Job Website Evaluation Essay

Length: 6 pages Sources: 4 Subject: Education - Computers Type: Essay Paper: #11006677 Related Topics: Aesthetics, Job Description, Bmw, Web Site Design
Excerpt from Essay :

Job Sites

The three job sites that I evaluated were Monster.ca, Eluta.ca and Workopolis.com. These are three major job sites in Canada. Workopolis and Monster're older and are more popular in terms of traffic (Alexa.com, see graph), while the newer Eluta trails by quite some distance at this point. The graph shows their Alexa ranking for Canada, obviously with the lower number being better.

These three sites were evaluated on the basis of their content and user experience. The three sites were tested through randomly searching jobs in finance here in Toronto. For the user, the quality of the jobs is another proxy that can be looked at -- the best sites will have the best jobs. There are a number of dimensions along which the sites can be evaluate -- their functionality, their aesthetics and pragmatic considerions. If it doesn't look good, people will be turned off quickly. If the site does not function as intended, then people will quickly leave. If there are too many barriers to getting things done, the user may also decide to leave. Lastly, if the user cannot execute on what they came to the site for, they may not return. So these are the three major dimensions on which these three websites were evaluated, something that has been mirrored in other studies, like Douglas & Mills' study (2004) on Caribbean tourism websites. These factors have been demonstrated to be critical to fostering repeat visits and therefore ultimately for revenue generation. As Bai, Law and Wen (2008) note:

"Results indicate that website quality has a direct and positive impact on customer satisfaction and that customer satisfaction has a direct and positive impact on purchase intentions. While the influence of website quality on purchase intentions exists, customer satisfaction does significantly mediate this effect."

Background Concepts

The aesthetics of a website affect the user experience. Sites that look good will be perceived as being superior, even if that is not the case. If it looks like it was built on a 1996 AOL kit, that would have to be considered negative. Even finance grads like things that look nice. Knight and Pandir (2004) note that key variables in the study of website aesthetics are "complexity, interestingness and pleasingness."

Functionality is another key element in the effectiveness of a website. The site must function as intended. This is a basic prerequisite for any Internet site, but job sites I particular must meet this condition. First, job sites will record your personal information from your CV, so trusting the site is important and a lack of functionality will betray trust. Furthermore, people using the site will be active every day, so the site must function at all times. Code must be perfect, and when something goes awry, it must be repaired immediately. Ease of use, multimedia and rich content are three variables relating to functionality (Zhou, 2009).

Finally, pragmatic considerations are also important in evaluating a website. Every website has a function, and for a website to be considered effective it needs to fulfill that function. In this case, the sites are designed to bring together job seekers with companies that have jobs. Thus, the number of jobs on each site will be evaluated, along with the fit of the jobs to the target market (a finance grad) and the ease with which an application for the position can be filed.

Workopolis

The first site to be evaluated is Workopolis, which is owned in part by Torstar and has a nationwide presence. Aesthetically, the site is a bit dated. There is a generic search bar at the top, two colours, and the eye is not really drawn anywhere. This does not score highly, but nor is it offensive.

In terms of functionality, there are some

...

A basic search for "Accounting/Finance" not only failed to give the choice between one or the other, it failed to give me a choice to narrow down my location. I'm not looking for a job in Calgary or Winnipeg but that's what came up. Furthermore, the search results are confined to a narrow band at the bottom of my screen, so that I have to scroll the screen down to reach them. Most of the screen is taken up with a banner ad at the top, another one down the right hand side and some other ad in a middle banner that chews up all the prime on-screen real estate to tell me that I'm looking at accounting and finance jobs. This is the dated design getting in the way of functionality. Once I find the button for advanced search, I am confronted with prompts for four types of key words. That's a lot of work for no marginal increase in functionality. I entered finance as a keyword, Toronto for location but otherwise left it open, and got a popup window for my effort. This barrier detracts from the website. I received a selection of random finance jobs in Toronto, all that I asked for. I then embarked on a finely-tuned search for a "Senior Budget Analyst." I received a wider range of jobs than I was expecting, but did get a selection of Senior Financial Analyst positions. These were sorted by date, which is good for me if I come back tomorrow to search the jobs again.

From a pragmatic perspective, it is apparent that the initial search is all but useless because there was no opportunity to tailor it to my needs. I am not logged in, so I can only email the job to myself, which is a start. Presumably with a membership I would be able to apply directly using a CV that I've uploaded. I clicked on a position offered at Bell. Again, the aesthetics get in the way -- I have a giant banner repeating back to me the title of the position and employer. I get a giant ad from Bell as well. I have to scroll down to get any useful information about the job -- another barrier. The job, ultimately, has nothing to do with Senior Budget Analyst, so it's a dead link to me.

Overall, Workopolis suffers from dated design, mediocre functionality, multiple barriers to getting what I want, and it is pretty hit or miss as to whether many of the jobs are even applicable.

Monster.ca

Aesthetically, Monster is as dated as Workopolis. I should seek work as a web designer as apparently we lack them here in Canada. I immediately see a search box taking up half my screen, and goodness knows what that is at the bottom -- photos and links to articles maybe? It's not obvious. But there's a lot of it. It just goes on and on, rather excessive for a home page. At the top we lose a full-length section at the top to ask me if I want to keep English as my language. Mais non! Look, I'm not logging on from a francophone or bilingual part of the country, we can make this question less disruptive to my site experience.

