts of scientific research to ensure the effectiveness of the vaccines. Grady (2020)
Scientific research facilitates acquisition of true knowledge, whose highest level is being able to examine scientific issues (Glickman et.al 2009). If knowledge constitutes a universal human property thus greatly impacting overall societal development and wellbeing, the key goal of science will clearly be the truth. Moreover, science’s credibility with the masses is reliant on upholding the highest standards of ethicality when conducting research. Sticking to such guidelines helps prevent deviation
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now