Indian Dance An Analysis Of The History Essay

Length: 5 pages Sources: 2 Subject: History - Asian Type: Essay Paper: #4611497 Related Topics: Dance, East Asian History, Worship, Islamic Art
Excerpt from Essay :

Indian Dance

An Analysis of the History and Origins of "Belly Dancing"

Indian Dance is described in the West as "belly dancing," but the name "belly dancing" does not do justice to the style of dance which the title conveys. Indian and Middle Eastern dance actually has more of a history to it than what the West views merely as a kind of erotic show. Described as "danse du ventre" by the French in the Victorian Age, the English translation has come to signify the Indian dance, which in Arabic is known as raqs sharqi or raqs baladi -- the former meaning "Dance of the Near East" and the latter meaning "Folk dance." Essentially, what Westerners have identified as "belly dancing" is actually the traditional folk dance of the Middle East and India. This paper will discuss the origins and history of Indian Dance, or "belly dancing," and show how it has come to be understood today.

Dance Myth

One common myth surrounding Indian "belly dancing" is that it grew out of a "birthing ritual" -- but as Marisa Wright states, there is actually little to no evidence for this claim. Rather, the promotion of such an origin actually came about due to the bad reputation that Indian "belly dancing" was receiving in the West at the beginning of the 20th century. In an attempt to justify what was being condemned as a provocative dance, some authors (and dancers) like Armen Ohanian described a "sacred dance" that was being corrupted by "the spirit of the Occident," transforming the "holy dance" into "the horrible danse du ventre, the 'hoochie-koochie'" (Wright). This attempt to legitimize the raqs sharqi worked to a certain extent -- but it did not change the nature of the "belly dance." The dance, as Wright shows, has always been (from the earliest time) a dance for men's entertainment: "All the evidence indicates belly dancing has been used to entertain, and particularly to entertain men, for hundreds of years" (Wright).

History is no less obliging when it comes to setting the record straight. In the Judeo-Christian narrative, there is the story of the Middle Eastern dancer Salome, whose provocative dance so enthralled Herod that he promised to give the girl anything she desired for recompense -- and, so the story goes, that is how John the Baptist lost his head (for she asked for it on a silver platter). Likewise, there are the writings of Martial, the Roman poet of the 1st century AD, who "commented on the female 'erotic ballerinas' who entertained visitors to Ephesus, Turkey, in the days of the Roman empire. They wore diaphanous robes and 'gyrated…to a steady beat'" (Wright). When one considers the actual style of dance that is involved in Indian "belly dancing," these reports should come as no surprise. In fact, the art of Indian dance appears "in Persian miniature paintings of the 12th and 13th centuries" (Wright) and can now be found in European museums: "Women dancing head downwards constantly appear in Persian pictures; several examples may be seen in the Victoria and Albert Museum, and the same subject often occurs on the valuable pencil-cases formerly made with so much taste and art in Persia" (Jusserand 118).

The fact of "belly dancing" as primarily a form of Indian and Middle Eastern entertainment is indisputable. Nonetheless, some similarities do exist between the dance and "traditional birthing" practices. Wright describes how in the 1960s Carolina Varga Dinicu, a "belly dancer," witnessed a traditional birth in southeast Asia: she recorded "first-hand how the women walked in a circle, executing belly rolls and flutters, with the mother alternately joining the circle or squatting" (Wright). The report that Dinicu produced afterwards made no attempt to locate "belly dancing's" origins in the birthing rite: it was merely acknowledging a similarity: "She makes it clear in her article that only two abdominal moves are used in the ritual," and Wright further points out that such moves make up only a fraction of the moves in the "belly dancing" repertoire.

The War over Modern Interpretation

Researcher Andrea Deagan, however, attempts to uncover the history of the dance by looking beyond India to the Aryan West and the ancient Egyptian rituals. Several stories coming from ancient Egypt relate creation myths, and Deagan notes how the "belly dance" has been identified in recent times as an expression of these myths.

...

Essentially, in the 60s and 70s when the dance really began to become popular (as a result of Bollywood films), a cultural debate in the West flared up in unison with the sexual revolution already underway and the Feminist movement gathering steam. "Belly dance" became the victim of political spin: depending upon how one viewed it said much about one's take on gender roles and norms. By explaining the significance of "belly dancing," one was making a judgment on the traditional role of womanhood.

Divorcing oneself from political taboo allows one to take an objective look at Indian dance without fear of offending either Feminist or traditionalist. Therefore, one may choose to consider Indian dance as an historical art form.

