The Morality Of Surrogate Mothers Term Paper

Home
/
Topic
/
Other
/
Surrogate
/
The Morality of Surrogate Mothers Term Paper

Verified Document

100% Human Written

Related Topics:

Mother Autonomy Women Personal

Open Document Cite Document

Two Opposing Ethical Theories of Surrogacy

Payne (2018) supports surrogacy by demonstrating that the woman's autonomy should be the determinant for whether she wants to become a surrogate or not. Autonomy is the right to determine what is right for an individual based on their understanding and willingness. Therefore, when it comes to surrogacy, the woman should be allowed to decide what she wants. Due to the nature of surrogacy in other areas where the intended couple pays the surrogate mother, most people tend to view this as the commercialization of surrogacy. With commercialization, people believe women are forced into the trade by other third-party players. However, Payne (2018), argues for the women who opt for surrogacy by demonstrating they are doing so out of their willingness to assist others. We cannot take away the autonomy of surrogate mothers because we believe they are being paid. Everyone should have the right to determine how they wish to live their lives. Therefore, we cannot in good authority stand up and say surrogate mothers should be denied the opportunity to...

The decision to become a surrogate is a personal one, and it is only the surrogate mother who knows for sure if they are willing or not. We, as the onlookers, cannot determine this for the surrogate mother.

Surrogate mothers can want to assist either a sister or a friend, and they offer their womb to them. The underlying issue is...

…pushes us to look at surrogacy from the perspective of relationships and not from an ethical perspective.

By looking at the relationships that are subverted in commercial surrogacy, we can see that the surrogate mother is left to nurse her wounds while the intended parents leave feeling happy. They now have a child. The relationships formed between the intended parents and the surrogate mother are broken immediately after birth resulting in unhappiness for the surrogate mother. While most people in the deal are happy, including the surrogate mother, she still has feelings or loss both for the child and the broken relationship she had with the intended parents (Krause, 2018). Therefore, the commercialization of surrogacy should be looked at based on the risks involved…

Sources used in this document:

References

Krause, F. (2018). Caring relationships: Commercial surrogacy and the ethical relevance of the other. Care in Healthcare, 87-107.

Payne, J. G. (2018). Autonomy in altruistic surrogacy, conflicting kinship grammars and intentional multilineal kinship. Reproductive biomedicine & society online, 7, 66-75.

Cite this Document:

APA 7th Edition MLA 9th Edition Chicago 17th Edition

Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Essay

Surrogate Parenting

Words: 904 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Surrogate Parents For many infertile couples, the assistance of a surrogate mother represents one last hope for becoming a genetic parent. They thus turn to surrogate mothers, or women who bear children for couples who cannot become parents through normal pregnancy and childbirth (Gentry). With careful preparation on both sides, surrogate parenting can be a viable option for couples to conceive a child and add to their family. For many critics, the

Essay

Women Choose to Become Surrogate

Words: 2177 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Some surrogates know the couple, and volunteer their services. Others do it simply because they want to help a couple that is childless. Four authors continue, "One woman said, ' I wanted to do something that was out of the ordinary and that made me a little bit special'" (Dooley, McCarthy, Garanis-Papadatos, and Dalla-Yorgia 57). In other cases, the surrogate may be a friend or relative of the couple,

Essay

The Morality of Surrogate Mothers

Words: 392 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

Surrogate MotherhoodSurrogate motherhood is thought to be a treatment option for infertile mothers or an alternative to adoption (Bagan-Kurluta, 2017). At its face value, surrogacy seems like an attractive alternative for the infertile couple and the surrogate mother as all parties will benefit from the arrangement. The infertile couple will get their long-desired biologically related child, and the surrogate mother will receive much-needed money when paid to carry the pregnancy

Essay

Patient Rights and Informed Consent the Relevant

Words: 1302 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Patient Rights and Informed Consent The relevant legal issues at stake in this case are those related to the question of whether Mr. Jones is indeed incompetent and if Mr. Jones is indeed incompetent then what is the authority that should be assigned to the surrogate daughter of the patient in this case. The hospital physician and staff must avoid legal liability and ensure that they are in adherence to

Essay

Individual Case Analysis Terri Schiavo

Words: 1880 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Ethics The Terri Schiavo case was an unusual incident where a person who should have been removed from life support long ago was sustained due to federal and public intervention. The case instigates moral and ethical questions of decision to end life as well as the limits of autonomy in surrogate decision making. Torke et al. (2008) argue that guardian judgment is often used as decision-making when a patient lacks the