From a functional perspective, my initial search query let me enter Toronto, which was nice, but after telling me there were 456 such jobs, it didn't show me any. I had to scroll off the screen, a pointless barrier used to shove an ad in my face. The entire top third of the screen is also ads. When I tried to go back to the homepage, I got hit with a popup. It would not let me leave the popup and when I clicked the 'x' on the popup I ended up having gone nowhere -- I was on the search results with the back button my on browser blocked out. The website just gave me the middle finger when I asked it to perform a simple task like going back so I could re-try my search. I'm done with this site.

From a pragmatic perspective, Monster.ca threw the most absurd, unprofessional barriers at me, leaving me with a very rudimentary search. You can click on those, but I need to be able to move freely around the website. The jobs that did come up show as ads first, making me scroll down. There is a brief description of the position, but really they're not doing anything to sell me. Also, I never was able to search for my specific position. And I'm annoyed with this website.

Eluta.ca

This website opens with a simple, clean, Google-esque homepage. Functionally, this is the same page as Monster but with a professional design. After the first basic search, the design travels back in time to 1997, and the page is mostly ads and dead space. The positions are listed in really basic font…it just doesn't look good.

Clicking on a job pops up a new tab with the job description -- one fewer click than the other two websites. The new tab doesn't look great, but it has all the pertinent information. Also, I can leave that…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Bai, B., Law, R. & Wen, I. (2008) The impact of website quality on customer satisfaction and purchase intention: Evidence from Chinese online visitors. International Journal of Hospitality Management.. Vol. 27 (3) 391-402.

Douglas, A. & Mills, J. (2008). Applying a structural equation model approach to evaluating national tourism organization websites in the Caribbrean. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing. Vol. 17 (2-3) 269-293.

Knight, J. & Pandir, M. (2004). An experimental aesthetics approach to evaluating websites. Aesthetic Approaches to Human-Computer Interaction. Retrieved March 23, 2014 from http://ojs.statsbiblioteket.dk/index.php/daimipb/article/viewFile/7129/6092#page=27

Zhou, Z. (2009). Evaluating websites using a practical quality model. DeMontfort University. Retrieved March 23, 2014 from https://www.dora.dmu.ac.uk/xmlui/bitstream/handle/2086/3422/ZihouZhou_Thesis-Final.pdf?sequence=1


Cite this Document:

"Job Website Evaluation" (2014, March 24) Retrieved May 7, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/job-website-evaluation-185827

"Job Website Evaluation" 24 March 2014. Web.7 May. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/job-website-evaluation-185827>

"Job Website Evaluation", 24 March 2014, Accessed.7 May. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/job-website-evaluation-185827

Related Documents
Job Performance Evaluation When It Comes to
Words: 811 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 40858899

Job Performance Evaluation When it comes to the measurement of performance a common method used is the rating scale. However there are a wide range of considerations when it comes to the type of scale to be used, the source that will provide the ratings on the scale and the ethical and legal issues that surround the scale and the usage of its results. The paper is an evaluation of a

Job Ad and Orientation Program
Words: 1200 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 52589804

Seasonal Lobby Manager Reports to: Front office manager Position summary: Mainly responsible to guarantee Front Office shifts run effectively and efficiently, offering superb guest service, aiding all Front Office staff as well as always maintaining a professional, calm environment. Trains and assesses four 'Lobby Hosts/Hostesses' and assigns and supervises duty roster for his/her Lobby Support team. Job duties also encompass maintaining payroll records' and ensuring timely movement of each guest through the

Hospitality Management Website Evaluation
Words: 810 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Sports - College Paper #: 28660373

Corporate Websites Aramark Aramark is an institutional services provider. It runs three different divisions -- food, facilities and uniforms. Aramark serves four main industries -- education, healthcare, sports & entertainment, and business & government. They sell all three services to each of these four customers, but likely have this divisional structure to reflect that there are unique needs for each customer type. There are many different jobs available to hospitality graduates at

Job Satisfaction in Nursing Related to Generational Differences
Words: 2329 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 5248383

Job Satisfaction in Nursing Levels of Job satisfaction in nursing in relation to generational differences The contemporary society has suffered an acute shortage of nurses within the public and the government sponsored hospitals. Indeed the shortage is so intense that it was and still is viewed as one of the impediments that stand on the way of fully experiencing the positives of the Obama Healthcare program that was recently introduced. This has

Job Task Analysis -- Customer Service Job
Words: 625 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 55189988

Job Task Analysis -- Customer Service Job Task Analysis Customer Service Position Customer Service Location: Corporate Office shifts, 8-5, 4-12 Sat/Sun -- 9am-6pm Full Time Hourly (Entry 10.00/hour, range to $14.80/hour) Position Objective Call Center Agent Preparation / Prerequisites High School Diploma or Equivalent Excellent Interpersonal Skills Working Knowledge of Basic Computer Operations and MS Word and Excel Must pass a background and drug screen Organizational Skills Ability to Multi-Task effectively Clear speaking voice and good command of English Flexible Schedule Negotiating Skills Typing skills of 25-30 wpm or greater One year

Job Analysis From Undercover Boss
Words: 1021 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Human Resources Paper #: 28063944

Job Analysis from 'Undercover Boss' From the 9th episode, "Subway" of Undercover Boss -- Season 2, two jobs have been identified: Store Manager and Chief Development Officer. In the episode, Subway's Chief Development Officer (CDO), Dan Fretman goes undercover in order to assist with the development of Subway stores. The position of Store Manager in the episode involves 4 persons who work alongside Dan. Job Analysis For Chief Development Officer Position The central part played