As Deagan notes, dance has always had a place in worship. The Greeks practiced dance in their annual worship ceremonies (out of which grew the theater). However, there is little recorded information concerning the nature of the raqs sharki. Wright observes that "with the advent of Islam, Muslim women were no longer allowed to dance in public and their place was taken by men" (Wright). This idea corresponds to the Asian and Middle Eastern sense of decency and modesty. Women, even today, are forbidden to dance in front of men publicly. Even in Egypt, where "belly dancing" was witnessed by Napoleon's army more than two centuries ago, the dance was viewed negatively. Wright states that in Egypt, however, the dance was performed by two types: a low type (which was performed in the streets and was often linked to prostitution), and a higher type (called "Almeh," which was performed by "educated women skilled in singing, dancing and poetry, who were well-paid for performing") (Wright). The low type mainly consisted of gypsies (and no self-respecting Egyptian would ever marry one); however, the high type "was considered an acceptable bride, provided she gave up her profession" (Wright). The point of this illustration of Egyptian mores regarding the dance is that even though the West (in the 20th century) has attempted to portray it as having cultural significance, the fact is that "belly dance has been debased and associated with prostitution in its countries of birth for many centuries. It is still not a 'respectable' dance in the Middle East." On the other hand, it has become iconic in India -- thanks, of course, to Bollywood cinema and the rise of the Bollywood sirens.

Since its rise in popularity in the 20th century, Indian dance, or "belly dancing," has taken on a new kind of significance. As in Egypt, there are those forms which are considered as part of a cultural narrative, and there are those types that are more sensual and erotically-driven for male spectators. The modern Western style of "belly dancing" is hardly, however, cultural. As Wright notes, it has its real origins in Hollywood: the very costume of the "belly dancer" -- "the bedleh, comes from Hollywood!" (Wright).

To recap, the origins of Indian dance, or "belly dancing," are somewhat obscure in that there is not much written information regarding the subject. However, from what little can be gathered, it appears that the dance's origin was for entertainment: even still, anthropologists tell of "many types of tribal dances performed…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

"Belly Dancing." Eijkhout.net. 2000. Web. 12 Oct 2011.

Deagan, Andrea. "In Search of the Origins of Dance." UNCW. Web. 12 Oct 2011.

Jusserand, J.J. English Wayfaring Life in the Middle Ages. Chatham, UK: W&J Mackay & Co. Ltd., 1950. Print.

Wright, Marisa. "Origins of Belly Dance." HubPages. 2009. Web. 12 Oct 2011.


Cite this Document:

"Indian Dance An Analysis Of The History" (2011, November 16) Retrieved July 31, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/indian-dance-an-analysis-of-the-history-52917

"Indian Dance An Analysis Of The History" 16 November 2011. Web.31 July. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/indian-dance-an-analysis-of-the-history-52917>

"Indian Dance An Analysis Of The History", 16 November 2011, Accessed.31 July. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/indian-dance-an-analysis-of-the-history-52917

Related Documents
History of Native Americans How Did Native
Words: 1489 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Native Americans Paper #: 94695317

History Of Native Americans How did Native responses to European activities affect the direction that colonies took? In 1585, Richard Hakluyt guaranteed that the economic potential of the North America is strong enough to provide the basis for the creation of a grand English commercial empire. He assured that the colonization by Englishmen would open profitable and productive new American markets. The next 178 years proved really beneficial for the Native Americans

Music and Dance in Indian Films in
Words: 2575 Length: 8 Pages Topic: History - Asian Paper #: 30617024

Music and Dance in Indian Films In sheer quantity, INDIA produces more movies than any other country in the world-over 900 feature-length films in at least 16 languages, according to a recent industry survey. This productivity is explained by several factors: the size of the Indian audience, low literacy rates, the limited diffusion of television in India, and well-developed export markets in both hemispheres. (http://worldfilm.about.com/cs/booksbolly/) In its historical development, India's film industry

Bollywood Indian Culture Is Clearly Demonstrative of
Words: 2436 Length: 8 Pages Topic: History - Asian Paper #: 66992384

Bollywood Indian culture is clearly demonstrative of a postcolonial culture. The post- colonial nature of the country, as well as its intrinsic diversity drastically effect the expressions of culture and the arts. One foundational example is the movie industry within the country. Nicknamed "Bollywood" by the west it is both an essential part of the new India and a challenge to the traditional and neo-traditional standards of the diverse culture. One

French and Indian War
Words: 4779 Length: 13 Pages Topic: Native Americans Paper #: 21094723

French and Indian War Cultural Analysis of French and Indian War The French and Indian War is considered to be part of Seven Years War that took place from 1756 till 1763. It is one of the most fierce and bloodiest battles that ever took place and in which thousands of people were killed. Participants of the war included French, Indians and British. It is believed that the war was fought in

Environmental History of Sandia Mountains New Mexico in Albuquerque...
Words: 1936 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Native Americans Paper #: 84146352

Sandia Mountains Environmental History of Sandia Mountains The view from the top of Sandia Peak is breathtaking. Showing off some of Nature's finest work, the Tramway glides along the cable climbing the rugged Sandia Mountains presenting spectacular views of the Rio Grande Valley and nearby Sandia Crest. Even though you're just a few miles from Albuquerque, the 15 minute tram ride has taken you far away from the everyday world. As your

Global Business Cultural Analysis
Words: 8186 Length: 25 Pages Topic: History - Asian Paper #: 23504537

business culture and expansion trends that exist for American companies in India. The paper focuses on answering the following questions: 1. What are the major elements and dimensions of culture in this region? 2. How are these elements and dimensions integrated by local conducting business in the nation? 3. How do both of the above items compare with U.S. culture and business? 4. What are the implications for U.S.